Live data from Hacker News

Deepseek: The quiet giant leading China’s AI race

chinatalk.media

151–160 of 476 posts

Re: Deepseek: The quiet giant leading China’s AI race

#151

I find that the gushing around deepseek is fascinating to watch. To me there are a few structural and fundamental reasons why deepseek can never outperform other models by a wide margin. On par maybe--as we reach the diminishing returns with our investment in the models, but not win by a wide margin. 1. The US trade war with china which will place deepseek compute availability at disadvantages, eventually, if we ever…

> The US trade war with china which will place deepseek compute availability at disadvantages I doubt it'll make much difference. Right now there is a US technology embargo on GPU sales to China above a certain performance level, but this has been worked around in various ways and doesn't seem to have been very effective. At the end of the day higher performance GPUs only serve to keep the cost of a cluster down vs u…

[dead]

Re: Deepseek: The quiet giant leading China’s AI race

#152

I find that the gushing around deepseek is fascinating to watch. To me there are a few structural and fundamental reasons why deepseek can never outperform other models by a wide margin. On par maybe--as we reach the diminishing returns with our investment in the models, but not win by a wide margin. 1. The US trade war with china which will place deepseek compute availability at disadvantages, eventually, if we ever…

> The US trade war with china which will place deepseek compute availability at disadvantages I doubt it'll make much difference. Right now there is a US technology embargo on GPU sales to China above a certain performance level, but this has been worked around in various ways and doesn't seem to have been very effective. At the end of the day higher performance GPUs only serve to keep the cost of a cluster down vs u…

Not only that, but having a constraint often feeds innovation. Having to work with less compute might mean new ways of doing things that leads to faster iteration, etc.

Re: Deepseek: The quiet giant leading China’s AI race

#153

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Yes, but there should be a difference between providing answers about provably dangerous things and providing provably false answers for political reasons. For example if there is a Russian LLM that refuses to answer any questions about homosexuality while also saying it's wrong, that's demonstrably false from an empirical basis. But the western LLM's are also doing this latter type of thing already. If you ask any o…

Western LLMs have a bias when it comes to Israel and Palestine issue. Out of curiously, what part of the Quran do you consider controversial?

[deleted]

Re: Deepseek: The quiet giant leading China’s AI race

#154

I find that the gushing around deepseek is fascinating to watch. To me there are a few structural and fundamental reasons why deepseek can never outperform other models by a wide margin. On par maybe--as we reach the diminishing returns with our investment in the models, but not win by a wide margin. 1. The US trade war with china which will place deepseek compute availability at disadvantages, eventually, if we ever…

> ... why deepseek can never outperform ... This read more like a "western supremacists" post. 1. Only until China produces more compute than the west. 2. You don't have to ask ChatGPT / Claude many questions before realizing the grave censorship these are under - DeepSeek has access the roughly the same corpus of data as their western counter parts. 3. It is naive to think they only develop open source or will not s…

[deleted]

Re: Deepseek: The quiet giant leading China’s AI race

#155

I find that the gushing around deepseek is fascinating to watch. To me there are a few structural and fundamental reasons why deepseek can never outperform other models by a wide margin. On par maybe--as we reach the diminishing returns with our investment in the models, but not win by a wide margin. 1. The US trade war with china which will place deepseek compute availability at disadvantages, eventually, if we ever…

> China censorship which limits the deepseek data ingestion and output, to some degree.

We just call it alignment research instead. Same pig, different shade of lipstick.

Re: Deepseek: The quiet giant leading China’s AI race

#156
To this day, asking Deepseek "what model are you" typically gives the answer

"I'm an AI language model called ChatGPT, created by OpenAI. Specifically, I'm based on the GPT-4 architecture, which is designed to understand and generate human-like text based on the input I receive. My training data includes a wide range of information up until October 2023, and I can assist with answering questions, generating text, and much more. How can I help you today?"

this tells us something about using synthetic data to bootstrap new model. All those clauses in the terms of service about not using the model to develop competing UI? Yeah, good luck with that.

Re: Deepseek: The quiet giant leading China’s AI race

#157

To this day, asking Deepseek "what model are you" typically gives the answer "I'm an AI language model called ChatGPT, created by OpenAI. Specifically, I'm based on the GPT-4 architecture, which is designed to understand and generate human-like text based on the input I receive. My training data includes a wide range of information up until October 2023, and I can assist with answering questions, generating text, and…

And you can ask it if it's sure, and it'll consistently double down on insisting it's ChatGPT. Ask it what country it's developed in, and it'll say US; ask it if it's sure it's not China, and it'll be sure.

Re: Deepseek: The quiet giant leading China’s AI race

#158

To this day, asking Deepseek "what model are you" typically gives the answer "I'm an AI language model called ChatGPT, created by OpenAI. Specifically, I'm based on the GPT-4 architecture, which is designed to understand and generate human-like text based on the input I receive. My training data includes a wide range of information up until October 2023, and I can assist with answering questions, generating text, and…

I'm sure OpenAI breaches copyright just as well. They are just a little bit better at hiding it.
Post reply on HN