Live data from Hacker News

Ideas That Changed My Life

perell.com

151–160 of 160 posts

Re: Ideas That Changed My Life

#151

Earlier quoted context omitted.

This is a known problem in math, it's called a local maximum. It's a function of where you start on the graph. Experience and understanding can let you start in a different place on the graph that may be less efficient but have a higher local maximum.

but you don't usually just jump from one peak to another. there's series of repeat failures that have to happen to get to the next mountain to traverse(usually there could be point solutions I suppose)

With optimization functions, the general process is pick a point, iterate until a local maximum, pick a new point, iterate until a local maximum, and repeat until you have an answer you're comfortable with. You might run out of time, or evaluate enough of the space that you're confident you've found an anawer.

When you apply the same idea to iterating on a product, or an engineering problem, the end result of your iteration depends on you choosing a good starting point. that's where experience comes in - you don't start all the way at the beginning, you start at the place where you know you can iterate to higher maximum. You've already had those repeat failures in the past.

A slightly silly but less abstract example. Let's say im brought in to a company to help solve the problem that the developers can't work on the project together because they can't share code.

_A_ starting point is a network drive, and you can iterate on that with file locks and faster networks, but you hit a local maximum. You then decide to use a database or something, and eventually you reinvent CVS.

Meanwhile, an experienced developer will skip all of that and start with git, and iterate on things like code review, merge pipelines.

Iteration is still key.

Re: Ideas That Changed My Life

#152
post #149

Earlier quoted context omitted.

>Why did they choose “journalists” when the “death tax” narrative was created by politicians, a much better example group for this conjugation. I think for the same reason people blame web developers for how websites are built, ignoring that the web developer is not the product manager.

To be fair, groupthink in web design has generally led to worse performance with 100kb pageloads to show 1kb of content, and this blame generally does not reside with the product manager.

I'd say that the incentives are aligned in a way that produced the outcome of website bloat. The churn of hardware enables it, service providers have different priorities, and frankly, 99.99% of the users also have different priorities. So, no one is really striving for less bloated pages - including, most importantly, the product managers, whom have all the say of how developer capacity is allocated.

Re: Ideas That Changed My Life

#153
post #28

Earlier quoted context omitted.

What's the point? What one person needs at one point in their life is very unlikely to be what another person needs - it might appear banal or unintelligible to another.

In that case, we should all be viewing random sentences and hope something clicks.

Koans are kind of like that, at first glance.

Re: Ideas That Changed My Life

#154
post #107

Earlier quoted context omitted.

>Why did they choose “journalists” when the “death tax” narrative was created by politicians, a much better example group for this conjugation. I think for the same reason people blame web developers for how websites are built, ignoring that the web developer is not the product manager.

“I was just following orders.”

I believe in better designed systems, not in individual responsibility. Individual responsibility is a must have, but systemic incentives override that, on a population level, every time. But this can't only be used to build the Third Reich, it can be used for good things too, like building websites with less bloat. Such a change was when Google began to rank pages on loading and other performance criteria, and also provided a tool for people to check their sites. That was a nice incentive for the people who are actually in charge of websites, to have the people who actually build the websites, to build the website to be better.

But if the incentives are perverse, so will be the people.

Re: Ideas That Changed My Life

#155

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I wish there was a sizable center echo chamber, unfortunately there isn’t really one.

Its because the center failed to provide a path that people were satisfied with, hence there was movement away from the center into the fringes. It is entirely the center's fault that they are small. Maybe its just the end state of any sizable society.

Or perhaps it’s because the US system favors scale in a way that brought it down to the minimal number of political parties: 2.

Re: Ideas That Changed My Life

#156
post #116

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Could you explain how's that related to 51 ideas that are listed on the link? I'm struggling to see the connection you are seeing, can you clarify? Are the ideas mentioned worth less because you found a potential way to discredit the person listing them?

Opportunity cost. We'd do better to discuss something that wasn't GPT vomit. Especially this GPT vomit, which is not very good

So what you're saying is that what you wrote is correct and you should be trusted because... of what?

Given your nickname and attitude, how does one not conclude you're here to just be negative because you can?

Re: Ideas That Changed My Life

#157

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The ideas are simple and not particularly unique, but sometimes a list of simple but not unique ideas, which many of us already know, but nicely articulated in one place, can spark thought. If I took at as a deep philosophical treatise I might agree with you, but that isn’t what it is and I don’t think that makes it vomit.

These aren't even nicely articulated, they're poorly articulated and full of inaccuracies

To quote Luke Skywalker: everything you said is wrong

Re: Ideas That Changed My Life

#158
post #67
post #48

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Great insight about different kinds of rationality! Any recommendations to dive deeper into instrumental rationality topic?

I came across the idea on this website ( https://commoncog.com/start-here/ ), which I feel is far more "applied" than the Farnam Street blog ( https://fs.blog/ ). The latter is a distillation of essentially rationalist type mental models that sound good but often don't work in real life without a specific context (context really matters in real life). The specific part about rationality is here: https://commoncog.com…

Yep, its the only resource known to me that delves into these topics with a lot of ins & outs and its not just white & black business advice.

Re: Ideas That Changed My Life

#159

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Its because the center failed to provide a path that people were satisfied with, hence there was movement away from the center into the fringes. It is entirely the center's fault that they are small. Maybe its just the end state of any sizable society.

Or perhaps it’s because the US system favors scale in a way that brought it down to the minimal number of political parties: 2.

The parties reshuffle themselves every few decades. Yes in the American system, it is inflexible to have more than two parties but the parties themselves are quite malleable and are following changing trends even though it may not appear to be so day to day. See the movement of Republicans towards far right despite the party leadership trying to stop it (they failed). The same seems to be happening on the Democratic side with them trending towards the far left although that might take a few more election cycles to bear out.

Re: Ideas That Changed My Life

#160
post #92

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The Overton Window works as a concept when we all talk to each other. But we now have three separate echo chambers - "Left", "Right", "Center" - and they each have their own Overton Window.

I wish there was a sizable center echo chamber, unfortunately there isn’t really one.

That's because the center doesn't work for many things.

If you support individual patients making their own healthcare decisions with their doctors, how do you find the center with someone who wants to take that right away for reasons that have zero effect on them?

If you support a consenting adults right to love and marry whichever consenting adult they want, how do you find the center with someone who wants to tell people which consenting adults they can and can't marry?

If you think people should not be denied jobs or housing based solely on what's in the their pants, how do you find the center with people who think it's okay to deny people jobs and housing based on what's in their pants?

How do you find the center with the Nazi party?

The center is meaningless for most issues that actually matter.

Post reply on HN