Live data from Hacker News

The Awkward but Essential Art of Office Chitchat

nytimes.com

151–160 of 170 posts

Re: The Awkward but Essential Art of Office Chitchat

#151

I think the essential office chitchat issue is "being yourself" vs. "seeming like a high quality professional". I've found out the hard way that relaxing and aiming for a real conversation carries a high % chance of saying something unbecoming of a team leader. Better pay attention to appearances when you're at work. I don't understand coworkers who say silly things at the lunch table without a second thought, or tho…

I'm not a team leader and have no interest in becoming one. Moreover, I spent most of my adult life hiding behind a professional persona and all it did was make me miserable because people only noticed me when they wanted something from me. I'm done with that nonsense. I won't embarrass the company, insult clients, or create a hostile work environment but otherwise I'm not going to pretend that I left my personality…

do you think professionalism was the main cause of people only seeing you instrumentally? if so, I'd be interested to hear more about your definition of professionalism

Re: The Awkward but Essential Art of Office Chitchat

#152
post #75
post #69

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The strongest model I have for understanding the world is that your prefrontal cortex is a simulator that is always predicting. When something occurs that surprises you (like a glass breaking in a restaurant), the anomaly diverts your attention to the sound source so your visual system can feed more data to your model and rationalise the event. But when something happens that contradicts your model, it means your mod…

This is very insightful. Incidentally, the essence of what you say (the mind is always predicting and learns from prediction failure) is also the essence of idealist philosophy, and has found its most advanced expression in Kant's Critique of Pure Reason . Unfortunately, Kant uses a language that's difficult to access today, so a lot Kant's insight has fallen out of today.

I fail to see any strong connection to Kant or german idealism in general

Re: The Awkward but Essential Art of Office Chitchat

#153
post #45

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> I don't understand coworkers who say silly things at the lunch table without a second thought I'm such a coworker. Two reasons I do this: 1. I don't care about "upward mobility". 2. People don't see me as a threat to theirs, which is a good thing, because you don't want an overly ambitious junior developer trying to prove his(or hers) worth by picking on you. Reason 0. is that weirdly enough it's good to appear som…

> 1. I don't care about "upward mobility". Wait long enough and you'll probably find younger people will do your job for cheaper, unless you can prove you're worth promoting. Some people can really stick it out, but usually by job security ("Larry is the only one who knows AIX and we can't replace it") > 2. People don't see me as a threat to theirs Eventually there will be layoffs, at which point you don't want to be…

1. Already happened and I wasn't laid off because of that, because apparently people are still making money on my work.

2. I've been laid off in the past. What's interesting about this is that another company will still have you provided you pass their recruitment process. Seems obvious, but not for someone who's going through this for the same time.

What also helps is that I'm EU-Eastern-European, so my labour is relatively cheap.

Re: The Awkward but Essential Art of Office Chitchat

#154

Small talk is an extremely high-risk low reward activity depending on your status with the company, especially if your manager has told you your status is utterly fixed. How in the hell are you supposed to build a rapport with people who would as soon skin you alive as look at you, and only tolerate you for what you can do that no one else can?

[deleted]

Re: The Awkward but Essential Art of Office Chitchat

#155

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Except the incentives are aligned to be a Hobbesian war of all against all. There is no incentive to collaborate or team up at all. Ever wonder why shows like Survivor and Battle Royale games are so popular? That's how office life is these days. Nobody is ever "in your corner" as you put it. Everyone is always and forever trying to gut everyone else in a neverending zero sum game. Unless you work in a new/high growth…

I'm fascinated to see if you just work in bizzare confrontational companies or are just paranoid. Pretty much everywhere I've been I've gotten on well with my coworkers, chatted about videogames, beer, gone to various resturants for lunch, and generally enjoyed myself. To do anything else would seem almost unbearable - and this comes from a 100% introvert. There are subtle signals that people have to both recognise a…

I may be paranoid, but I can't grok as much social information as my coworkers can. I've had to memorize what different emotional states look like, and I come from a working-class background where emotional dishonesty is not a valued thing, going to an office environment where it is.

Apologies for the Star Trek reference, but it feels like being a particularly dense Betazoid working in an office of Vulcans.

Re: The Awkward but Essential Art of Office Chitchat

#156
> “I’m good. I just started a book/podcast/TV show

Hm - my wife (who’s an expert on this sort of thing) says that’s actually rude and you should always answer back, “good and you” so that _the other person_ can start taking about their TV show/podcast whatever.

Re: The Awkward but Essential Art of Office Chitchat

#157
post #60

Earlier quoted context omitted.

one reason I do like working remote is that I don't have to deal with others' grade 8 drama skills!

But then you have to deal with their 8th grade writing skills.

golf clap >>> Made me laugh, so thank you. But so true

Re: The Awkward but Essential Art of Office Chitchat

#158
Counterpoint:

Don't Talk to Anyone, Ever

https://freebeacon.com/blog/dont-talk-anyone-ever/

Don't talk to strangers at work. I don't care if you're coworkers: Unless you have to do a task with this person, they aren't interested in being anywhere near you, nor should you be in them.

Don't talk to anyone. Ever. Talking is awful. People are worse. It's hard to imagine a more horrifying combination than talking to people.

Re: The Awkward but Essential Art of Office Chitchat

#159

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I'm not a team leader and have no interest in becoming one. Moreover, I spent most of my adult life hiding behind a professional persona and all it did was make me miserable because people only noticed me when they wanted something from me. I'm done with that nonsense. I won't embarrass the company, insult clients, or create a hostile work environment but otherwise I'm not going to pretend that I left my personality…

do you think professionalism was the main cause of people only seeing you instrumentally? if so, I'd be interested to hear more about your definition of professionalism

I honestly have no idea if my notion of professionalism was the main cause of others only seeing me instrumentally, but my idea of professionalism is to come in, do the job well, not talk about anything unrelated to the job, attend unavoidable company functions, and then go home. Anything not directly related to the job remained outside the office.

Re: The Awkward but Essential Art of Office Chitchat

#160

Counterpoint: Don't Talk to Anyone, Ever https://freebeacon.com/blog/dont-talk-anyone-ever/ Don't talk to strangers at work. I don't care if you're coworkers: Unless you have to do a task with this person, they aren't interested in being anywhere near you, nor should you be in them. Don't talk to anyone. Ever. Talking is awful. People are worse. It's hard to imagine a more horrifying combination than talking to peopl…

I was hoping for an honest exploration of full-on misanthropy, and all I got was a crappy satire blog. I'm disappointed.
Post reply on HN