Live data from Hacker News

I am stepping down as the CEO of Mastodon

blog.joinmastodon.org

161–170 of 497 posts

Re: I am stepping down as the CEO of Mastodon

#161
post #2

What happened last summer? (I couldn't find anything on it)

I'm not entirely sure, I wonder if that is related to the "fight" between fans of ActivityPub and fans of Bluesky AtProto where he was personally involved.

Because both protocols can actually interface together, we had people on both side of the 2 networks talking to each other in the same thread (which is truly impressive when you think about it)

https://mastodon.social/@Gargron/115074431325055303

Re: I am stepping down as the CEO of Mastodon

#162
post #145

Mastodon is great. It's just unfortunate that the number of people is on the low side.

I see bots that import from/link to other sources, bots that are clearly someone's attempts at automation. Then "classic" ad spam bots and countless porn/drawn lewd content profiles and even instances that contain nothing else. Normal people are getting buried beneath all of this trash and if you actually want to have some conversations you need to either look up by particular tags or comment in trending posts.

> Normal people are getting buried beneath all of this trash

This is the entire opposite of my experience on Mastodon. I get buried in trash on Twitter, any semi-popular tweet ends up with hundreds of bots and racial slurs. I see none of that on Mastodon

Really curious how you ended up in a situation like that.

Re: I am stepping down as the CEO of Mastodon

#163

Earlier quoted context omitted.

In addition to that: With money you can always buy popularity easily, but converting popularity into money is hard work at least. I'd even say that turning fame into significant wealth is an art only few have truly mastered.

> With money you can always buy popularity easily I don’t know if Elon Musk is an example or a counter-example. Maybe both?

Sadly, I suspect he's reasonably successful at being popular amongst the people he wants to be popular with.

Taylor Swift is super popular in the demographic she plays to, while being unpopular with, say, techno or metal fans.

Musk is super popular in the outspoken nazi demographic. (And has fallen way way out of popularity with huge parts of demographics that he used to be popular in, like electric car people, home solar/battery people, and spaceflight fans.)

Re: I am stepping down as the CEO of Mastodon

#164
post #132

My mastodon account on mastodon.social (the official instance of Mastodon gGmbH) was deleted without a reason after I criticized the former GDR. Not going to donate another €100 this year.

Would you say that people who donate one hundred euro or more every year should receive some form of special treatment when it comes to their account status? Not sure why that detail is relevant. That is a very American point of view tbh, not sure why a fellow European would be parroting such currency-focused viewpoints. It's not a good look

It’s rude to pretend OP said something they didn’t say. And a little side insult to Americans, nice.

Re: I am stepping down as the CEO of Mastodon

#165
post #128

Mastodon seems pretty unhealthy to me. I logged in for the first time in months a few days ago and it was mostly angry memes, a surprising number of which were celebrating violence and murder. This is despite me aggressively muting people who post that sort of thing. I hope they find a niche, but the cultural damage may already be done.

I never see that on the php instance.

this was on the math instance

Re: I am stepping down as the CEO of Mastodon

#166
post #118
post #80

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I don't see his linked comment as blocking progress. Both of those questions are very valid and something I'd expect from a good core maintainer. Disclaimer: I don't have any additional context.

There are other examples. He single-handedly prevented quote tweets from being implemented in Mastodon because "they lead to toxicity", disregarding the benefits of quote tweets and the barrage of feedback supporting it. Meanwhile, Bluesky implemented QTs in a perfect way: you can detach your post from quotes or prevent quoting entirely if you want, but the feature is there.

This was also the largely held opinion of the community at a time. I don't know if we can blame him on that. The opinion started changing once the community grew bigger after the twitter migration and after Bluesky implemented it in a more sensitive way.

For anyone reading, quote tweets are now available on Mastodon.

Re: I am stepping down as the CEO of Mastodon

#167
post #143

> I have so much passion for Mastodon and the fediverse. The fediverse is an island within an increasingly dystopian capitalist hellscape. And from my perspective, Mastodon is our best shot at bringing this vision of a better future to the masses. This is why I’m sticking around, albeit in a more advisory, and less public, role. Wait ’til the masses hear about this one.

You can claim the opposite of the fediverse. The fediverse became an ultra left-wing (in terms of anti-capitalism and anti-imperialism, not human rights). If you write one positive thing about AI/LLM based coding and you will be tarred and spring-loaded. People use Fediverse for venting, less for creating and sharing original content. Some creators on TikTok provide much more insightful content than most of the Fediv…

Wait now I love the fediverse.

Re: I am stepping down as the CEO of Mastodon

#168
post #107

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I think it's more the keming of the domain portion of the HN title, especially combined with HN's rather small font size choice (it's a meager 8pt¹!) there, and that it just happens that the mis-kemed result ends up with "John Mastodon", and is thus not trivially noticeable as "wrong"… (I read it the same way, too.) (¹I personally have a browser override for HN's tiny font choice; I thought that 12pt was the universa…

HN is simple enough that it scales well with browser zoom, and so (imo) is excusable for not following that 12pt standard.

Agreed. I need a larger font on a lot of sites nowadays, but HN is probably the one that behaves best with simple browser zoom. I have it set to 125 or 150% depending how tired my eyes are..

Re: I am stepping down as the CEO of Mastodon

#170
post #118

Earlier quoted context omitted.

There are other examples. He single-handedly prevented quote tweets from being implemented in Mastodon because "they lead to toxicity", disregarding the benefits of quote tweets and the barrage of feedback supporting it. Meanwhile, Bluesky implemented QTs in a perfect way: you can detach your post from quotes or prevent quoting entirely if you want, but the feature is there.

This was also the largely held opinion of the community at a time. I don't know if we can blame him on that. The opinion started changing once the community grew bigger after the twitter migration and after Bluesky implemented it in a more sensitive way. For anyone reading, quote tweets are now available on Mastodon.

> This was also the largely held opinion of the community at a time

Eugen didn't refer to the community when he declined implenting it. So, no, community wasn't a parameter at the time regardless what their opinion was.

Post reply on HN