Live data from Hacker News

They used Xenon to climb Everest in days – is it the future of mountaineering?

nytimes.com

161–170 of 199 posts

Re: They used Xenon to climb Everest in days – is it the future of mountaineering?

#161

So they slept in hypoxia tents which activates the hypoxia-inducible factor molecule, but they also took xenon which also activates the molecule. So, it's not clear if the xenon actually did anything? Back during the 2000 dot-com boom crash I met a guy who got into a top business school in part by writing about the challenges of climbing Everest. He confessed drunkenly at a party to me that he'd never even left the U…

> Back during the 2000 dot-com boom crash I met a guy who got into a top business school in part by writing about the challenges of climbing Everest I met a startup founder in my local community who would always bring up his ambitions to climb Everest. He made sure everyone knew and made it part of his personality. Except, he was very out of shape and undeniably overweight. He was not doing any type of training or fi…

I met a climbing guide who had summitted Mt. Everest multiple times (and had the pictures to prove it). His normal cardio workout was to put on a heavy backpack, then get on a StairMaster machine and go at maximum speed for a couple hours. He looked amazing — although I don't think he ever founded a tech startup.

Re: They used Xenon to climb Everest in days – is it the future of mountaineering?

#162

So they slept in hypoxia tents which activates the hypoxia-inducible factor molecule, but they also took xenon which also activates the molecule. So, it's not clear if the xenon actually did anything? Back during the 2000 dot-com boom crash I met a guy who got into a top business school in part by writing about the challenges of climbing Everest. He confessed drunkenly at a party to me that he'd never even left the U…

"Back during the 2000 dot-com boom crash I met a guy who got into a top business school in part by writing about the challenges of climbing Everest. He confessed drunkenly at a party to me that he'd never even left the USA..."

It kind of makes sense. A lot of business success is about being able to bullshit convincingly.

Re: They used Xenon to climb Everest in days – is it the future of mountaineering?

#163
post #143

IMO this climb doesn't really do much to prove of xenon's effectiveness (altitude researcher Dr. Peter Hackett says as much [0]). The team used supplemental oxygen on the climb, with the starting altitude and flow rate not being reported [1]. This is speculative, but if they were using more oxygen than typical and starting at a lower altitude, that's a massive advantage. Further, Andrew Ushakov traveled from NYC to t…

I believe the Xenon team also did hypoxic tents

Re: They used Xenon to climb Everest in days – is it the future of mountaineering?

#165
post #72

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> why bother with xenon? Just inject EPO. As a recreational anything I'd say avoid wrecking your body to make some arbitrary numbers nobody will ever care about go up (or down)

Given that the odds of dying on Everest are so high, a bit of ill-advised drug use seems like a minor concern.

Are they?

I thought nowadays the sherpas practically carry you up there so it's of low risk to you.

Both wikipedia [1] and an expedition company [2] seem to put the deaths per year as [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_people_who_died_climbi...

[2]: https://www.climbing-kilimanjaro.com/mount-everest-deaths/

Re: They used Xenon to climb Everest in days – is it the future of mountaineering?

#166

Note that these all of these Xenon-Everest stories come back to the same person: Lukas Furtenbach Why? Because he’s launching a business that sells Xenon-assisted Everest tours: https://www.furtenbachadventures.com/ These stories are never about uncovering an underground world of Xenon performance enhancement or discussing the science (which is much less optimistic about Xenon’s benefits). They’re always lazily relay…

That’s some really solid PR work on his part if true, but if he is scaling (pun intended) tours that actually do manage to summit Everest in significantly decreased time, I would say that it’s strong evidence that Xenon actually works and the science just hasn’t caught up to it yet. Unless he has found some other clever way that he is for some reason pretending is Xenon.

Re: They used Xenon to climb Everest in days – is it the future of mountaineering?

#169

Note that these all of these Xenon-Everest stories come back to the same person: Lukas Furtenbach Why? Because he’s launching a business that sells Xenon-assisted Everest tours: https://www.furtenbachadventures.com/ These stories are never about uncovering an underground world of Xenon performance enhancement or discussing the science (which is much less optimistic about Xenon’s benefits). They’re always lazily relay…

That’s some really solid PR work on his part if true, but if he is scaling (pun intended) tours that actually do manage to summit Everest in significantly decreased time, I would say that it’s strong evidence that Xenon actually works and the science just hasn’t caught up to it yet. Unless he has found some other clever way that he is for some reason pretending is Xenon.

> Unless he has found some other clever way that he is for some reason pretending is Xenon.

Meth. It's meth.

Re: They used Xenon to climb Everest in days – is it the future of mountaineering?

#170
post #146

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> but meta-analyses still doesn't show a real performance bump I wish all of these news articles would discuss the actual studies instead of lazily parroting the claims of the one guy who is trying to sell expensive Xenon-assisted Everest hikes. These articles are always PR pieces for Lukas Furtenbach’s expensive Everest tours. Every single time I see the words “Xenon” and “Everest” in a headline, his name is in the…

> I wish all of these news articles would discuss the actual studies They do, if you read them. > While some doctors have used the gas in the past to “precondition” patients to low oxygen levels — for example, before major heart surgery — the practice hasn’t really caught on because “it hasn’t been as protective as one would hope,” he said. > Mike Shattock, a professor of cellular cardiology at King’s College London,…

All the quotes you posted basically say the same thing; There is no evidence for the efficacy of xenon. That's scientist speak for: "Xenon doesn't work".
Post reply on HN