Hacker News Board Hacker News, browsed like a classic message board
Live data from Hacker News

Suno AI

suno.ai

Post reply on HN
Print view View original

151–160 of 171 posts

Re: Suno AI

#151

Post by consumer451 »

mcamac wrote: post #149
consumer451 wrote: post #134

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Another piece of feedback which might save you server costs: On /create/ in custom mode, after tapping the Create button, I feel like I should be shown the progress in the Library to see the result processing. I am surely more likely to want to see the output after Create is tapped than to stay at that screen to create another immediately without see the previous result. When not in custom mode, the user sees the pro…

Hey thanks, there's a loading indicator around the image, but agree it could be more clear about processing and progress!

Thanks for responding, and also thanks for making a truly useful product for people who communicate via music. You made a significant difference in my life.

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38753465

Re: Suno AI

#152

Post by [deleted] »

consumer451 wrote: post #139

Using Suno(custom) and ChatGPT [0] + editing - I just helped heal a lost friendship. I had no way to break the ice of our lost friensdhip for two years now. But this did it. I was finally able to communicate what happened and I finally got a response from him. I cannot describe how important this was for me. Thank you. I already subbed, but I would pay a lot of money to get the remainder of the song. Don't make me op…

[deleted]

Re: Suno AI

#153

Post by consumer451 »

consumer451 wrote: post #139

Using Suno(custom) and ChatGPT [0] + editing - I just helped heal a lost friendship. I had no way to break the ice of our lost friensdhip for two years now. But this did it. I was finally able to communicate what happened and I finally got a response from him. I cannot describe how important this was for me. Thank you. I already subbed, but I would pay a lot of money to get the remainder of the song. Don't make me op…

Whoa! Did you guys just change the voicing that is singing in the link? Wait, did the track change entirely? Does this happen every so often?

I don't get it. Why would it regen? Should I be saving audio and sharing it via GDrive or whatever at every interesting playback?

I was replaying this track all night long. Then suddenly the linked song was different. This is not good UX. I shared it with my friend, which version will they hear?

Each time I hit Create, it should make a unique waveform. Crappy from an ML pov, or not. This is all a matter of listener preference. Sometimes artifacts are cool.

Each shared link should be a unique "printed" MP3 distributed via CDN, right? Or, am I being silly, and why? This also sounds so much cheaper as far as server costs, doesn't it?

Last of all, I love this entire thing. If you have any room in hiring, I have spectral opinions and would love to be involved.

Re: Suno AI

#154

Post by 93po »

I love this product, the discord community sort of seems like a dumpster fire though

Re: Suno AI

#155

Post by JonathanFly »

93po wrote: post #154

I love this product, the discord community sort of seems like a dumpster fire though

> I love this product, the discord community sort of seems like a dumpster fire though

Do you mind saying more? (via dm if you like, I'm in that Discord same name)

Re: Suno AI

#156

Post by consumer451 »

mcamac wrote: post #149
consumer451 wrote: post #134

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Another piece of feedback which might save you server costs: On /create/ in custom mode, after tapping the Create button, I feel like I should be shown the progress in the Library to see the result processing. I am surely more likely to want to see the output after Create is tapped than to stay at that screen to create another immediately without see the previous result. When not in custom mode, the user sees the pro…

Hey thanks, there's a loading indicator around the image, but agree it could be more clear about processing and progress!

I would like to add one more thing, only because I care a lot about the product:

A shared song link should be a waveform print, and not change in any way in the future. Otherwise, how do I know what I am sharing?

I would imagine the the models may be changing, but now that you are public, you need to lock this aspect of the UX down.

https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=38754720

Re: Suno AI

#157

Post by mcamac »

consumer451 wrote: post #153
consumer451 wrote: post #139

Using Suno(custom) and ChatGPT [0] + editing - I just helped heal a lost friendship. I had no way to break the ice of our lost friensdhip for two years now. But this did it. I was finally able to communicate what happened and I finally got a response from him. I cannot describe how important this was for me. Thank you. I already subbed, but I would pay a lot of money to get the remainder of the song. Don't make me op…

Whoa! Did you guys just change the voicing that is singing in the link? Wait, did the track change entirely? Does this happen every so often? I don't get it. Why would it regen? Should I be saving audio and sharing it via GDrive or whatever at every interesting playback? I was replaying this track all night long. Then suddenly the linked song was different. This is not good UX. I shared it with my friend, which versi…

We do make 2 songs per create, so perhaps you could be looking at the other one? We don't regen/overwrite...

Re: Suno AI

#158

Post by consumer451 »

mcamac wrote: post #157
consumer451 wrote: post #153

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Whoa! Did you guys just change the voicing that is singing in the link? Wait, did the track change entirely? Does this happen every so often? I don't get it. Why would it regen? Should I be saving audio and sharing it via GDrive or whatever at every interesting playback? I was replaying this track all night long. Then suddenly the linked song was different. This is not good UX. I shared it with my friend, which versi…

We do make 2 songs per create, so perhaps you could be looking at the other one? We don't regen/overwrite...

I was just pressing play over and over on the amazing song that you (we) created.

I eventually heard multiple versions, it could have been the Czech beers.. but I heard different tracks.

However, I will take you work word for it if that is truly impossible.

Re: Suno AI

#159

Post by mcamac »

consumer451 wrote: post #158
mcamac wrote: post #157

Earlier quoted context omitted.

We do make 2 songs per create, so perhaps you could be looking at the other one? We don't regen/overwrite...

I was just pressing play over and over on the amazing song that you (we) created. I eventually heard multiple versions, it could have been the Czech beers.. but I heard different tracks. However, I will take you work word for it if that is truly impossible.

If you scroll through your library (https://app.suno.ai/me/) you can probably see multiple versions if you did make them ... eventually we'll have search :)

Re: Suno AI

#160

Post by 93po »

JonathanFly wrote: post #155
93po wrote: post #154

I love this product, the discord community sort of seems like a dumpster fire though

> I love this product, the discord community sort of seems like a dumpster fire though Do you mind saying more? (via dm if you like, I'm in that Discord same name)

One of the moderators seemed to be relatively argumentative for no reason, guessing they're sort of young
Post reply on HN