Live data from Hacker News

The underground economy of Glassdoor reviews

careerfair.io

151–160 of 160 posts

Re: The underground economy of Glassdoor reviews

#151

I believe that Glassdoor exists almost purely because salary information is not public. While company reputation and reviews are of interest, the salary information is likely much more a driver of traffic. And based on my attempted use of the site, Glassdoor is unreliable and (intentionally) misleading. Even at the most basic level, their UI flatly lies about what data they possess. If you search a company, in the sa…

When I search a job, I'd like to know both work environment and the salary, in the end both are really important

Re: The underground economy of Glassdoor reviews

#153
post #143

Earlier quoted context omitted.

This is absolutely crazy to a European.

Really? How would European business culture approach this? I feel like talking about debating religion when it’s not relevant to a potential employee is extremely short sighted or some type of backhanded mind game; it just doesn’t seem normal to say that at a job interview. After a working relationship has been established if it comes up, that is different, but if the VP just says that based on seeing a potential emp…

I'd happily talk religion, trans rights, racism etc with anyone at work.

But then I'm not paranoid , and Ive never worked anyplace in 20 years where I feel people are being dishonest or disingenuous or playing any sort of games. especially not mind games, that's fucking absurd to me that you would even think that at all.

What sort of people are you working for, that sounds like hell.

I've always been in offices, and worked for managers I've gone and got drunk with and talked about all sorts of shit. it's never been an issue.

If US office culture Is as you describe it, it sounds fucking awful.

Re: The underground economy of Glassdoor reviews

#154

I used to work at Desktop Metal which was (at the time) a pretty small startup here in Boston. When I left, I wrote a pretty negative review on Glassdoor about what I felt was a toxic work environment. At the time I submitted my review, there were probably about 10 reviews for the company. The very next day after my review was posted, about 7 positive reviews popped up. Obviously pretty suspicious behavior, but when…

Sounds like target.com

I ordered a play kitchen based on reviews and then I found it to be poor quality, I wrote a review which was never published without any reason given

As such, I don't really trust positive reviews anymore, especially, there

I only mostly trust yelp reviews

Re: The underground economy of Glassdoor reviews

#155

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Wire cutter is hardly objective - check out their bike lock reviews. Every single recommended product is from Kryptonite.

On youtube there are videos from an expert lockpicker, I can't remember the name, where he goes on lockpicking kryptonite locks. He explains in great detail what he expected more from the high end, but his recommendation by the end was still a kryptonite lock, not necessary the ultimate, and said that unless you are ready to lose the bike, unless it's in sight, there is very little you can do. And with an angle grind…

That would be the Lockpicking Lawyer.

Re: The underground economy of Glassdoor reviews

#156
post #153

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Really? How would European business culture approach this? I feel like talking about debating religion when it’s not relevant to a potential employee is extremely short sighted or some type of backhanded mind game; it just doesn’t seem normal to say that at a job interview. After a working relationship has been established if it comes up, that is different, but if the VP just says that based on seeing a potential emp…

I'd happily talk religion, trans rights, racism etc with anyone at work. But then I'm not paranoid , and Ive never worked anyplace in 20 years where I feel people are being dishonest or disingenuous or playing any sort of games. especially not mind games, that's fucking absurd to me that you would even think that at all. What sort of people are you working for, that sounds like hell. I've always been in offices, and…

All those topics sound like minefields I would be cautious discussion even with good friends, and then only if we have similar views. If I knew there would be a significant disagreement I would drop the topic probably, avoids more trouble.

I think it’s about minimizing liability. I wouldn’t want a work dynamic to turn toxic due to a coworker’s prejudice or some disagreement we had debating over the water cooler. At work you focus on work, sure you can have some chit chat but generally these topics are breached after being acquainted with someone.

Re: The underground economy of Glassdoor reviews

#157
post #154

I used to work at Desktop Metal which was (at the time) a pretty small startup here in Boston. When I left, I wrote a pretty negative review on Glassdoor about what I felt was a toxic work environment. At the time I submitted my review, there were probably about 10 reviews for the company. The very next day after my review was posted, about 7 positive reviews popped up. Obviously pretty suspicious behavior, but when…

Sounds like target.com I ordered a play kitchen based on reviews and then I found it to be poor quality, I wrote a review which was never published without any reason given As such, I don't really trust positive reviews anymore, especially, there I only mostly trust yelp reviews

[dead]

Re: The underground economy of Glassdoor reviews

#158

Earlier quoted context omitted.

On youtube there are videos from an expert lockpicker, I can't remember the name, where he goes on lockpicking kryptonite locks. He explains in great detail what he expected more from the high end, but his recommendation by the end was still a kryptonite lock, not necessary the ultimate, and said that unless you are ready to lose the bike, unless it's in sight, there is very little you can do. And with an angle grind…

That would be the Lockpicking Lawyer.

That's the one indeed!

Re: The underground economy of Glassdoor reviews

#159
post #153

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I'd happily talk religion, trans rights, racism etc with anyone at work. But then I'm not paranoid , and Ive never worked anyplace in 20 years where I feel people are being dishonest or disingenuous or playing any sort of games. especially not mind games, that's fucking absurd to me that you would even think that at all. What sort of people are you working for, that sounds like hell. I've always been in offices, and…

All those topics sound like minefields I would be cautious discussion even with good friends, and then only if we have similar views. If I knew there would be a significant disagreement I would drop the topic probably, avoids more trouble. I think it’s about minimizing liability. I wouldn’t want a work dynamic to turn toxic due to a coworker’s prejudice or some disagreement we had debating over the water cooler. At w…

[deleted]

Re: The underground economy of Glassdoor reviews

#160
post #135

We had a nasty review from one ex employee and in Germany it was easy to find a cheap lawyer/agency who wrote a letter to glassdoor demanding removal and a few days later the negative review was gone.

Was the review truthful?

From his perspective yes, objectively I'd say half of it was reasonable
Post reply on HN