Live data from Hacker News

Biden launches action on "Big Tech, Big Pharma, and Big Ag" – can it be real?

mattstoller.substack.com

151–160 of 595 posts

Re: Biden launches action on "Big Tech, Big Pharma, and Big Ag" – can it be real?

#151

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> The entire point of patents... Well, if that were so, you would expect them to be secret and to never expire. The fact that are published and expire after a relatively short period belies the simplicity of that statement.

Ever greening patents is standard practice today. This is why insulin is so expensive. Another good example is Disney's bs. They have kept thinks out of public domain for over a hundred years.. The 20 years thing is for the little guy, if he can ever afford the 50k patent and legal fees in the first place.

Disney is copywrite, not patent. Copywrite lasts 50 years past the creators death (was shorter, but Disney lobbied to have it extended).

Re: Biden launches action on "Big Tech, Big Pharma, and Big Ag" – can it be real?

#152
post #69

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Yeah, that used to be the point of patents. Now it seems it's mostly to squeeze as much out of people by capturing the majority of the market by not allowing similar products. I mean, we have CEOs of biomedical companies admitting that they aren't basing prices off of what it costs to research, develop, and deliver a therapy, but rather base it off of what a deaparare person is willing to pay for it. This is the very…

Agreed? Patents are being misused. We should fix that. Patents fixed gross injustices when they were created, and we shouldn't forget that, either. Software is probably the worst example of a field for patents and I think the case for patenting algorithms or design is dicey. But if you sink 100M into drug R&D, a novel type of medical device, or a new type of semiconductor CVD process you should have some protection a…

Drug companies spend more on marketing than on R&D. Much of the research is done with grants and government money. The vast majority of medical devices use the 510K process for approval, which means they are substantially similar to existing device (to bypass testing).

Sure some protection is necessary. You could make it based on development costs and have much shorter times for things that were cheap to do.

"maybe the problem is the role of money in politics and we should address the root cause. "

There are a lot of problems in politics that should be fixed - rules for thee but not for me (rule of law ignored), basically insider trading, high lifetime pensions, long careers, two party system, media bias/lies, and even problems in the voter base (us v them). Money is an issue, but it's really only good if the constituents are gullible or believe in the ends justifying the means. The real root of all of this is that politicians are a separate class from the rest of us and aren't accountable to anyone unless their transgressions are egregious, and then only sometimes. Rule of law has become a joke.

Re: Biden launches action on "Big Tech, Big Pharma, and Big Ag" – can it be real?

#153
post #89

Earlier quoted context omitted.

When they spent $400,000,000 on favorable monopolistic legislation it helps to aim the spotlight on anyone else.

What organization and legislation was that?

American Medical Association, aka physicians

Re: Biden launches action on "Big Tech, Big Pharma, and Big Ag" – can it be real?

#154

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It was not great before patents when a big company could steal your work and put you out of business after you put in the R&D effort.

As someone who started a business only to get a bullshit suit that I was unable to afford by one of the largest re insurance providers in the world (#1/2), the idea that the ip/patent legal framework as it is today helps the little guy is a slap in the face. They preemptively sued me in a state I've never worked in or entered for that matter because the favorable corporate law there, and that is why they have their h…

The court system is a joke. It has nothing to do with justice. On the criminal side, you can get a citation for a $500 fine and it's better to just plead guilty because a lawyer will cost you at least that much. It's a financial punishment even if you are innocent. If you don't hire a lawyer the judge won't take you seriously and call you names like "sovereign citizen". The number of mistakes and the amount of ignorance by the people running the system is repulsive and leads to violations of rights.

As just one laughable example, I had a magistrate think that requesting the case to be dismissed with prejudice was me calling him prejudice. You dont even need to have a law degree or pass the bar to be a magistrate.

Re: Biden launches action on "Big Tech, Big Pharma, and Big Ag" – can it be real?

#155
post #87

Earlier quoted context omitted.

As long as they're airtight they stay good for years. Some local producers sell small jars too. I mostly sell pint jars (1.4 lbs). I will probably switch to standard 1 lb jars soon.

> they stay good for years The lifespan is indefinite. If crystals start to form, you can heat the honey and it'll return to it's normal(?) state.

As long as it's air tight, sort of. They found honey that is safe to eat from the pyramids. I wouldn't recommend eating it as it probably doesn't taste good at all. The flavor will decrease after a while, but that generally takes years. Eventually it will taste bad, but that should take decades.

Re: Biden launches action on "Big Tech, Big Pharma, and Big Ag" – can it be real?

#156
post #89

Earlier quoted context omitted.

What organization and legislation was that?

American Medical Association, aka physicians

And what was the legislation? How was it monopolistic in favor of physicians?

The AMA does not really represent physicians. Less than 1/4 of doctors belong to the AMA. Many of them do not feel the AMA represents them. The AMA also accepts substantial donations from other sources, including corporate donors and foundations.

https://www.physiciansweekly.com/is-the-ama-really-the-voice...

Re: Biden launches action on "Big Tech, Big Pharma, and Big Ag" – can it be real?

#157
post #90
post #55

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Only for billing cost of procedures. It's still a mess. Did you know that hospitals make money by using name brand medications? They will get a contract with a brand, like Motrin, and charge you full price at $8 a pill. Then Motrin will will evaluate how much the hospital used and give them a big rebate to bring the hospital's cost down under $1 per pill. You can literally buy a bottle of ibuprofen for what they char…

I’m not sure what your point is. These contracts between seller and merchant were voluntary. There are other hospitals available should you choose, and if not then you have no one to blame but yourself.

I love how conservatives still make this argument. You're arguing for the free market in a system that literally isn't, and doing it in such a way that it tries to be a thought-terminating cliche.

If you get into a car accident tomorrow driving to work, the ambulance/paramedics aren't going to ask you to do your research prior to shuttling you to a hospital to get life saving treatment. Even if you could how would you be able to tell which hospital has what price structure, what services you'll actually need given your medical condition, and what arrangements they have with various drug manufacturers and how that relates to what you require to help your condition. Save it.. "no one to blame but yourself" is so incredibly idiotic is comical.

Take something even more benign, like someone falling and breaking/straining something. Wanna still do your research first? Is it a sprain, fracture, break? How do you know? Is it clear cut? What pain medication will you need? Will you require surgery? What lab work will you need? How many tests will you need? X-rays? CAT scan? MRI? What kind of surgeon? How many nurses? Will you require blood? Whats the recovery like? What about follow up visits? Do you expect us all to practice free market principles and know all that crap in advance for price discovery before deciding to seek treatment?

True free market principles require an asymmetry of information for the system to work, and even "fathers" of the theory understood that and acknowledge the need for regulation when its absent.

Re: Biden launches action on "Big Tech, Big Pharma, and Big Ag" – can it be real?

#158

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> Bose’s hearing aids were recently approved by the FDA, and they’re only $850. Only $850? That is a new use of the word only as far as I'm concerned. These things, which are in many ways similar to if not identical with bluetooth earbuds should not cost more than those - and given the fact that Apple managed to convince people that $200 is a normal price for these things that should leave more than enough margin for…

Traditionally, the cost for hearing aids runs in the thousands of dollars. Perfect is the enemy of good enough, progress takes time.

The only progress needed here is for the protection racket to be broken down, this can be done with the stroke of a pen. Allowing it to "take time" only gives those who seek to extract as much money as possible from the artificially limited market more time to do so.

Re: Biden launches action on "Big Tech, Big Pharma, and Big Ag" – can it be real?

#159

Earlier quoted context omitted.

But you don't need to be a monopoly or even a big company to have an awful feedlots, monocrop farming, ect.

What you say is true in theory but not in aggregate. It's no different from any other business in that respect. Look at companies in a field you are familiar with and you will find that the very large ones are a lot more impersonal, ruthlessly efficient, and amoral.

That's the huristic I'm pushing back on: Big = bad, efficient = bad, ect. Some problems are indeed exaserbated at scale, others are not. I think this is especially true for the ag industry and the issues mentioned up thread. You can bust up the biggest factory farms into 100 smaller companies, but they would still have the same practices. Same with monocrop farming.

Re: Biden launches action on "Big Tech, Big Pharma, and Big Ag" – can it be real?

#160

"Hearing aids cost thousands of dollars apiece, for no other reason than there is a cartel established by government that prevents firms from selling hearing aids without a prescription." An example of how many (most?) monopolies are able to exist because of some sort of legal authorization or protection. Regulatory capture. There are dozens of companies who would no doubt start making inexpensive hearing aids tomorr…

If it’s true that hearing aids shouldn’t need a prescription and can be made cheaply, shouldn’t it be easy for anyone who needs one to buy online from overseas? The same way you can get grey market viagra.
Post reply on HN