Live data from Hacker News

SureFly – a personal helicopter designed for safe and easy flight

workhorse.com

151–157 of 157 posts

Re: SureFly – a personal helicopter designed for safe and easy flight

#151

Just reading through the about page... Where is the aircraft/rotorcraft experience in upper management? There are many reasons that helicopters are dominant at the scale of human transport (some of which have been brought up in this comment thread) and multicopters are prevalent at smaller (drone-size) scales... All of this is to say I'm extremely skeptical.

All that is missing is mention of blockchain.

Re: SureFly – a personal helicopter designed for safe and easy flight

#152
post #98

Is there any data on the sound profile of this thing? As the rotors become smaller the disc loading increases, making them much louder and more shrill. If that's effectively mitigated here, this looks really cool; if not, I think it will be hard to negotiate take off and landing rights with most communities.

As well as being higher pitched, contra-rotating designs also produce more noise.

The sound field is non-uniform (mostly axial), and there are claims of being able to reduce it through special phasing of the two rotors, using different numbers of blades on each, etc. But I wouldn't be particularly hopeful.

Re: SureFly – a personal helicopter designed for safe and easy flight

#153

Earlier quoted context omitted.

As any pilot knows, the stomach unfriendly words from Tower are: "Caution, Wake Turbulence". The air, being a sparse fluid, can change fast. Especially so if another aircraft has flown through it recently. It's not that there isn't anyone there, it's the air they left behind is all non-laminar now. Doubly being suddenly downwind of stationary objects like towers, wind farms, and mountains. Also, quick point of cautio…

It comes with a parachute

If anything, that makes it more dangerous. Besides a sense of 'false' security, chutes do take a certain amount of height to catch air and become safe. IIRC it's about 100m and turbulence will affect that in strange ways.

In the end, I still fear tech like this will not be as stringent as needed.

Re: SureFly – a personal helicopter designed for safe and easy flight

#155
post #40

electric transmission vs mechanical and 8 tiny inefficient props? 1 hour flight with 30kg of fuel? I can make something more efficient in a garage...

Well, Colin Furze can make it in his garage.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=soxxPyaAT1k

Post reply on HN