Live data from Hacker News

China is no longer importing waste – 111M tons will have to go elsewhere

bloomberg.com

151–160 of 213 posts

Re: China is no longer importing waste – 111M tons will have to go elsewhere

#151
post #129

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Isn't that a problem that could be solved with law enforcement and cleaners like what developed countries do? That still seems to be cheaper than glass bottles.

Cheaper is not the measure of everything. Glass bottles, returned and re-used are much better for the environment than plastic bottles.

Also for your health - lots of plastic bottles are not so stable and less so, in heat. So you end up drinking small amounts of plastic and additives.

Re: China is no longer importing waste – 111M tons will have to go elsewhere

#152

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Yeah, we're the problem. It's OUR plastic that China isn't allowing in anymore.

No we're not the fucking problem. We are the good guys.

I would love to think the world is so black and white, but we export plastic to China and now, they don't want it. So.

It's always dangerous to think one is on the right side of history.

Re: China is no longer importing waste – 111M tons will have to go elsewhere

#153
post #147
post #145

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The biggest problem with making statements about "plastic" is that it's such a broad category of materials that you almost invariably doom yourself to talking nonsense. Most plastic (particularly PET, PP, HDPE, and LDPE) is not poisonous, even when decomposed, and does not bioaccumulate in the conventional sense. Perhaps by "poison sponge" you don't mean that it's poisonous; you mean that it absorbs poisons. Well, is…

> Well, isn't that what you would want to do with poisons? Not if something is going to eat the plastic, and I'm going to eat that something, because then I'm eating the poison.

You're still better off if most of the poison stays inside the plastic than if you were to eat the same amount of poison without the plastic.

Re: China is no longer importing waste – 111M tons will have to go elsewhere

#154

Earlier quoted context omitted.

No we're not the fucking problem. We are the good guys.

I would love to think the world is so black and white, but we export plastic to China and now, they don't want it. So. It's always dangerous to think one is on the right side of history.

You, sir, are exhibiting dangerous relativistic tendencies.

It's imperative that this sorry excuse of a country be wiped off the face of the earth

Re: China is no longer importing waste – 111M tons will have to go elsewhere

#155
post #35

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> Should we go back to glass bottles and paper bags? If you put a price (read: tax) on plastic, I'm sure many folks would jump at the opportunity of replacing plastic-heavy stuff with no/minimal plastic options possibly using glass or paper (or metal where things are disposable that shouldn't be). Thing is, plastic has a subsidized price right now due to petroleum supply chain being subsidized - plastic is a byproduc…

Not necessarily. In 2004, Germany introduced a 25 cent deposit on single-use plastic bottles [1] for types of beverages where single-use bottles were much more common than reusable bottles. The intention was like you describe: to encourage consumers and manufacturers to prefer reusable bottles. However, the opposite happened. In the first few months after the law came into power, each retailer would only take back bo…

What if they just standardised on say 10 form factors for reusable bottles? Just replace the label and you can refill it at the factory.

Re: China is no longer importing waste – 111M tons will have to go elsewhere

#156

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I don't understand why it's better to not recycle glass. Yes transporting used glass is costly, but isn't collecting and transporting sand even more costly? And while we won't run out of sand, good sand is limited. Or can you use any sort of sand to produce glass instead of a specific type of sand? Doesn't refining sand into glass take additional energy compared to melting existing glass?

For one truck load, how much sand can you carry per volume, vs. old glass bottles? For the latter, aren't you mostly transporting air? You don't want to BREAK the glass bottles, since they still need to be sorted, and cleaned.

Do you know what you are talking about?

I am far from an expert, but here in germany glas gets recycled in 3 bins, brown, green, white - and get usually smashed by people throwing those bottles in. So not much air. And cleaned they still can get (and should)

Re: China is no longer importing waste – 111M tons will have to go elsewhere

#158
post #74

Earlier quoted context omitted.

China is the one creating the plastic in the first place. Don't act like they have a moral high ground.

They create the plastics for those who buy them. Don't act like anyone has the moral high ground.

Ah yes, the "Just following orders" defense

Re: China is no longer importing waste – 111M tons will have to go elsewhere

#159

We need to stop making things out of plastic, where any alternative exists. The stuff is going to be the asbestos of the 21st century. Microplastic has been vastly, vastly underrated as a problem. All my lifetime the attitude has been that plastic takes eons to degrade and pulverize, but when it does, the problem of unsightly or dangerous litter is presumably finished. Now we're seeing the opposite: plastic dust is a…

Plastic is an amazing material. You can thermoform it, it's a great insulator, molds and fungi don't feed on it, it's incredibly strong (e.g. UHMWPE rope a.k.a dyneema) and so on. The trouble seems to be we don't really respect the environment enough, so we use it in terrible ways, like single use products. We often don't need those nice properties in single use products, yet we use it anyway because we don't pay due…

What about aluminium bottles? There are a bunch of Japanese drinks that come in aluminium bottles.

Eg Miracle Body https://www.mix.com.my/en/goods.php?id=3456

They’re light, and you can make the entire thing out of the same material.

Post reply on HN