Live data from Hacker News

Ted Chiang: The Secret Third Thing

linch.substack.com

151–152 of 152 posts

Re: Ted Chiang: The Secret Third Thing

#151

> The ability to send bits across parallel universes is just insane in terms of economic and experimentation value. For example, pharmaceutical companies can do $100 billion trials for all sorts of novel drugs, and trade the results of this information with their clones in other universes. I remember reading this short story and being obsessed with the consequences. It immediately solves P = NP, and makes guarding se…

If you like explorations of the deep impacts of parallel universes which have bridges that lets you transport bits (but not matter), you might enjoy https://brainchip.thecomicseries.com/

I like some of Yudkowsky's shorter fiction but I could never get into HPMOR. The writing style just comes across as too smarmy. I know it's intentional but I still can't get past it (I had trouble with Thomas Covenant) as well.

Re: Ted Chiang: The Secret Third Thing

#152

I love Ted Chiang and re-read his stories every few years. Most of author's criticisms arise from their refusal to accept that Chiang's stories are mostly science fantasy[1][2], and not some third option. Most/all of the stories primarily focus on characters and relationships on the macro and micro. In each story, the gimmick(tm) is thoroughly examined and extrapolated in an internally-consistant way, but that is exc…

I have heard approximately equal number of comments that Chiang's writings are clearly hard sci-fi and that his stories are clearly science fantasy.

I find my own ontology to be useful for myself and others, but I don't begrudge others their preferred definitions.

Post reply on HN