Live data from Hacker News

Una GPS smart watch – Repairable, USB-C charging, developer-friendly

unawatch.com

161–170 of 199 posts

Re: Una GPS smart watch – Repairable, USB-C charging, developer-friendly

#161

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Yeah, and drop your iPhone, in a ruggedized case, into 3 inches of bath water for 5 seconds from a height of one foot and then realize apple's IP68 claim is laughable.

Yes, this happens to people all the time. The seals that keep water out degrade over time. New phones are generally ok, but heat, dirt, detergent/salt in water, etc. wear them down until they are not water resistant anymore. This is also why almost none of the manufacturers will fix the device under warranty when there is water damage, despite the IP rating. Even Apple themselvers recommend against submerging and iPh…

> The water resistance in these phones exist so that the phone hopefully survives when they get wet accidentally

So accidentally dropping the phone in a bath or toilet for a few seconds doesnt count as that?

Re: Una GPS smart watch – Repairable, USB-C charging, developer-friendly

#163
post #157

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Cue to younger me that discovered the difference between water resistant and water proof when I found out that my "7 melodies electronic watch" didn't survive after a few minutes in the swimming pool. Will the UNA hint us with a little bit of fog on the window?

I too destroyed my "7 melodies electronic watch" back in the 80's by taking it for a swim at the beach .. man, that was so disappointing. Did get me on the CASIO Data Bank train, though ..

If you ever get into this situation again, you can rinse it with distilled water to remove corrosive/conducting residues, then let it dry.

Re: Una GPS smart watch – Repairable, USB-C charging, developer-friendly

#164

> "UNA is currently a non-submersible device due to its innovative modular design. So, swimming is not something we offer as an activity, nor do we advise it. UNA is IPX5 rated, which means it is splash & showerproof to a high degree." If I had a dollar for every time some project that was ipx5 rated failed after getting caught in the rain one too many times...I'd have enough to buy another Garmin Fenix.

I got all the way to the order screen thinking it was IP68 because my eyes scanned over "UNA features a universal IP68 rated usb-c charging cable" and thought the port was IP68.

The CABLE is IP68? But the watch is IPX5? This is just up to the line of criminally deceptive false advertising. It's not criminal because the fine print, but what an absolute loss of trust. They know what they're doing. IPX5 is a no-go, which they know, which is why they're being so deceptive.

Re: Una GPS smart watch – Repairable, USB-C charging, developer-friendly

#165

> "UNA is currently a non-submersible device due to its innovative modular design. So, swimming is not something we offer as an activity, nor do we advise it. UNA is IPX5 rated, which means it is splash & showerproof to a high degree." If I had a dollar for every time some project that was ipx5 rated failed after getting caught in the rain one too many times...I'd have enough to buy another Garmin Fenix.

I mean, they're from Scotland, the watch would have to be pretty water resistant to survive more than one day...

Re: Una GPS smart watch – Repairable, USB-C charging, developer-friendly

#166

> "UNA is currently a non-submersible device due to its innovative modular design. So, swimming is not something we offer as an activity, nor do we advise it. UNA is IPX5 rated, which means it is splash & showerproof to a high degree." If I had a dollar for every time some project that was ipx5 rated failed after getting caught in the rain one too many times...I'd have enough to buy another Garmin Fenix.

Cue to younger me that discovered the difference between water resistant and water proof when I found out that my "7 melodies electronic watch" didn't survive after a few minutes in the swimming pool. Will the UNA hint us with a little bit of fog on the window?

Or middle-aged me swimming with my "10 ATM water resist" ~$400 Hamilton watch...

Re: Una GPS smart watch – Repairable, USB-C charging, developer-friendly

#167
post #8

I really want to like this watch. Price is certainly right, and it does all of the things I'd want out of a Garmin or Apple Watch Ultra. But what problem does this solve for me? In the Apple Watch use case, a replaceable battery would be nice. But in contrast to Garmin, I've never replaced a Garmin because the battery wouldn't hold charge anymore. I've never broken a screen (if one has a habit of that, Garmin and App…

For me, I want an open API I can pull my data from. Last I checked, you have to be a business to use Garmin's API. Apple certainly doesn't let you. My goal is to have a cron that runs on my homelab that pulls my health data into a DB I own, from various sources, and visualize it in Grafana.

I ran into the same issue when building ProForta.com. My solution was to build a companion app that pulls data (including Garmin) via Health Connect. Right now, it seems that every hardware platform from Oura to Garmin is trying to build their moat around user's data. That's not OK - users need access to the combination of all their data to derive meaningful health benefits. Thats the guiding principle behind lifecare.id (https://lifecare.id)

Re: Una GPS smart watch – Repairable, USB-C charging, developer-friendly

#168

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It's just a collation of sleep-end RHR/HRV. It's completely trivial and many manufacturers do this correctly; both are extremely reliable predictors of recovery metrics. Garmin has absolutely shitty sleep tracking but it doesn't matter; any wearable more or less nowadays can get static heart rate correct, leading to more or less accurate recovery metrics. "Collect every paper you can find on RHR/HRV/etc. recovery met…

Do you have a particular hardware sensor requirement needed to clone the body battery function? I’m interested in developing this too but always resisted getting a smartwatch due to privacy concerns. If there’s something available that’s Gadgetbridge compatible I’d be very interested.

Good news; I'm gifting you with the fruits of AI, that has collated 200+ papers on the topic. I know, I know; this is generous.

https://github.com/catigula/recovery

Re: Una GPS smart watch – Repairable, USB-C charging, developer-friendly

#169

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It's just a collation of sleep-end RHR/HRV. It's completely trivial and many manufacturers do this correctly; both are extremely reliable predictors of recovery metrics. Garmin has absolutely shitty sleep tracking but it doesn't matter; any wearable more or less nowadays can get static heart rate correct, leading to more or less accurate recovery metrics. "Collect every paper you can find on RHR/HRV/etc. recovery met…

How does HRV predict stuff like this ?

Good news; I'm gifting you with the fruits of AI, that has collated 200+ papers on the topic. I know, I know; this is generous.

https://github.com/catigula/recovery

Post reply on HN