Live data from Hacker News

Apple Pay

apple.com

161–170 of 225 posts

Re: Apple Pay

#161
post #53

Japan has a flourishing NFC payment ecosystem, and it's strange it's completely left out on this announcement. Would they have given early access and bundled the Suica app for instance, they could have boasted millions of users from the get go. I wonder if the upcoming API is even compatible with the Felica standard, but that would be a weird thing to do.

It was left out of the announcement the same way Xerox was left out of the claim that Apple invented the mouse.

Re: Apple Pay

#162
post #6

I really hope this doesn't end up fragmenting the NFC payments space. Only Apple Pay is accepted in one place, and only Google Wallet is accepted in another. Both of these technologies work with contactless card readers, let's just stick with that.

IDK, as long as it's NFC and the terminals have firmware that can get upgraded to support additional standards, they could make it work.

I live in a country where banks tend to come up with similar payment technologies at the same time; one example is the Chipknip vs Chipper, both bank card technologies for putting pre-paid amounts of cash on the card to be used to pay without having to enter a PIN or the longish time it took for a regular card payment to process. Didn't take long for the payment terminals to support both platforms.

ATM we've got a similar fight going on; a few banks have contactless payments now, but one bank is going for NFC payments via (very specific models of) smartphones (Samsung Galaxy models; I gathered they're using an already deprecated API/technology for that). But the same argument applies; both technologies use NFC, so all it needs to work is a firmware upgrade.

Re: Apple Pay

#163

No-contact payment is exactly the kind of secure piece of engineering we needed. Especially after the iCloud debacle. /s

Actually, this has been working great in other first-world countries for years.

The U.S. is one of the last places to get this.

Re: Apple Pay

#164
post #56
post #50

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The cynic in me winces when thinking of the mess all the banks and interested companies would make trying to get together and build a payment standard. Just look at the terrible mess of stuff like OFX.

Bitcoin might be a way around this. Also it might not be necessary for the involved parties to get together. They could release different protocols. And then the lesser used will be forgotten (like gopher is forgotten today) and the more frequent used will survive (like http has survived). Update: Why the downvotes?

Well, the point of those payment systems is to make money out of fees and basically control the whole system. You cannot do that with decentralized payment methods.

Re: Apple Pay

#165

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Google doesn't cause bloatware, Carriers and Handset makers do. One of the many consequences of OSS, people can fork and bloat to their heart's content. Also, I haven't had one issue with software updates on my Nexus 5 (which indeed comes bloatware free). If I recall correctly, wasn't the iOS7 update a shit show?

If I recall correctly, wasn't the iOS7 update a shit show? Not sure what you're referring to. I'm happily using iOS7 on a iPhone 4 (a 4 year old phone) to this day.

http://www.usatoday.com/story/tech/2013/10/17/apple-ios-7-pr...

Re: Apple Pay

#166
post #53

Japan has a flourishing NFC payment ecosystem, and it's strange it's completely left out on this announcement. Would they have given early access and bundled the Suica app for instance, they could have boasted millions of users from the get go. I wonder if the upcoming API is even compatible with the Felica standard, but that would be a weird thing to do.

It was left out of the announcement the same way Xerox was left out of the claim that Apple invented the mouse.

They didn't say "invented", they said "introduced."

Re: Apple Pay

#167

Earlier quoted context omitted.

If I recall correctly, wasn't the iOS7 update a shit show? Not sure what you're referring to. I'm happily using iOS7 on a iPhone 4 (a 4 year old phone) to this day.

http://www.usatoday.com/story/tech/2013/10/17/apple-ios-7-pr...

Fair enough. I didn't have any of these problems. I would say that every Mac OS update ever has generated a bunch of traffic on user forums as well, though it's always difficult to say what percentage of the user base were affected.

Re: Apple Pay

#168
post #128

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Looks like Apple's commission is ~15-25 BPS for participating banks (from those banks): "The biggest “surprise” over last 2 months is that Apple has squeezed 15-25bps from the 5-6 participating banks at launch (C, BAC, COF, JPM, Amex and perhaps WFC)." http://blog.starpointllp.com/blog/?p=3855

BPS?

Basis points, or 1/100th of a percent

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Basis_point

Re: Apple Pay

#169

Earlier quoted context omitted.

You might not remember this, but that's exactly what originally happened. You had CompuServe mail, and Prodigy mail, and AOL mail, and any number of internal mail systems at different companies. There was not a single mail format or agreed upon address space. Getting mail from one system to another was a huge pain.

That's not how it "originally happened." Perhaps you're too young to remember the days before AOL and CompuServe, but email was being used more than a decade before those services. When those services started bringing messagint to consumers, yes, they had some proprietary set-ups but that was not how it "originally happened" -- that was a short-term glitch in the much longer and more open history of email.

I am old enough to remember. Actually, because my mother worked at a university in engineering while I was in another city going to university, I could email her. It was crazy!!! My bestie and I then tried to figure out how it worked, and spammed the entire college with a "Happy Holidays Laidies" email. (It was a simpler time).

That said, no one else was using it back then unless you worked military or university. Once it started to commercialize, then you had all the walled gardens. So although you're technically correct, BBS's were still the majority of the way we were connecting back then.

Re: Apple Pay

#170

ApplePay is only on iPhone 6. This means that the availability rate for this technology will get into (tens of) millions in a couple of years, based on the update cycle with the phone carriers. Realistically we're talking 2-4 yrs. Plenty of time for providers to get acquainted with the technology and to integrate it into their retail systems. For developers it would be interesting to see how the API looks like and if…

> For developers it would be interesting to see how the API looks like and if it will be available at all in any shape or form (which I doubt actually).

Well it's already available through Stripe: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8292026 - so I'm pretty sure there's good news ahead :)

more info: https://developer.apple.com/apple-pay/

Post reply on HN