Live data from Hacker News

How Big Tech Is Importing India’s Caste Legacy to Silicon Valley

bloomberg.com

151–160 of 213 posts

Re: How Big Tech Is Importing India’s Caste Legacy to Silicon Valley

#151

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> It used to be truth seeking was important. There is truth to what Trump was saying. No, there is no truth. I consider all the hardworking people, including Mexicans, who harvest my fruits and vegetables, do construction and landscaping labor, work in meat processing plants, and any other task “to be the best”. How one can indict Mexico for the opiate problem rather than the pharmaceutical companies and doctors that…

> How one can indict Mexico for the opiate problem I never said this and neither did Trump. You should restate it to make sure you understand the real argument. If you notice I mentioned Oxy. Everyone shares some of the blame.

Then what purpose does the statement “Mexico is not sending their best” and endorsing that as the truth serve?

Re: How Big Tech Is Importing India’s Caste Legacy to Silicon Valley

#152

Prepare for serious astroturfing if this post gets any traction.

How so?

There are swathes of Indians who consider it their responsibility to push back against any content that is critical of certain topics. Caste being one of them. Have a look at any of the past threads [1]

[1]: https://hn.algolia.com/?dateRange=all&page=0&prefix=true&que...

Re: How Big Tech Is Importing India’s Caste Legacy to Silicon Valley

#153
Dear Dang and YC: as someone who has been admonished in the past for not walking over eggshells while criticizing CCP, I’m genuinely surprised at the unchecked vitriol that is allowed in this thread against Brahmins, IITs, Indians, their culture and so on.

Thank you!!

Re: How Big Tech Is Importing India’s Caste Legacy to Silicon Valley

#154
post #68
post #49

This article is as bullshit at it can get with no proof and random catch phrases on the lines of "ohh blacks are hated in America". Truth is, there is absolutely no place for cast in any top Indian engineering colleges. Millennials and GenZ does not give a single fuck to what the cast of a person is. That too in IITs were 90% students come from middle or poor class of society and have similar lifestyle. There can alw…

This is a highly inaccurate comment. Caste lines are more alive than ever especially with the advent of social media.

Don't need to go to social media, just look at the number plates of the "upper class" folks

They usually plaster their caste names on the bike or number plate

Re: How Big Tech Is Importing India’s Caste Legacy to Silicon Valley

#155
post #49

This article is as bullshit at it can get with no proof and random catch phrases on the lines of "ohh blacks are hated in America". Truth is, there is absolutely no place for cast in any top Indian engineering colleges. Millennials and GenZ does not give a single fuck to what the cast of a person is. That too in IITs were 90% students come from middle or poor class of society and have similar lifestyle. There can alw…

I can confirm. There are very fringe sections left in the society which are still practicing caste based discrimination. To get more clicks, news websites try to project this small minority as the truth of the whole nation.

In that case entire country is fringe because I've seen cast discrimination everywhere. Including metro cities.

Re: How Big Tech Is Importing India’s Caste Legacy to Silicon Valley

#156
post #153

Dear Dang and YC: as someone who has been admonished in the past for not walking over eggshells while criticizing CCP, I’m genuinely surprised at the unchecked vitriol that is allowed in this thread against Brahmins, IITs, Indians, their culture and so on. Thank you!!

I disagree, while there are some unsavory comments, this thread is allowing sunlight into some bad aspects of the Indian-American subculture. We - I am Indian-American myself - need to be serious about such allegations and not get defensive.

Re: How Big Tech Is Importing India’s Caste Legacy to Silicon Valley

#157
post #153

Dear Dang and YC: as someone who has been admonished in the past for not walking over eggshells while criticizing CCP, I’m genuinely surprised at the unchecked vitriol that is allowed in this thread against Brahmins, IITs, Indians, their culture and so on. Thank you!!

I disagree, while there are some unsavory comments, this thread is allowing sunlight into some bad aspects of the Indian-American subculture. We - I am Indian-American myself - need to be serious about such allegations and not get defensive.

I’m not at all being defensive, merely pointing to the double standards.

Re: How Big Tech Is Importing India’s Caste Legacy to Silicon Valley

#158

What if you just lie and tell everybody you're Brahmin? Seems that would be a solution. Is that illegal?

This comment made me lol.. Not sure if you were just joking or you were unaware that case system is overlaid on racial/genetic subtleties of Indian subcontinent. Brahmin casts tend to be light skinned. For outsiders, all Indians are same, but believe me, there are subconscious clues a trained human mind (through upbringing, culture etc.) can pick up.

Re: How Big Tech Is Importing India’s Caste Legacy to Silicon Valley

#159

Earlier quoted context omitted.

You have a modern view of the world. You'll be surprised as I was back in the day that not everyone is open minded. Ppl still want to keep old systems in place because their parents have brain washed them into thinking that they're upper caste and that Hindu Khatre mein hai

I come myself from middle class Brahmin family in Maharashtra, have a engineering degree from a mediocre school in Maharashtra. If at all I witnessed something negative is snobbishness from people who graduated from better school than me. I have been in silicon valley for over 25 years now. I worked in 2 startups and 4 mega corporations/public companies with friends/superiors/colleagues (some of whom are Brahmin IIT…

I appreciate people like you. But the thing is, if you are an upper caste person then it is very less likely that you'll be discriminated against as far as caste is concerned.

Overtly discrimination will happen less but covertly ot happens a lot.

But the good news is that not everyone is like that so we are slowly progressing

Re: How Big Tech Is Importing India’s Caste Legacy to Silicon Valley

#160

What if you just lie and tell everybody you're Brahmin? Seems that would be a solution. Is that illegal?

This comment made me lol.. Not sure if you were just joking or you were unaware that case system is overlaid on racial/genetic subtleties of Indian subcontinent. Brahmin casts tend to be light skinned. For outsiders, all Indians are same, but believe me, there are subconscious clues a trained human mind (through upbringing, culture etc.) can pick up.

Nordics probably read as superbrahmins.
Post reply on HN