Live data from Hacker News

Dear Internet: It's no Longer OK Not to Know How Congress Works

informationdiet.com

161–166 of 166 posts

Re: Dear Internet: It's no Longer OK Not to Know How Congress Works

#161

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Clearly people don't agree with my original comment. I'll see if I can figure out where I've strayed, and make my original idea clearer. If I may, I'd like to squish the content of your comment into the single word "motivation." At present, it takes a high enough amount of motivation to either take time off work to vote early, vote by mail, or wait in excessively long lines after work, that far fewer than a majority…

I think buried in your statement is the idea that democracy is inherently better, an end in itself. I strongly dispute this: I think that it's more important to get to the best answer, than to follow the herd, whatever direction it might go in. In your second link, it notes two problems. First, it says that Crowds tend to work best when there is a correct answer to the question being posed, such as a question about g…

That Wikipedia article used to explain how democracy was not an example of "wisdom of the crowds"; I'm disappointed that I can't find an older revision with that segment intact.

But that said, it's important to distinguish "crowd" from "people". I've lately been trying to explain to people that the vote is the least important (while still being necessary) part of a democracy. The effort of explaining to the whole population why a certain law needs passage is the soul of democracy; votes are merely to maintain a formal record of dissent and to resolve deadlocks. They're decision making tools of last resort.

Re: Dear Internet: It's no Longer OK Not to Know How Congress Works

#162
This article made me think of the cool startup https://www.popvox.com/ They are working to provide a two way bridge between Congress and Constituents. They won the Social Media Tech award in the SXSW Accelerator this year and Tim O'Reilly is a founding advisor. I think they're the kind of company that would love help from open sourcing l33t haxxors such as yourselves.

Re: Dear Internet: It's no Longer OK Not to Know How Congress Works

#163

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Couldn't this be addressed by requiring all spending bills to have their funding built in? ie, the bill must include what they are proposing to spend, and where the funding will come from (tax hike). This would also help people understand the costs of what they are voting for.

I think it's a particularly interesting idea for citizen initiatives to have to be in the black, but a lot of times when it comes to policy/program issues, there's disagreement over whether or not budget figures are realistic. Think about how hard it often is for developers to estimate the time and effort involved in a project. Programs that involve putting together networks of people, hard assets, and information sy…

Yeah, I see how that could be an issue. How is it handled now, though? If government approves a project to improve [community service here] for $X, and the project goes over, what happens? Does the contractor have to eat it? Does government have to approve an additional extension? The project can't just run on and on, right? Sorry, I just am not that familiar with how it all works, which is kind of sad, I suppose.

Re: Dear Internet: It's no Longer OK Not to Know How Congress Works

#164
post #18

Earlier quoted context omitted.

This would indeed be great, but as Clay pointed out software like this would need to be housed on hardware belonging to Congress. That being the case, it could be very difficult to get them to agree to something having the sole purpose of holding them to a greater accountability. I'm not saying it isn't an idea worth pursuing; just that it may not be a walk in the park to get them to use it.

Dunno, they picked up twitter pretty fast.

Twitter is designed to let you pop soundbites.

How could politicians not pick it up fast?

Re: Dear Internet: It's no Longer OK Not to Know How Congress Works

#166
post #144

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Are you really saying that high school was so bad you'd rather not vote than go back there for an hour or 3?

Absolutely. Try growing up as a geek in a semi-suburbanized farming community (though things have changed since then).

If you want to play this game: try growing up as a liberal, atheist geek from out of town in a rural bible-belt town of ~7,000. Then, try becoming an adult and getting over it so that you can perform your civic duty.
Post reply on HN