A friend of mine told me earlier today that they had a discussion at work (a coding shop) about "downgrading" to luna from sol for cost reasons and that many were quite unhappy about this because they didn't want inferior tech to be forced upon them. Do they have a point? Is sol actually worth the extra cost? Especially if you ramp up the effort level?
Small Models Have Arrived
151–160 of 374 posts
Re: Small Models Have Arrived
#152A friend of mine told me earlier today that they had a discussion at work (a coding shop) about "downgrading" to luna from sol for cost reasons and that many were quite unhappy about this because they didn't want inferior tech to be forced upon them. Do they have a point? Is sol actually worth the extra cost? Especially if you ramp up the effort level?
Yes. If they don't like the cost then they should fire the "leader" who introduced the AI there to begin with.
Re: Small Models Have Arrived
#153Earlier quoted context omitted.
I got a great deal on ~72 TB of NVMe right before storage prices shot up, doesn't make it any less ridiculous that I have it or any more relevant to people talking about building a NAS now. 99% of people, even in tech, do not have the stupid amounts of hardware people like us hobby on.
Most people in the US have a car, and the average new car is $40,000. Hell where I live a middle class consumer will spend double that on a Boat or an RV and think nothing of it. These aren’t elite tech workers. It’s not unfathomable that if a personal, generally intelligent local AI provides enough utility and doesn’t require you to tweak CLI flags millions of Americans would want one.
Most people in the US don't drive a new car, and used cars can be had for far less than $40k. An $80k purchase would be just shy of the median annual household income -- anyone who thinks nothing of that has financial resources far above typical. You are in a bubble.
Re: Small Models Have Arrived
#154A friend of mine told me earlier today that they had a discussion at work (a coding shop) about "downgrading" to luna from sol for cost reasons and that many were quite unhappy about this because they didn't want inferior tech to be forced upon them. Do they have a point? Is sol actually worth the extra cost? Especially if you ramp up the effort level?
It is a good question. Luna is definitely a very capable model. Much more capable than the top SOTA models from 12 months ago. It definitely isn't at the same level as Sol, but you get 20x the tokens for the cost, and it has a much faster tokens/second rate.
If this is a cost conscious company where I'm going to get a fairly limited amount of Sol, or a nearly unlimited amount of Luna, I'm probably choosing Luna.
Re: Small Models Have Arrived
#155Earlier quoted context omitted.
Yes LLMs are a beautiful way to compact knowledge. It would be such a cool technology to develop and worked with if it wasn’t linked to such a toxic industry
I think you're just observing ppl in one of these rare instances where enough of them come together because they are motivated. 'Toxic' is the clamoring sound of a crowded room where what gets through to your ears are just the most annoying snippets of incomplete conversations. I dare you to hang out with any actual people here, understand their viewpoint and listen to what they actually have to say in person, within…
I know those people. Lots of them are fantastic humans. That doesn’t change the fact the AI industry is extremely toxic
Re: Small Models Have Arrived
#156Earlier quoted context omitted.
What kind of work are you doing? For example, if I have some code in the hot path and I want to do all the usual tricks to help the compiler vectorize it, such a small model is not able to do much.
RAG is your friend (or any vector db). No model can vectorize an entire codebase in context. Even a big mainstream product (like Gemini) cannot handle more than ~1k lines without missing details and making mistakes. And about every 1k lines, it seems to forget the previous 1k, doesn’t it? So you can never hold more than a file or 2 (or 3) in context at a time without losing details. What you find is that the big mode…
Out of interest, have you tried the newer models? You are not describing my experience recently.
Re: Small Models Have Arrived
#157I’m kind of cautiously excited for the next five to ten years, with these AI chips becoming incredibly fast and RAM capacities ramping up its in the cards that we’ll have chips like today’s ATMEL microprocessors that fit on a single board computer and can run small models locally, then all our gizmos can have local AI and I can have a truly intelligent home. Of course there will be a huge push to put all of it in the…
Can we stick one of these in something that looks and sounds like HAL 9000 ?
Re: Small Models Have Arrived
#158Nobody is questioning what is meant by small? When you started mentioning frontier models that don't run locally, I just go TB;DR "Too big, didn't read"
Re: Small Models Have Arrived
#159using small local models - with a little bit of extra work - for the first time over the past few days was _really_ illuminating and inspired similar thoughts about how far you can practically get with so little. column of zap emojis, mane ...
Re: Small Models Have Arrived
#160A friend of mine told me earlier today that they had a discussion at work (a coding shop) about "downgrading" to luna from sol for cost reasons and that many were quite unhappy about this because they didn't want inferior tech to be forced upon them. Do they have a point? Is sol actually worth the extra cost? Especially if you ramp up the effort level?
Luna as a doer, with a smarter model planning, can be a good compromise. Using sol for everything can be expensive without much gain, as a lot of steps don't need that sort of intelligence.