>The scrapers themselves already happily ignore copyright, they won't be inclined to obey a no-ai.txt.
Name two entities that were asked to stop using a given individuals' images that failed to stop using them after the stop request was issued.
>Currently I see no organisation who would be willing to do this or even just technologically able - as even just detecting such scrapers is an extremely hard task.
// Part of Image Web Scraper For AI Image Generator ingestion psuedocode:
if fileExists("no-ai.txt") {
// Abort image scraping for this site -- move on to the next site
} else {
// Continue image scraping for this site
};
See? Nice and simple!
Also -- let me ask you this -- what happens to the intellectual property (or just plain property) rights of Images on the web after the author dies? Or say, 50 years (or whatever the legal copyright timeout is) after the author dies?
Legal grey area perhaps?
Also -- what about Images that exist in other legal jurisdictions -- i.e., other countries?
How do we know what set of laws are to apply to a given image?
?
Point is: If you're going to endorse and/or construct a legal framework (and have it be binding -- keep in mind you're going to have to traverse the legal jurisdictions of many countries, many countries!) -- you might as well consider such issues.
Also -- at least in the United States, we have Juries that can override any Law (Separation of Powers) -- that is, that which is considered "legally binding" -- may not be quite so "legally binding" if/when properly explained to a proper jury in light of extenuating (or just plain other) circumstances!
So kindly think of these issues prior to making all-encompasing proposals as to what you think should be "legally binding" or not.
I comprehend that you are just trying to solve a problem; I comprehend and empathize; but the problem might be a bit greater than you think, and there might be one if not serveral unexplored partial/better (since no one solution, legal or otherwise, will be all-encompassing) solutions -- because the problem is so large in scope -- but all of these issues must be considered in parallel -- or errors, present or future will occur...