This exact same thing happened to me today! I'm in Germany, so I put the Olympics on TV. But I don't yet speak German, so after an hour I wanted to watch them in English. I went to the NBC web site, but they geolocate your IP and only stream to US people. Fine, I'm used to this crap (lots of Youtube videos are blocked in Germany too) so I just fired up my proxy and tried again. This time I got through, only to find t…
I'm an American and I want to watch the Olympics. What do I do?
161–170 of 191 posts
Re: I'm an American and I want to watch the Olympics. What do I do?
#162Re: I'm an American and I want to watch the Olympics. What do I do?
#163Earlier quoted context omitted.
Cool - I talk about that at the bottom of the article. But I added a note in that section that you need to pay for a TV license to stream legally. Thanks.
I'm nitpicking but I feel it's worth pointing out that not only do UK viewers of live TV need a license but all taxpayers contribute to the BBC by separate payments from direct taxation. UK ISPs appear to throttle iPlayer traffic so ironically using a proxy might be worthwhile in the UK too.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/BBC#Finances
I also don't think it's true to suggest ISPs are throttling iPlayer specifically. The bbc has said it will name and shame any ISP that does.
http://www.pcpro.co.uk/news/broadband/362950/bbc-will-alert-...
Re: I'm an American and I want to watch the Olympics. What do I do?
#164Earlier quoted context omitted.
I guess technically I'm paying for VPN service, but I would have been anyway, so I didn't buy something new. And, I'm not certain it's illegal. Are you? Is the legislation specific about where you must reside? What if you're consuming content but you're not in the UK? If it is illegal for anyone to consume BBC content at the time of broadcast without a TV license regardless of location, what if someone outside of the…
[IANAL] My understanding of copyright is that for events such as the Olympics, copyrights are often licensed licensed a country by country basis and that the retransmission of material across national boundaries is a violation. Doing so violates the author's right to control their work because it bipasses the arrangements the author has made to control their work. Incidently, this rests on the same legal principles u…
So, really now it should just be a question of the rights holder allowing me in the US to watch something broadcast in the UK that I paid for.
Re: I'm an American and I want to watch the Olympics. What do I do?
#165I'm actually quite surprised to see so many posts on HN discussing ways to pirate Olympic content. The BBC is restricted to UK IP addresses for a reason. Every household in Britian pays the equivalent of around $230 per year for the right to watch live television, whether it be on your phone, laptop or TV. The BBC has a finite amount of resources to spend on hosting online content & if the whole World logs on to watc…
There's no higher cost of transmission for the BBC - they're sending it to a UK based IP and then I pay a monthly fee for that transmission to the US.
https://img.skitch.com/20120729-8nkr9edjmm4966yt8qm1sfyg5t.p...
Re: I'm an American and I want to watch the Olympics. What do I do?
#166In the Netherlands you can watch it via NOS. They have explanations for how to watch it on your pc, mobile, tv, radio, twitter/fb. See http://nos.nl/os2012/volg-de-spelen/ . To watch on your pc, they partnered with Youtube Live: http://www.youtube.com/user/nosnlsport which gives me: "The uploader has not made this video available in your country. " which is a bit strange (living in the Netherlands). Fortunately it is…
The NOS website has a nice design. The sports and events are very well categorised. They even place a thumbnail of the video stream in the floating menu when you are looking at items further down the page (so you don't miss out on anything while reading the articles). The only thing that's missing are other languages than Dutch, is it possible that it's done deliberately to keep people from abroad out?
Re: I'm an American and I want to watch the Olympics. What do I do?
#167I'm not in the US but I've been watching the Olympics on YouTube - http://youtube.com/user/olympic - this is the official Olympics channel. Funny nobody's mentioned this. Is the channel not available in the US?
Re: I'm an American and I want to watch the Olympics. What do I do?
#168At a very basic level, they could offer live streaming of all events --advertising free-- for a fee. I would gladly pay, say, US $100 for this service. Some might only be interested in a subset of events, which means that there's a possibility to create tiers and capture revenue at various levels.
Here in the US, as has been discussed in this and other threads, NBC has royally fucked up things beyond all recognition. I finally broke down and downloaded their app. It's shit. The ads are intrusive TV-style ads. What's worst, they have some sort of a bug somewhere that is causing videos to end prematurely.
As and example, I tried watching Archery, Judo and Taekwondo pre-recorded events (not live). One of them was supposed to be a five hour event. We watched about fifteen minutes and the stream stopped with a message that read something akin to "This video has ended". There was no way to watch it beyond that point. It literally stopped in the middle of the action.
The other moronic thing is the way the video ads are inserted. They seem to be using a simple timer to determine when to run a video ad. This means that they'll interrupt your viewing in the middle of a match --just as someone is throwing a kick-- to run a stupid ad. Unbelievable.
I am hoping that there's widespread dissatisfaction with this and that the next Olympics, World Cup, etc. see a massive change. I'd really like to see a true Internet company get the rights and do it right. The IOC could make far more than what NBC and others are paying for these events by having a single-point internationally-friendly Internet strategy rather than old-school per country/region licensing.
Finally, a note to NBC advertisers: I am NOT watching your ads. Stop paying NBC! We DVR the coverage and are masterfully skilled at fast-forwarding through your commercials. When I am watching gymnastics I could not care less about your movie or your insurance offering. So, stop supporting broadcasters, you are wasting your money in a monumental way.
Re: I'm an American and I want to watch the Olympics. What do I do?
#169Earlier quoted context omitted.
Except this time around, CTV has done a good job of providing Olympic coverage to non-TV people. The iOS app is great, and the web portal is great, and it's free.
Yes, but why can't I watch the coverage from whichever country I choose? Canadian coverage focuses on Canadian athletes. Perhaps I'm an ex-pat, and want to watch my home country, or just curious how events are portrayed elsewhere.
Different problems completely... But I agree with your sentiment either way.
Re: I'm an American and I want to watch the Olympics. What do I do?
#170Sign up for www.unblock-us.com or www.unotelly.com and watch the amazing BBC coverage on iPlayer. Super super simple setup. Personally, I prefer www.unblock-us.com
Just use http://tunlr.net/ 's DNS servers instead - it's the same type of service, just completely free and with no signup required. Primary DNS: 64.250.122.104 Secondary DNS: 199.167.30.144