Live data from Hacker News

The great blogging collapse: What happened to 100 successful blogs?

danielstanica.com

151–160 of 191 posts

Re: The great blogging collapse: What happened to 100 successful blogs?

#151

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Illusion of learning is more important than actually learning stuff to many.

I prefer to separate it as "casual learning/curiosity" and "intentional learning" rather than something so crass. I'd admit to being an enjoyer of both, I have no dreams or illusions about me becoming civil engineer or city planner just because I like watching those sort of videos, even though they're informative as well as mostly just entertainment with unreliable narrators. As long as you're conscious about what mo…

Well, I was talking about myself. I used to learn mostly through videos, but I often struggled to apply what I'd watched. Over time, I realized I learn best by reading, writing, and actually putting things into practice, rather than passively consuming videos. Videos often gave me the illusion that I was learning, but later I'd have trouble recalling or using what I'd learned. I don't have that problem with text.

Re: The great blogging collapse: What happened to 100 successful blogs?

#152

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Mommy bloggers was probably the most ludicrous niche back then. Tons of consumer companies wanted to pay them to promote their product or have a “giveaway”

And if "mommy" content is no longer popular in blog form, then, anecdotally, it's found a new, lucrative medium in short-form videos a la Tiktok.

Popular probably, lucrative unlikely

Re: The great blogging collapse: What happened to 100 successful blogs?

#153
I was around when blogging started and I've seen a lot of blogs come and go. The web was a much different place then and it was easier to attract and hold an audience than it is now. It's still possible to have a successful blog but it will never be as easy as it was in 2000.

Re: The great blogging collapse: What happened to 100 successful blogs?

#154
post #31

No mention of Substack? Making money from paying subscribers has different trade-offs than making money from ads, but my read is that mostly traffic moved vs evaporated. But I do expect this to change further with AI, where as the author says, a blog needs to add something new and not just try to answer a question someone might search for. There's also no discussion of how blogging has always been somewhat frothy: pi…

I’m curious why many tech bloggers choose Substack, when it’s almost trivial to set up your own blog with infinitely more style control, and math/syntax-highlighting etc.

Re: The great blogging collapse: What happened to 100 successful blogs?

#155
post #107

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Your post is a red herring, some platforms simply replaced bespoke blogging websites. How would I, without any special services, consume multiple blogs today? It's so much easier with instagram/social media.

> consume multiple blogs today? It's so much easier with instagram/social media I beg to differ. Follow 12 “people” on Insta and you’re just telling the algorithm you’re into parent stuff, or fashion, or makeup, or cars, or attractive women, or attractive men. It’s not like even 50% of what they serve you will BE those 12 people you followed. Most of what you get will be related to the same niches, but it’ll be from…

Yeah but nobody uses RSS, which universe are you living in?

I love the idea of RSS yes.

Re: The great blogging collapse: What happened to 100 successful blogs?

#156

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Your post is a red herring, some platforms simply replaced bespoke blogging websites. How would I, without any special services, consume multiple blogs today? It's so much easier with instagram/social media.

RSS.

I know about RSS, do your users know about RSS? Does a gradpa from midwest looking for a steak recipe care about RSS?

Re: The great blogging collapse: What happened to 100 successful blogs?

#157

Earlier quoted context omitted.

RSS.

Correct. It does not require a "service" to consume multiple blogs efficiently, just simply "software" (an app will do). The below RSS readers pretty much do their job and get out of the user's way. What's amazing is the sheer number of RSS readers that people choose to use; there are so many, people find ones that they personally like. On desktop: Vienna https://www.vienna-rss.com/ On iOS: R2SReader https://apps.app…

None of that matters since instagram has more users etc. Jesus, the question is "why blogs disappear" - they disappear because users don't care about the value proposition of your RSS app. Most of them are quite shit anyway - little commonality in terms of styling etc.

Re: The great blogging collapse: What happened to 100 successful blogs?

#158
post #107

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> consume multiple blogs today? It's so much easier with instagram/social media I beg to differ. Follow 12 “people” on Insta and you’re just telling the algorithm you’re into parent stuff, or fashion, or makeup, or cars, or attractive women, or attractive men. It’s not like even 50% of what they serve you will BE those 12 people you followed. Most of what you get will be related to the same niches, but it’ll be from…

Yeah but nobody uses RSS, which universe are you living in? I love the idea of RSS yes.

I use RSS, it's great! Why aren't you using RSS?

Re: The great blogging collapse: What happened to 100 successful blogs?

#159
post #31

No mention of Substack? Making money from paying subscribers has different trade-offs than making money from ads, but my read is that mostly traffic moved vs evaporated. But I do expect this to change further with AI, where as the author says, a blog needs to add something new and not just try to answer a question someone might search for. There's also no discussion of how blogging has always been somewhat frothy: pi…

I’m curious why many tech bloggers choose Substack, when it’s almost trivial to set up your own blog with infinitely more style control, and math/syntax-highlighting etc.

Substack handles emailing and payments well. Many people want to receive posts by email, which is a pain to do on your own with high deliverability. Some are willing to pay for it, and payments are similarly annoying (and benefit from a familiar interface, which Substack now provides).

Re: The great blogging collapse: What happened to 100 successful blogs?

#160

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I’ll say this with certainty, video is terrible reference material. Talk me through something the first time, sure, but if I need to look something up (yes, I know asking an LLM is available) I want a comprehensive subject guide, mostly in text, searchable by actual keywords.

I think parent is trying to make the point that yes, for you video is a terrible reference material. For me too, but some people do keep links to videos and look up things that way, as surprising and counter-intuitive (to us ) that may be.

Nobody said they do that though? Weird comment from my perspective.

They said they learn from them, not that they are effective references. I’m not buying the “us and them” or to each their own on this one, sight unseen. Do you have an example?

I mean of course you can go back to a point in time in a video, if you index a transcript and ignore the weird narration and wait through the typing sounds, OCR whatever comes up on the screen to copy and paste and need animations to be reminded you are supposed to pay attention, and you are aligned with the video feed algorithm.

I’m not trying to stop anyone.

Post reply on HN