Live data from Hacker News

IPCC climate crisis report delivers ‘final warning on 1.5C’

theguardian.com

161–170 of 456 posts

Re: IPCC climate crisis report delivers ‘final warning on 1.5C’

#161

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I'd argue we have no idea what will happen when the glaciers melt, given the lack of accurate climate change predictions to date. We have a lot of models that have historically proven very incomplete with no reason to believe they're any more complete now. The oceans rising is more a problem, but it's not going to end human civilization and will happen slowly enough that adaptation is possible, albeit expensive. "Dro…

Oh my Sweet Summer Child, you really have an unplaced faith in humanity - especially given our track record. "The sky is shifting" - is a hand-wave to the life-changing impacts headed our way and what our collective response to those impacts will be. Look how nuts people are getting over what are mere trivialities in comparison. Wait until there's crop failures threatening our food supply, fresh water supplies being…

>Oh my Sweet Summer Child

Yeah, this person offers nothing but condescension. Immediate downvote.

Re: IPCC climate crisis report delivers ‘final warning on 1.5C’

#162
post #87
post #57

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Not the GP, but sure, if the people making those wrong predictions are advocating for policy changes that will impoverish so many people.

How accurate do people have to be in their predictions to advocate for policy change?

If said policy change is a radical departure from status quo that allowed humanity to flourish since the start of the Industrial Revolution, then quite accurate indeed. People can't just bandy about phrases like "abolish fossil fuels" without justifying it with strong evidence.

Most climate advocacy, I find, focuses too much on the doom and gloom of what will happen if we continue down our present path, and not enough on the number of lives that have been and will continue to be enriched by easily and cheaply accessible energy from fossil fuels. I am aware of the downsides and by no means think we should pollute for the sake of polluting, but I remain unconvinced by the current alternatives proposed by the overall climate movement.

Re: IPCC climate crisis report delivers ‘final warning on 1.5C’

#163

Earlier quoted context omitted.

So is understating the impact. This take is seriously dangerous. "1.5C is not so bad, chill people" When the fact is - we don't know the impact - if we go beyond 1.5. What we do know (because it's already very much measurable) is that much of the worlds glaciers will melt, causing drought. What we do know is that eventually the sea levels will rise and drown many extremely valuable coastal areas.

we don't know the impact To your point, we know quite a bit, and it's pretty bad. Will 10% of the world's population perish? Most likely. There's already a population die-off in progress in many areas of the world as the birth rate continues to decline. People don't have to drop dead for the population to die off, they can simply not be born in sufficient numbers to replace the existing population. As for those who a…

Population declines on the other hand are expected because birth rates have been dropping for hundreds of years. This is a good thing you can’t support infinite growth on a finite planet. Suggesting global warming is the cause completely ignores these long term trends.

Peoples quality of life globally has been consistently improving and that’s unlikely to change with global warming. China had one of the worlds largest famines in living memory 1958-1961, it’s simply been the norm for most of human history. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_famines

Re: IPCC climate crisis report delivers ‘final warning on 1.5C’

#164
> as rising greenhouse gas emissions push the world to the brink of irrevocable damage that only swift and drastic action can avert.

Well like no one knew that :) But the official report I am sure details all the background to prove that statement. It is too bad the people that can do something will not only ignore the report but probably will double down.

Re: IPCC climate crisis report delivers ‘final warning on 1.5C’

#166
post #24
post #8

For anyone interested in what 1.5C represents, I can't recommend enough the Climate Fresk [1] exercise. It's not just the droughts and floods, the heatwaves, the changes in birds, insects, crop yields, … Include permafrost melting and releasing greenhouse gasses, civil unrest in populated areas that won't be livable anymore, unstable food production, and quite a few other causes and consequences. It's a feedback loop…

What I always find so hard to believe is that, knowing how well we can predict weather and other complicated systems, climate change science somehow is able to make 1/10 centigrade precision predictions on time horizons of decades and centuries.

Compare with how hard it is to exactly predict if a patient is gonna survive the next day-- while assuming that *anyone* (for now) is gonna be dead in 120 years is a pretty safe bet.

And predictions about life expectancy become easier in aggregate, too.

Re: IPCC climate crisis report delivers ‘final warning on 1.5C’

#167
post #24

Earlier quoted context omitted.

What I always find so hard to believe is that, knowing how well we can predict weather and other complicated systems, climate change science somehow is able to make 1/10 centigrade precision predictions on time horizons of decades and centuries.

If climate models were predicting the temperature of your city on March 21, 2120 then your intuition here would be wise. But that is not at all what these models are predicting. They are predicting global average annual temperatures and other gross, planet-scale statistics. "Average annual global temperature in a given year" and "temperature in my city tomorrow" are fundamentally very different types of predictions.…

Predictions so far have been terrible compared to what actually happened.

Re: IPCC climate crisis report delivers ‘final warning on 1.5C’

#168
post #130

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The point he is making is the disconnect between models and reality. Also when are people held accountable for their models being wrong and the output that comes from that. Climate models has a terrible track record and have failed to materialize over and over again. We have environmental crises all over the place which we should be focused on. The two are not the same thing and climate activism seems to not care abo…

Please back up the claim "climate models has a terrible track record" and qualify the word 'terrible'. Casting blame is a common denier tactic [1] used despite the models being useful and accurate [2]. The "whataboutisms" you mention are another common tactic. [3] Blaming EV batteries is a red herring; they have much lower lifecycle emissions than gas-based engines. [4] [1] https://skepticalscience.com/climate-models…

‘We got it right NOW we promise!’

Re: IPCC climate crisis report delivers ‘final warning on 1.5C’

#169
post #124

So, does this apply to China, which is burning more coal than ever? The UN secretary general, António Guterres, said: “This report is a clarion call to massively fast-track climate efforts by every country and every sector and on every timeframe. Our world needs climate action on all fronts: everything, everywhere, all at once.”

This is not one of those problems that goes away by pointing a finger.

If one set of countries is lowering what they are doing, and another set of countries is increasing what they are doing, is that exactly equal in your eyes?

Re: IPCC climate crisis report delivers ‘final warning on 1.5C’

#170
post #8

For anyone interested in what 1.5C represents, I can't recommend enough the Climate Fresk [1] exercise. It's not just the droughts and floods, the heatwaves, the changes in birds, insects, crop yields, … Include permafrost melting and releasing greenhouse gasses, civil unrest in populated areas that won't be livable anymore, unstable food production, and quite a few other causes and consequences. It's a feedback loop…

Thanks for sharing that. I signed up for a workshop on Thursday!
Post reply on HN