Live data from Hacker News

TPP banning requirements to transfer or access to source code of software

keionline.org

161–162 of 162 posts

Re: TPP banning requirements to transfer or access to source code of software

#161
post #4

These are rules for States. It has no bearing whatsoever on the GPL. This prevents a country from forcing somebody like Microsoft or Apple to give up their source code for "inspection" in order to access their market. It also helps to prevent States from demanding and acquiring encryption or other private keys (there's a separate section that also explicitly forbids mandating backdoors be added). Not everything in th…

Just because this clause is completely unrelated to the GPL doesn't make the clause okay. It's still shitty because it blocks democratic governance options to have policies that require source release for various situations (such as requiring Open Source for government software use or making policies that software in schools needs to be Open Source etc)

Re: TPP banning requirements to transfer or access to source code of software

#162
post #63

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Just as a counterpoint: the Nevada Gaming Commission has plenty of time and money to sift through the source code of every gaming device that gets deployed in NV.

Do we have specific evidence that they actually do sift through the source code? They demand its submission, but how do we know they actually do anything with it? I'm asking this as a serious question.

It doesn't really matter if they sift through every one so long as they have them on record. If there's ever an allegation of misconduct, the code can be examined in full by any large variety of experts.
Post reply on HN