Live data from Hacker News

Jellyfin as a Spotify alternative

coppolaemilio.com

161–170 of 497 posts

Re: Jellyfin as a Spotify alternative

#161

This article fails to mention the absolute butchering of features that takes place moving from a typical music streaming subscription to a self hosted Jellyfin library. A large part of my listening on YouTube Music is going to a particular song or band I like and clicking "Radio", which generates a playlist of similar sounding songs. You can then fine tune it with a filter i.e "Popular songs, deep cuts" or specific e…

I've discovered so many niche bands and subgenres since I got Spotify.

Re: Jellyfin as a Spotify alternative

#162
post #81

I’ve been doing this since 2005 with just my NAS and mediamonkey or foobar2000. Additionally, Sonos can index the NAS directly over SMB, although they have not really put much effort into fixing bugs in their implementation it still works well enough. Any upnp/dlna streamer that runs on your NAS (plex, twonky, etc…) should be able to handle other situations.

The nice thing about these media servers is support for mobile etc

Re: Jellyfin as a Spotify alternative

#163

Earlier quoted context omitted.

What do you do for backups? I'm just setting up an Emby instance with a 4 TB hard drive attached, but I'm worried it'll fail and take everything with it.

Is there really a point in backing up media? Unless you've ripped it yourself, I'm sure anything you have is easily obtainable again.

You'd think so but lost media is called that for a reason.

Re: Jellyfin as a Spotify alternative

#164

Earlier quoted context omitted.

What do you do for backups? I'm just setting up an Emby instance with a 4 TB hard drive attached, but I'm worried it'll fail and take everything with it.

Is there really a point in backing up media? Unless you've ripped it yourself, I'm sure anything you have is easily obtainable again.

I have a lot of media from countries that are not the US. That kind of stuff tends to disappear from the internet and market.

Re: Jellyfin as a Spotify alternative

#165

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Amazon S3 Deep Archive and rclone for < 4-5TB. Backblaze in a Windows VM or container for 5TB+.

Do you have a write up on how to do these?

No, I sat down for an evening and figured out rclone from their docs: https://rclone.org/docs/

Re: Jellyfin as a Spotify alternative

#166

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Does it help to connect a different frontend app like Finamp to your jellyfin server?

Jellyfin maintains its own server-side database, the client you use is irrelevant.

How hard would it be to fork and make the change?

Re: Jellyfin as a Spotify alternative

#167

Earlier quoted context omitted.

For "content subscriptions" (Spotify, YouTube, Netflix) keep in mind that a part of the revenue goes towards the content creators. For anything else, I can also highly recommend using local or self-hosted software. Plenty of open source software has even exceeded proprietary alternatives in the last couple years.

It is an incredibly, and almost criminally, small portion of the pie

Better than nothing...

Re: Jellyfin as a Spotify alternative

#168

This article fails to mention the absolute butchering of features that takes place moving from a typical music streaming subscription to a self hosted Jellyfin library. A large part of my listening on YouTube Music is going to a particular song or band I like and clicking "Radio", which generates a playlist of similar sounding songs. You can then fine tune it with a filter i.e "Popular songs, deep cuts" or specific e…

It's a "YMMV" situation, because... I don't want that. At all. It's algorithmic and there's nothing stopping artists and labels paying for placement in there. I don't want that. I am a musician, and a DJ, and I've been digging deep through artist and label catalogues on my own for decades. The process of discovery via my preexisting routes is far more fruitful, enjoyable and rewarding than lazily letting an algorithm…

I miss last.fm and audioscrobbler so much. Yeah it's still there, but it's not like the old days, which was far better for feeling like I was in touch with other users, finding tons of new music, and not hearing yet another Home Depot ad.

I half wonder if Spotify US is one of those harbingers of doom for the old web in the same way I think of Twitter and iPhone/SPAs/The Stream UI.

Re: Jellyfin as a Spotify alternative

#169

Self-hosting stuff is awesome if you have the skills. I have been on a mission for the last 2 years to replace as many subscriptions as possible with self-hosted solutions. The subscriptions really had gotten out of hand, it had gotten to about $200 (AUD) a month. Quick napkin math is that I have cancelled about ~$150 a month worth of subscriptions so far. The $500 office desktop I got for a home server is struggling…

Is there a reason you went with Emby over Jellyfin (forked from Emby)?

Emby just felt more polished and focused while Jellyfin felt like it was on the path towards feature bloat. Also, I had more confidence in Emby supporting future devices I might get than Jellyfin.

When it comes to supporting multiple media types (video/audiobooks/music/etc..) I prefer using a seperate solution for each that is focused on that use case instead of an all-in-one solution.

I am using audiobookshelf for audiobooks and podcasts, so I really don't need that from my video solution.

I have configured Emby to keep the metadata in nfo files next to the videos, so I should be able to easily switch to something else if things change in the future.

Re: Jellyfin as a Spotify alternative

#170
Self hosting Data point.

Owntone has my library to play in my house through shairpoint-sync driven amps & speakers in different rooms. (Synced perfectly and seamlessly - your ears can really tell too).

That same Owntone installation over wireguard using http stream in my phone/laptop browser when I'm not home.

Owntone & airplay2 is absolutely first rate.

Owntone http streaming is plenty good enough for me.

(Owntone also works great with your spotify subscription if you do that).

Post reply on HN