Live data from Hacker News

Amazon Unveils One-Hour Delivery Service

wsj.com

151–160 of 161 posts

Re: Amazon Unveils One-Hour Delivery Service

#151

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> Because it's so, so easy to get trapped in a cycle of endless below-livable jobs just to support yourself. That's an appeal to emotions and has nothing to do with the argument. > My personal belief, and I'm more than willing to pay more for goods and services to support it, and I live in a country where we have a liveable minimal wage, is that every job if worked 40 hours should be enough for a very modest, but not…

> The forcing of every job to be "living wages" removes a part of the labor force that is willing and able (due to parents or other income) to provide services for less money. This, and I think every one of your points, can be sufficiently addressed with one word: Australia. My 19 year old unskilled housemate gets paid minimum wage $21.08 per hour as a casual.[1] She works 4 days a week and supports herself just fine…

  This, and I think every one of your points, can 
  be sufficiently addressed with one word: 
  Australia.
Youth unemployment (both 15-19 and 15-24) is trending higher[0][1] but the government doesn't seem to think that's a crisis[2] and it has gotten worse since that statement[0][1].

  My 19 year old unskilled housemate gets paid 
  minimum wage $21.08 per hour as a casual.[1] She 
  works 4 days a week and supports herself just 
  fine. They say the cost of living is high in 
  Australia, and it is -everything is expensive 
  here- but we have options: we live in a share 
  house and pay $100 a week per room (four of us) 
  including electricity and Internet. She doesn't 
  own a car, and doesn't smoke cigarettes or drink 
  alcohol. Financially she isn't struggling at all.

  The minimum wage for full time employment is 
  $16.87 per hour, which includes 10 day a year 
  sick leave and 20 days a hear paid leave.[1]
Point 1, I said it increases the cost of living which you confirm.

I'm not sure a frugal person with 3 roommates making 25% above the minimum is a good example.

  Also, because everyone here is paid a 'living 
  wage' we're able to afford to pay social welfare. 
Since it looks like Australia is running a A$48.5 billion budget deficit[3], it looks like you really cannot afford it. In fact, the range of changes look like you are going to reduce social welfare to cover the budget. For students, it seems the cost of university education (the main path in turning an unskilled person to a skilled person) is going to have a jump[4]. This is looking much worse for youth since the need to become skilled labor is going to hit a bit of a wall if the university education costs jump per one of the governments proposals.

  'Newstart Allowance' is paid to unemployed 
  job-seekers at $515.60 per fortnight.[2] It isn't 
  a lot, below the poverty line apparently, but it 
  is enough to rent a room buy food.

  I do not think any of your arguments hold water.
We have unemployeement payments in the US, so I'm not seeing its relation to minimum wage. I am don't believe Australia proves high minimum wage is a good thing.

The argument is high minimum wage cuts youth and unskilled employment and removes a class of worker from the workforce. Looking at [0][1], I think the trends show just that.

0) http://www.ausstats.abs.gov.au/ausstats/meisubs.nsf/0/333D19...

0b) small side note: I do wonder why the change to this reporting is occurring according to

1) http://www.aph.gov.au/About_Parliament/Parliamentary_Departm...

2) http://www.smh.com.au/federal-politics/political-news/christ...

3) http://www.bloomberg.com/news/2014-12-09/abbott-removes-poli...

4) http://www.brisbanetimes.com.au/national/tertiary-education/...

Re: Amazon Unveils One-Hour Delivery Service

#152

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Ever ordered a pizza? 1 hour delivery doesn't come close to any kind of realistic safety margin.

That depends: is the average distance between Amazon warehouses and recipients higher than the distance between a neighborhood pizza shop and it's customers?

Well 1 hour delivery leaves at least 15-20 minutes to actually cook the pizza. I suspect the fact that they're doing this one a few limited parts of Manhattan indicates that they have some kind of courier depots especially for this.

Re: Amazon Unveils One-Hour Delivery Service

#153
post #95

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Tipping is a nuisance, something that goes in the "Con" category in a Pro & Con analysis. The vendor is implicitly warning you that you shouldn't count on getting good service included just because you officially paid for it. They're warning you that they have no real control over their service providers, and "it would be a shame if something unforeseeable, like getting caught in traffic, were to happen to a delivery…

The equivalent cost of shipping from a brick-n-mortar store that's five minutes away is almost surely more than 15 minutes of your time (could easily be 30 minutes) and, if you drive, $2-4 at the IRS/GSA rates. For me, avoiding that 15-20 minutes of annoyance is well-worth calculating and paying a tip. (Agree that that's a negative, but it's relatively small negative.)

You're right that effective B&M shipping cost is not always free. The brick 'n mortar cost of shipping is anywhere from a lot ("I'd have to drive into the city just for that and pay exorbitant parking garage fees, and I've got too much to do this afternoon...") to nothing ("I'll be in that store tomorrow anyway, and I won't need it until Thursday...")

In the former case, it's unlikely that the tip would impact my decision; in the latter, it very well might. In either case, it goes in the "con" category and, at the margin, changes some fraction of my Amazon-yes-or-no purchase decisions, always in the direction of no.

Re: Amazon Unveils One-Hour Delivery Service

#154
post #147
post #95

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Tipping is a nuisance, something that goes in the "Con" category in a Pro & Con analysis. The vendor is implicitly warning you that you shouldn't count on getting good service included just because you officially paid for it. They're warning you that they have no real control over their service providers, and "it would be a shame if something unforeseeable, like getting caught in traffic, were to happen to a delivery…

The stores don't charge sales tax. The state mandates that they collect sales tax. If the state doesn't mandate that the store collect sales tax, the store won't "make" you pay it, though I think technically in most states, you're still supposed to file those purchases with your state income tax and pay then.

If I can get what I want more cheaply from Vendor A than from Vendor B, the question of whether Vendor B is charging me more as an agent of the state or on its own behalf is unlikely to be relevant to the decision.

Re: Amazon Unveils One-Hour Delivery Service

#155
post #54

Earlier quoted context omitted.

>If a store is close to your commute route, for example, the delivery costs will probably never be low enough to match with that. I think it's not if it is "close," but if it's "convenient" to your commute route -- in terms of location and/or commuting method. If I am in NYC and I need to get off the subway, walk a half block, get the item, and then walk back and get not he subway; I might not want to do it, dependin…

> If I'm riding my bike to commute, I might easily be able to stop, but I might not be able to carry it. You could get one of these: http://www.christianiabikes.com/en/ :) I see a lot of then in Copenhagen these days. Mostly families though, since they use them to carry both kids and shopping. Also probably requires a certain infrastructure to work; you wouldn't want to ride one of those in traffic (esp. with kids),…

I've seen a couple and given something like that a thought, for a bike to run errands; but, I'd never commute with one. (I'm not sure where I'd park it at work, among other things.)

Re: Amazon Unveils One-Hour Delivery Service

#156
post #134
post #74

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Valid point. I'm not sure what "participate" really means though. Do Google Express customers have to provide their loyalty cards? Does Target get all of the data they'd get if the customer shopped in store or through their own delivery service? It would be silly to imply that Google's customers don't see any benefit as they're obviously getting some revenue and data. But it would be similarly silly to imply that Tar…

>Do Google Express customers have to provide their loyalty cards? No. I order stuff from Target via Google Shopping Express multiple times a week without a loyalty card. I didn't even know Target had loyalty cards, in fact! Also if you're logged into your account you go go here and see what loyalty cards you can type in: https://www.google.com/shopping/express/#SettingsPlace : The list includes Costco, REI, Staples,…

Target offers 5% discount on purchases if you use the RedCard Debit (linked to your bank account), credit, or Visa credit cards (no longer offered for new customers.) Essentially, they give you the fees charged by the payment brands and processors as a discount for using their card instead.

Target could compete effectively with the Google and Amazon offerings by adding delivery to their Cartwheel app.

Re: Amazon Unveils One-Hour Delivery Service

#157
post #95

I just placed an order with this new service (some HDMI cables for our office). The selection is pretty decent, definitely comparable to Google Shopping Express. One very odd note though: they ask for a variable tip to the delivery courier (something Google doesn't do). So even for "free" 2 hour delivery, you're paying for delivery. While I see how this is better for the courier, I think it's a big mistake—people hat…

Tipping is a nuisance, something that goes in the "Con" category in a Pro & Con analysis. The vendor is implicitly warning you that you shouldn't count on getting good service included just because you officially paid for it. They're warning you that they have no real control over their service providers, and "it would be a shame if something unforeseeable, like getting caught in traffic, were to happen to a delivery…

I certainly hope you don't carry that attitude with you throughout life. Tip your bartenders and pizza delivery guys... they make nothing, anyway. (And, if you're in tech, chances are an extra $2 for a tip is NOT going to break your budget.)

Re: Amazon Unveils One-Hour Delivery Service

#158
post #86

What I don't understand about the big retailers is why they haven't been doing something similar all along to compete with Amazon. Amazon has been building warehouses all across the country near cities to reduce shipping times. But the retailers already have what amounts to hundreds of warehouses at every population center, plus the inventory management systems. Why haven't they put their inventories online and offer…

Amazon has their entire infrastructure focused on rapid delivery of small amounts of stuff to a customer.

Big retailers are focused on maintaining optimum levels of inventory at their big box stores all over the country.

It's a different problem.

Re: Amazon Unveils One-Hour Delivery Service

#159

Earlier quoted context omitted.

That's the problem is: most Pizzerias don't. Or don't pay a living wage.

This may be because of an expectation of tips though? If the tips dried up they would be forced to move that pay to the persons wage.

That would work if workers and employers were equals. They don't. That's why you need strong unions: they tip the scales to a more equal balance of powers.

Re: Amazon Unveils One-Hour Delivery Service

#160
post #95

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Tipping is a nuisance, something that goes in the "Con" category in a Pro & Con analysis. The vendor is implicitly warning you that you shouldn't count on getting good service included just because you officially paid for it. They're warning you that they have no real control over their service providers, and "it would be a shame if something unforeseeable, like getting caught in traffic, were to happen to a delivery…

I certainly hope you don't carry that attitude with you throughout life. Tip your bartenders and pizza delivery guys... they make nothing, anyway. (And, if you're in tech, chances are an extra $2 for a tip is NOT going to break your budget.)

I think tipping well is absolutely one of the best returns on investment available in life.

From a selfish perspective: a few extra dollars can make a huge difference in service, particularly services you use repeatedly.

From a humanity perspective: a few extra dollars can also make a big difference in the life of the person you're tipping...usually jobs with tips do not pay very well.

Post reply on HN