Live data from Hacker News

Omarchy Is Not A Distro

abyss.fish

161–170 of 186 posts

Re: Omarchy Is Not A Distro

#161
post #43

We seem to have arrived at a set of assumptions that states that if a large number of people like something that we don’t, or don’t subscribe to some cultural norms that we doggedly adhere to, then there has to be something sinister afoot. The out of box experience with Omarchy is highly functional, aesthetically pleasing and challenges users to lean more on keyboard shortcuts than they’d typically be used to. That’s…

What trends were making Linux harder to adopt or less culturally relevant?

Re: Omarchy Is Not A Distro

#162
post #93

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> then there has to be something sinister afoot. Not sinister, but just a simple strategy of a business to increase sales of his products (such as hey.com) as well as pushing his personal preferences (grok) to younger audience masquerading as being done for public good. It is just repulsive for people who see through this. But I think it is an OK business strategy which may be somewhat successful. Values of DHH and h…

>Not sinister, but just a simple strategy of a business to increase sales of his products (such as hey.com) as well as pushing his personal preferences (grok) to younger audience masquerading as being done for public good. He has said multiple times Omarchy is his distro he designed for himself with his personal defaults. He's not masquerading anything, and what he's doing is being done for the public good, he's shar…

[deleted]

Re: Omarchy Is Not A Distro

#163
post #158

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Quality in general seems to be going downhill, too. Frequently the desktop app and the safari extension won't be in sync and missing a recently added password, or doesn't show up on my other devices hours later. I still have no idea how the extension vs desktop app actually work together, or if they do at all. Sometimes 1password (safari extension) is "locked" - but the desktop app isn't locked? and No amount of clic…

Wait, it even needs an extension for Safari? I'm using Strongbox (uses a KeePass-compatible database) which integrates into Apple's AutoFill API and appears automatically in all input fields - just like Keychain. No extension needed.

Maybe that’s why I get the 1Password UI _and_ the native password selection UI :-/

Re: Omarchy Is Not A Distro

#165
I really like Linux, but it's incredibly fragmented. The fragmentation can be seen as part of the allure of Linux (make it your own, use whatever you want, may the best software win, etc).

As I've gained experience (and maybe some wisdom), I've come to find the fragmentation a huge turn off. I've grown more and more fond of the BSD world. You install an operating system. You can learn the system and it doesn't change (much). It feels like you can accrue knowledge that doesn't become irrelevant every six months.

Re: Omarchy Is Not A Distro

#168
post #100

Earlier quoted context omitted.

No Linux distribution offers a good out-of-the-box experience with anything outside of XFCE, GNOME, or KDE Plasma. On the other end, these alternative WMs lack all of the shell features that people expect from a desktop experience. I run regular Arch with Niri and Noctalia Shell, which is based on Quick Shell. It is a pretty solid experience. But even with Quick Shell, which has taken a lot of the pain out of closing…

CachyOS (an Arch distro) has done something kid of like this, where it bundles eg a default setup for hyprland and several other desktop environments. It’s not perfect, but I like their model a lot. I mean it’s very Arch to be able to choose whatever you want, but nice to have some opinionated defaults.

CachyOS is not a distro. It's just an opinionated Arch spin

Re: Omarchy Is Not A Distro

#169
post #100

Earlier quoted context omitted.

No Linux distribution offers a good out-of-the-box experience with anything outside of XFCE, GNOME, or KDE Plasma. On the other end, these alternative WMs lack all of the shell features that people expect from a desktop experience. I run regular Arch with Niri and Noctalia Shell, which is based on Quick Shell. It is a pretty solid experience. But even with Quick Shell, which has taken a lot of the pain out of closing…

>My question for people is whether their objection has to do with Omarchy itself or with the person or people behind it both because as I said there's no distinction with a project like this, and I'll give you a technical example for this. The manual which I briefly read through says this on the monitor configuration: "Omarchy assumes you're running on a 2x-capable retina-class display by default[...] It's what you'd…

Monitors with that PPI have a market share of >98% among people this is targeting. The Apple using crowd.

Re: Omarchy Is Not A Distro

#170
post #67

By your reasoning of what is or is not a distribution, Ubuntu is not a distribution. After all, it’s just opinionated Debian. The vast majority of distributions are, by your logic, not distributions. I’m okay with this, but that isn’t how the word is commonly used.

ubuntu has its own packages from Debian and a different release cycle

And surprise so does Omarchy
Post reply on HN