Live data from Hacker News

Introducing Google Cast for audio

chrome.blogspot.com

161–170 of 172 posts

Re: Introducing Google Cast for audio

#161

Note the lack of spotify support. It's turning into a bit of a showdown between players like google cast and spotify connect. There will definitely be a small market in building devices which can serve as bridges between the standards.

I'm not sore what Spotify gets out of this - why bother pushing your own protocol, why not just make your music work as many places as possible?

They're probably looking to nurture some vendor lock-in

Re: Introducing Google Cast for audio

#162

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Google Play Music supports this. Upload your audio files; stream from anywhere. No subscription needed.

emphasis here being on local music collection. I don't want to have to upload a huge library of music just to stream it to my local network, where I already have the music on my hard drive.

There are other apps that allow you to stream your local music if that's what you want to do (AllCast, BubbleUPnP, etc).

But I've always wondered about this argument - Why wouldn't you put your local music library on Google music? It's free and means you've got access to your library everywhere. I could understand before they had matching that uploading 100+GB of music is probably not desirable, but it now even big libraries are fully uploaded in a day or so.

Re: Introducing Google Cast for audio

#163

>"Google Cast streams your music directly from the cloud instead of from your phone, so you won’t lose any sound quality." Huh??? This is almost _never_ the case in my opinion, especially when using popular cloud services for music playback. Pretty sure I just had to nerf a high quality .WAV file to a .WMV 20 minutes ago before I could even upload it to google music.

You converted an LPCM Audio file to a Windows Media Video file to upload to Google Music?

Re: Introducing Google Cast for audio

#164
post #78

Wow, it seems like this will take a while to come out and I didn't see any word on pricing. A good alternative to this is a Beep. Beep sells devices that plug into any speakers audio jack to let you stream music from your phone. What's better is that it also syncs up multiple units so you can have your music in sync across your house. We've used them in our office a few times and love them. https://www.thisisbeep.com

I don't think it's been officially announced yet, but at least one of the reports on the new Google Cast stuff, and a dev who claims to work on one of the partner apps commenting on reddit, suggest that the audio cast stuff will synced audio across multiple devices.

This would be a killer feature if true.

Re: Introducing Google Cast for audio

#165
Surprised no one mentioned Mopidy[0] in the thread. From their github:

Mopidy is an extensible music server that plays music from local disk, Spotify, SoundCloud, Google Play Music, and more. You edit the playlist from any phone, tablet, or computer using a range of MPD and web clients.

[0]:https://github.com/mopidy/mopidy

Re: Introducing Google Cast for audio

#166
post #134

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The problem is with this part of the statement: "Google Cast Ready speakers pull content directly from the cloud, so you’ll get the best audio quality" Pulling content from the cloud doesn't not mean you'll get "the best" audio quality.

Streaming over the internet will yield better quality than a Bluetooth stream which compresses the music. The bits that hit the speaker are as high quality as the source material.

Right, that would then be "better than bluetooth", not "the best technology". In particular, the network induces latency and buffering problems.

Re: Introducing Google Cast for audio

#167

Bluetooth speakers: Unbelievable but they also stream sound which is only locally on mobile phone. Why do all Googlers think that everybody in the whole world has good wifi everywhere?

BT Speakers typically use A2DP, which sounds horrid. Recompressing already compressed audio is not a path towards goodness.

That said, reading up on A2DP, it seems that A2DP supports higher quality audio streams, but I have yet to see anyone advertise such in their products.

Re: Introducing Google Cast for audio

#170
post #151
post #136

Is it just me or has anyone else been waiting for multi-room audio, I don't understand why I can't 'cast' to two locations at once? Seems like they'd take the Sonos market pretty easily if/when implemented

As a recent Sonos convert, I really think that they are going to be hard to catch in terms of nailing so many aspects of the user experience. Not least of which is how good the hardware (esp the Play:1 speakers) sound and look. I Have to admit how surprised I was to learn that the same company that made those janky wall controller systems a decade ago is now the second largest speaker company in the world.

My only issue is the price, the only thing it gives over any other implementation is the multi room aspect, as soon as a company like Google bakes it in to their already established platform I don't see them selling many units
Post reply on HN