Live data from Hacker News

Mexican government unveils a prototype for a new homegrown, ultra-affordable EV

gizmodo.com

151–160 of 217 posts

Re: Mexican government unveils a prototype for a new homegrown, ultra-affordable EV

#151

The Ford CEO is not wrong. Allowing foreign imports into the country at prices far below what US producers are able to make will decimate the local car industry in the US. There are 4 possible solutions to this problem; a) convince Americans that it's worth paying more for a locally built product. This is the simplest approach, but there's only so much margin here that the consumer will tolerate. At the moment this g…

[dead]

Re: Mexican government unveils a prototype for a new homegrown, ultra-affordable EV

#152

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> In the US, a range of 77 miles is a complete non starter. You'd have to charge it every single day. If not multiple times a day in some peoples cases. It's true that some people drive more than 77 miles per day. But a pretty big chunk of people never do, except road trips/vacations. It could easily be worth it to buy a cheap EV for everyday use and then rent a vehicle for long trips.

(2014 Leaf leaseholder here) At the time we were a 2-car household and used the gas car for longer trips. That being said, there were a few times we had to scramble: Once, when it was very cold my wife and I both needed to drive a long distance. I took the Leaf because I had access to a charger. On our last year of the lease we ended up having to move 90 miles away. When we bought the Leaf, we never planned on drivin…

We considered getting a used Leaf but my wife had too much range anxiety, even for vehicles with 70 miles of range. I plotted out on a map how many trips she would have to take in a day (to work, to doctor, to pick up kid, to dentist, to store, etc.) in order to come even close to 70 miles. Of course, she never goes that far around town (only when visiting relatives, when I typically drive and we take a PHEV). But the RA was too great, so we got another PHEV. It has been useful at times to be able to both go 50+ miles in a day without any concern, but it's literally a handful of times over the years.

Re: Mexican government unveils a prototype for a new homegrown, ultra-affordable EV

#153
post #30

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> In the US, a range of 77 miles is a complete non starter. You'd have to charge it every single day. If not multiple times a day in some peoples cases. It's true that some people drive more than 77 miles per day. But a pretty big chunk of people never do, except road trips/vacations. It could easily be worth it to buy a cheap EV for everyday use and then rent a vehicle for long trips.

Or you own more than vehicle. Plenty of families own multiple vehicles, and they don't all need to have tons of range.

> Or you own more than vehicle. Plenty of families own multiple vehicles, and they don't all need to have tons of range.

I wish there still were small and very cheap EVs to fill this niche.

We had the Fiat 500e (somewhat infamous) $82 lease as an extra car because for $0 down and $82/month, why not. Range was small but it was perfect for around town, and had other cars for other things. Anytime I was driving within town I'd just take the Fiat.

Re: Mexican government unveils a prototype for a new homegrown, ultra-affordable EV

#154

The Ford CEO is not wrong. Allowing foreign imports into the country at prices far below what US producers are able to make will decimate the local car industry in the US. There are 4 possible solutions to this problem; a) convince Americans that it's worth paying more for a locally built product. This is the simplest approach, but there's only so much margin here that the consumer will tolerate. At the moment this g…

Why is decimating our local car industry a problem? Why not build something else with the resources if cars are now a cheap commodity?

[deleted]

Re: Mexican government unveils a prototype for a new homegrown, ultra-affordable EV

#155

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I see this take on SUVs all the time, and I can't help but think it's wrong. Americans just like bigger vehicles and will downsize if gas gets too expensive. There's a reason almost all electric car companies start off with a CUV/SUV/truck, and it's not because they're allergic to sedans or coupes.

- Tesla, the most prominent and successful EV company, didn’t start with a truck. - Neither did all the attempts at EVs from other competitors in the 2010s, like the GM Bolt/Volt or the Nissan Leaf. - But you’re not wrong, that today EV companies usually start with SUVs/CUVs, but that’s because a larger chassis makes it easier to include a large enough battery.

Back in the 2010s, EVs were primarily sold to customers that were more likely to be averse to SUVs for the perceived environmental impact and, frankly, snobbery (liberals of the time used to mock big SUVs like the Cadillac Escalade and the Hummer, particularly after they got associated with the timespan of the Bush administration before becoming uneconomical after the late 2000s oil price spike). Also the batteries just didn't have enough capacity at a reasonable price to build anything heavier than a sedan.

As soon as it was feasible, Tesla released a CUV (the Model Y) which now outsells the Model 3 almost 2-to-1. Arguably Tesla has fumbled by letting Elon pursue the Cybertruck rather than a full-sized SUV or normal pickup truck. You can observe that Rivian went after precisely those missing models.

Re: Mexican government unveils a prototype for a new homegrown, ultra-affordable EV

#156

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I think you wildly overestimate how many Americans are white-collar workers commuting 100 miles to a 6-figure job. A remotely aiming at that market to begin with.

With a range of 77 miles, I wouldn't make it to work and back. Everyone I know (yes, it's anecdotal, but a widely-shared one) has to commute on roads where the average speed is well above 30mph. This is a non-starter for the US.

[deleted]

Re: Mexican government unveils a prototype for a new homegrown, ultra-affordable EV

#157
post #94

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I agree with you, for the mass consumer car market (individual/family transport) as a whole. It's coming fast. However, the current EV technology (mostly batteries + charging) is not a good fit for a whole lot of edge cases, and in the aggregate they matter, too, and thus the ICE engine industry won't really go away anytime soon: * General-purpose Semis for commercial hauling. Yes, there's some EV Semis on the road t…

Look, sure. No one is saying "no ICE ever". Some people still ride horses. 125 years ago cities were built around horses. Stabling. Breeding. Feeding. Grooming. Street cleaning (turns our horses poop a Lot). By 20 years later that's all gone . Sure horses survived in rural areas. Sure the Amish use them today as then. But the horse-based industry has (in real terms) vanished. ICE is headed the same way. It will exist…

It's not quite that simple though. A lot of these edge cases are necessary for everyone to live their cushy little city lives. It's not a matter of outmoded things. We will still need ambulances, and we will still need livestock trailers, and everything else on my list, for all of the foreseeable future. Unless batteries and charging gets a lot better, we'll still be manufacturing and improving ICE engines for many applications. Just not simple passenger cars.

Re: Mexican government unveils a prototype for a new homegrown, ultra-affordable EV

#158

My first thought when looking at it is that I doubt the vehicle could pass US safety regulations. Maybe I'm wrong.

In Europe these kinds of vehicles are treated as micro vehicles. You don’t even need a driver licenses.

https://insideevs.com/news/401218/citroen-ami-deliveries-jun...

Re: Mexican government unveils a prototype for a new homegrown, ultra-affordable EV

#159
post #3

> It remains to be seen whether the Olinia One will face similar pushback from the U.S. once it goes on sale. > can travel up to 125 kilometers (77 miles) on a single charge The US market generally rejects small-range EVs, except in very niche markets. In order to succeed in the US, it will need roughly 3-4x the range. In order for this to succeed in Mexico, their market will need different driving habits than the ty…

77 miles is nigh useless. Realistically that means you get 40 worry free miles. It’s ridiculous.

Re: Mexican government unveils a prototype for a new homegrown, ultra-affordable EV

#160
post #41

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Would have to be very affordable. Like well under $10K. Otherwise I'll just buy a used ICE vehicle and have a lot more flexibility in how I use it.

Even Cargo Bicycles cost more than $10k. I think a 6 seater people mover is worth far more than those. I'd buy a 6 seater with this range but not with the speed limitations (I think it is like 50-60 kph which is a non starter)

You can buy used ICE cars for $10k easy.

Like really really easy.

Apologies if I missed your point.

Post reply on HN