Live data from Hacker News

Visible from space, Sudan's bloodied sands expose a massacre of thousands

telegraph.co.uk

161–170 of 211 posts

Re: Visible from space, Sudan's bloodied sands expose a massacre of thousands

#161

[flagged]

Not sure why you are being downvoted, but you are exactly right.

The October 7 massacre passed with barely any notice in much of the Western world. Yet the moment Israel responded to recover the hostages—if not earlier—there were already demonstrations everywhere against so-called Israeli “atrocities.” It appears the world only pays attention when Jews are involved.

An estimated 500,000 children have died from malnutrition alone since the Sudan conflict began in 2023[0]. Do you see people in Paris, Washington, or New York demanding an end to that conflict? We have not even accounted for deaths caused directly by the fighting.

Even with regard to the war in Gaza, Hamas’ use of human shields[1] has resulted in significant civilian casualties, yet all condemnation is directed at the IDF, which attempts to avoid civilian deaths, including by dropping leaflets before airstrikes[2]. No one seems to care that Hamas—the elected government of Gaza—is deliberately placing civilians in harm’s way in a war it initiated. Instead, the criticism overwhelmingly targets Israel for civilian deaths caused by Hamas’ human-shield strategy.

[0]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Famine_in_Sudan_(2024%E2%80%93...

[1]: https://stratcomcoe.org/cuploads/pfiles/hamas_human_shields....

[2]: https://edition.cnn.com/2023/11/16/middleeast/israel-leaflet...

Re: Visible from space, Sudan's bloodied sands expose a massacre of thousands

#162
post #106
post #98

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Yes ofc. The RSF is just the rebranded Janjaweed which were legally classified as having committed genocide. But they never faced any international consequences and here they are committing genocide once again. It's also a major conflict though as the SAF is the major oppositional force fighting against the RSF. SAF was the military that took control after a democratic revolution pushed out the dictator Omar al-Bashi…

[flagged]

This is entirely false. The UN clearly defines [1] genocide as (emphasis mine):

> ...any of the following acts committed with intent to destroy, in whole or in part, a national, ethnical, racial or religious group...

[1]: https://www.un.org/en/genocide-prevention/definition

Re: Visible from space, Sudan's bloodied sands expose a massacre of thousands

#163

[flagged]

Not sure why you are being downvoted, but you are exactly right. The October 7 massacre passed with barely any notice in much of the Western world. Yet the moment Israel responded to recover the hostages—if not earlier—there were already demonstrations everywhere against so-called Israeli “atrocities.” It appears the world only pays attention when Jews are involved. An estimated 500,000 children have died from malnut…

[deleted]

Re: Visible from space, Sudan's bloodied sands expose a massacre of thousands

#164

[flagged]

Not sure why you are being downvoted, but you are exactly right. The October 7 massacre passed with barely any notice in much of the Western world. Yet the moment Israel responded to recover the hostages—if not earlier—there were already demonstrations everywhere against so-called Israeli “atrocities.” It appears the world only pays attention when Jews are involved. An estimated 500,000 children have died from malnut…

[deleted]

Re: Visible from space, Sudan's bloodied sands expose a massacre of thousands

#165

[flagged]

Not sure why you are being downvoted, but you are exactly right. The October 7 massacre passed with barely any notice in much of the Western world. Yet the moment Israel responded to recover the hostages—if not earlier—there were already demonstrations everywhere against so-called Israeli “atrocities.” It appears the world only pays attention when Jews are involved. An estimated 500,000 children have died from malnut…

[deleted]

Re: Visible from space, Sudan's bloodied sands expose a massacre of thousands

#166

[flagged]

Not sure why you are being downvoted, but you are exactly right. The October 7 massacre passed with barely any notice in much of the Western world. Yet the moment Israel responded to recover the hostages—if not earlier—there were already demonstrations everywhere against so-called Israeli “atrocities.” It appears the world only pays attention when Jews are involved. An estimated 500,000 children have died from malnut…

[deleted]

Re: Visible from space, Sudan's bloodied sands expose a massacre of thousands

#169

[flagged]

Not sure why you are being downvoted, but you are exactly right. The October 7 massacre passed with barely any notice in much of the Western world. Yet the moment Israel responded to recover the hostages—if not earlier—there were already demonstrations everywhere against so-called Israeli “atrocities.” It appears the world only pays attention when Jews are involved. An estimated 500,000 children have died from malnut…

I always find it fascinating that pretty much every time pro-Israel posters like yourself bring up Sudan, they only use it as a cudgel to deflect from the IDF's actions in Gaza, not out of any legitimate or sincere concern for the people of Sudan.

> The October 7 massacre passed with barely any notice in much of the Western world.

Verifiably false.

> Yet the moment Israel responded to recover the hostages—if not earlier—there were already demonstrations everywhere against so-called Israeli “atrocities.”

Because we've seen time and time again the brutal methods the IDF uses to retaliate against the entire population of Gaza, employing collective punishment against innocents. And the protesters were sadly proven very right yet again.

> Even with regard to the war in Gaza, Hamas’ use of human shields[1] has resulted in significant civilian casualties [...] Instead, the criticism overwhelmingly targets Israel for civilian deaths caused by Hamas’ human-shield strategy.

Surely even you realize that bombing a building when you know there are human shields held within is a bad thing, right? If you know there are innocent people in the blast radius of your bomb and you still fire the bomb, you are the villain in this story. The IDF has killed more civilians than Hamas has and it's not even remotely close, a difference of tens of thousands at minimum.

Re: Visible from space, Sudan's bloodied sands expose a massacre of thousands

#170

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Agree or disagree this post is clearly about which genocide they choose to protest.

[flagged]

The IDF has killed many tens of thousands more women and children than Hamas has, so who the bigger terrorists are is debatable.
Post reply on HN