Live data from Hacker News

GitHub Copilot for individuals available without waitlist, with free trial

github.com

151–153 of 153 posts

Re: GitHub Copilot for individuals available without waitlist, with free trial

#151

Anyone is interested in starting to work on an open source alternative? I have a few terabytes of GitHub repository archives, a bit of experience and an non-profit umbrella (goal is AI Safety).

pray tell, what about co-pilot is dangerous?

I think he hopes his Copilot competitor will be used to increase the safety of future AI systems that do not much resemble Copilot in purpose or architecture. (I agree with Eliezer that it will probably decrease safety on net despite his good intentions.)

Re: GitHub Copilot for individuals available without waitlist, with free trial

#152
post #148
post #29

Earlier quoted context omitted.

You don’t want to pay for it because you like free stuff. So does everyone. But that doesn’t pay the bills. You don’t need backcraft some moral argument. It’s trivial to see that a large amount of creativity went into developing the system, it’s not just a repackaging of public domain works.

Copilot's model is a derivative work of GPL-licensed code, but its source is not available anywhere, which violates the GPL.

Computers don’t violate licenses, people do. If you’re writing MIT code and copilot tells you to include Quake’s square root algorithm and you do so, that’s on you. If Google tells you to include Quake’s square root algorithm and you do so, it’s on you. If stack overflow tells you to do so and you do, that’s on you. In all of those cases it doesn’t matter whether the platform’s software is open source, why should it for copilot?

It’s the poorest of craftsmen who blames their tools. Rise above.

Also, note that simply accessing an online service does not constitute a distribution of software, and thus does not fall under GPL's domain. And "derivative" appears nowhere in the GPL.

Re: GitHub Copilot for individuals available without waitlist, with free trial

#153

Earlier quoted context omitted.

pray tell, what about co-pilot is dangerous?

I think he hopes his Copilot competitor will be used to increase the safety of future AI systems that do not much resemble Copilot in purpose or architecture. (I agree with Eliezer that it will probably decrease safety on net despite his good intentions.)

The Copilot or Google Collab are interesting as they allow to create wast datasets of developer's work sessions, incrementally, line-by-line editing and improving code. Exploiting such datasets have interesting potential. And currently that potential seems to be limited to Microsoft and Google.

It might be a good idea to have something in the open as well. But I agree, this has its disadvantages. Also chances of a small non-profit team coming close to Microsoft/Google's effort are near-zero. The amount of resources and time is incomparable.

Post reply on HN