Live data from Hacker News

Skier almost hit by camera drone in World Cup slalom

bbc.com

161–167 of 167 posts

Re: Skier almost hit by camera drone in World Cup slalom

#161
post #19

Has anyone actually been killed by a non military drone yet?

A few people have been killed by RC helicopters (see e.g. http://abcnews.go.com/US/minute-mechanical-error-led-teens-r...).

A man was killed by a larger drone when, it's suspected, the GPS was jammed: http://lemondronor.com/blog/index.php/2013/3/gps-loss-kicked...

Re: Skier almost hit by camera drone in World Cup slalom

#162
post #108
post #7

It was an official TV-video-quadcopter from an Italian local TV company. The FIS was initially okay with it. The quadcopter operater has a pilot license and was suposed to fly only in a specific corridor with no visitors nor athletes underneath. Though, the quadcopter (intentionally?) left the corridore several times in the minutes before the crash (for better videos?). https://translate.google.com/translate?hl=de&sl…

I'm having trouble understanding why the last part of this comment is relevant...?

Same FIS skiing TV event/discipline, both incidents involve mechanical engineering, computer hardware and software.

Both are currently featured in the news and are controversial. The second one happened just a few days earlier.

Same skiing nation (in 5 races, 4 of their favorities were knocked out for (broken bones, etc)). The involved companies came in both incidents from the same country (coincidence, doesn't mean anything).

But instead of downvoting, maybe just ignore it? Several downvoted/flagged it, but a lot more upvoted it. It seems other use a throw away user account to post controversial comments...

Re: Skier almost hit by camera drone in World Cup slalom

#163

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The average IQ of a user is inversely proportional to the popularity of a product. Case in point: laser pointers.

Penis enlargement pills are not popular.

Popular enough to take a chunk of a 26BN market: http://abcnews.go.com/Primetime/Health/story?id=814864&page=...

Re: Skier almost hit by camera drone in World Cup slalom

#164

It must be technically possible to prevent a drone from flying below a certain altitude. Probably one of the many features that will be added to drones in the coming years.

If the power cuts out and the drone is falling out of the sky, how useful is a software rule which is dependent on a computer that is now offline, a non-functioning altimeter and a set of dead engines? (Spoiler: not very much) But of course, such thing would never happen. (Except it just did.)

A small secondary powersource that deploys a parachute?

Re: Skier almost hit by camera drone in World Cup slalom

#165
post #8

Am sure when the first cars hit the road, similar news made it to the newspaper front pages then.

Funny story, heard Marc Andreessen once saying: During the early days, whenever a horse cart came in opposite direction to a car, the car owner was supposed to disassemble the car and hide behind a bush before the horse came near. We have come a long way :)

I also read, maybe when a kid, that in the early days of cars, a hired person had to walk on the road ahead of the car to notify horses and humans that a car was coming, with a flag or something ...

Re: Skier almost hit by camera drone in World Cup slalom

#166
post #118
post #49

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It is only a matter of time before decent pilots make mistakes. So what you are saying is that the risk-taking pilots are closing the "window of unregulated flying" a little bit faster than you'd like to see. Eventually, that window will be closed nonetheless.

If decent pilots make unavoidable mistakes, then they will make unavoidable mistakes when its regulated too?

There is no way to avoid all and any risks - you just can't have 100% safety and reliability. What you could do is push for increasing the safety (at the cost of something else, obviously). What you're looking for is preventing avoidable mistakes, and minimizing damage if Something Really Bad happens.

Re: Skier almost hit by camera drone in World Cup slalom

#167

Note to self: add a small mechanical trigger for a parachute for cases of emergency. This will trigger if the drone falls at a certain speed.

You could add an electromechanical failsafe that would trigger in the event of loss of power - i.e. the safety device wants to deploy itself, but is actively prevented from doing so by the electronics.

Won't help. An unsteered parachute slows down the fall so that it's sort-of survivable instead of terminal-velocity; there wouldn't have been any significant effect in this specific case.
Post reply on HN