Live data from Hacker News

User Inyerface – A worst-practice UI experiment

userinyerface.com

151–160 of 266 posts

Re: User Inyerface – A worst-practice UI experiment

#151

I about fell off my chair laughing with how slow closing the "how can we help" popover was. If I had to write a backstory for this I'd say some dev was really proud of animating that and wanted to make sure everyone noticed it.

Press "help" in that popover and you'll be shown "Please wait, there are 459 people in line".

Re: User Inyerface – A worst-practice UI experiment

#152

I am a UX designer with 30 years of digital design experience, 20 of those in UX/UI design. In my opinion, UX is dead. Companies don't want it. They still think they want it from a competition standpoint, but in terms of what value UX brings, they don't care and would prefer not to have it. UX in corporations is purely a political thing now. It used to be that commerical activity on the internet was not allowed. This…

Yikes. I see it the opposite way. My title has evolved from UX Designer to Product Designer. A lot of organizations have started to understand the value of design and are now giving us the power to think through everything, rather than just the optimization of a web form.

Technology is evolving and expanding so quickly that there's exponential need for good design. I'm happy to hear you're getting out of UX though. I wouldn't want to go to a doctor who blatantly calls the whole medical industry a sham.

Re: User Inyerface – A worst-practice UI experiment

#153
post #148

Earlier quoted context omitted.

They are the same country edit: Not sure why the downvotes. French Guiana is a region of France (the country): https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/French_Guiana

> > Even worse: several entries such as France, French Guyana share the exact same flag because they are, you know, the same country. > They are the same country > edit: Not sure why the downvotes. French Guiana is a region of France (the country): https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/French_Guiana Maybe the downvotes (not from me) were because your post initially appears to be correcting your parent ( https://news.ycombina…

Well no, I think the parent is agreeing with the GP actually.

Re: User Inyerface – A worst-practice UI experiment

#155

My favorite part was how s-l-o-w-l-y the "How Can We Help?" dialog sank when I clicked Send to Bottom. I also appreciate how it would reappear and block the interface. But kind of disappointed it didn't instantly reappear if you moused over it. Or that it didn't randomly bounce for attention in my peripheral vision. And to the person out there thinking of making a front end framework based on this, just don't do it m…

I had this happen today, in the wild, after visiting a HN linked Wired article. A few seconds on the page, a banner appears, blocking about a quarter of the page. Close it, start reading the article. 30 seconds later, the original banner reappears, again blocking a quarter of the page, and I close it again. I continue reading, think I hit a "click to read more button", another click. Keep reading, maybe two thirds of the way through the article, get bombarded with a modal dialog asking me subscribe to an email newsletter.

Who the fuck is implementing these things and how do they justify this shit as contributing to the user experience? I came to your aite to read an article, not to be bombarded with ridiculously distracting prompts, banners and subscribe prompts - and this completely ignoring the intrusiveness of the ads with autoplaying video and audio.

Shit like this really makes me rethink visiting sites like Wired, though they are by far not the only ones doing this, just the one that happened to me today.

Why do web devs think this a good thing to do? Pull this crap in a desktop, sure as he'll would uninstall.

/rant

Re: User Inyerface – A worst-practice UI experiment

#156

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Cookie banners are only really required if you're doing things like using them for "personalizing ads" and the like. If your cookies just there to check if you're logged in and other essential functions, you don't need a banner.

What about if you want to A/B test on a non-logged-in user?

E-mail them and ask them nicely to volunteer for your research study. Agency's a bitch when someone else has it, eh?

Re: User Inyerface – A worst-practice UI experiment

#158

Seriously? There's tons of stuff missing, at the very least a cookie banner ("we value your privacy not ") and "aw, snap, we're having probs to bla blah blah" and social media icons. Also, it's known that call-to-actions must come in a group of three, and have cute vectors. See [1] on how to do a website. [1]: https://www.reddit.com/r/web_design/comments/9pmqxb/typical_...

I'm very surprised there's no "sign up for our news letter" pop up and "hey don't go yet" when you move your mouse towards the close button.

Re: User Inyerface – A worst-practice UI experiment

#160

"Select all pictures with a bow" Then you have an actual bow. Like in archery. Next to a bowtie. Ok fine. "Select all pictures of glasses" Now you have a glass window. And glasses, as in spectacles. Holy crap, that triggers me.

Don't forget all the people who are, you know, bowing. Seriously, I'm pretty sure it rejects your captcha if you do. Sheer evil genius all the way through.
Post reply on HN