Live data from Hacker News

Spaniards face ham shortage as Chinese market gets taste for jamón ibérico

theguardian.com

151–153 of 153 posts

Re: Spaniards face ham shortage as Chinese market gets taste for jamón ibérico

#151
post #67

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It's not a trademark, it's a designation of geographical origin. France doesn't "protect" Champagne - it's just that if you call something Champagne it has to be real Champagne - i.e. be made in Champagne, following the Champagne method. Just like Campana Mozza, Feta, etc. It's as much for the consumer as it is for the producer. And there are rows of "Sparkling Wine according to the Champagne method" in French superm…

> France doesn't "protect" Champagne Oh, but they do. This goes a lot beyond simple geographical "truth in advertising", and is indeed a lot more similar to a trademark. As you mention, it's not enough for a wine to be produced in the region of Champagne to be allowed to be called Champagne, it has to be produced within very narrow parameters. Jamon Iberico is indeed protected, and again, there's quite a bit more goi…

Well yes they are narrow parameters - those are the parameters which define the product! I can't paint an apple red and call it a tomato... Same thing with Champagne. If it follows the definition of Champagne - made in Champagne following the Champagne method - it's Champagne. If not, it isn't.

Of course there are protection motives - but can you criticise the EU for ensuring that stalls aren't flooded with fakes? As a consumer I don't want to have to do extensive research on everything I buy - "Is this organic strawberry really organic?", "Are these Jersey Royals really from Jersey?", "Is this really Champagne?"

Re: Spaniards face ham shortage as Chinese market gets taste for jamón ibérico

#152
post #67

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It's not a trademark, it's a designation of geographical origin. France doesn't "protect" Champagne - it's just that if you call something Champagne it has to be real Champagne - i.e. be made in Champagne, following the Champagne method. Just like Campana Mozza, Feta, etc. It's as much for the consumer as it is for the producer. And there are rows of "Sparkling Wine according to the Champagne method" in French superm…

> France doesn't "protect" Champagne They sure do. They bake regulations on the naming into foreign trade agreements

I'm sure the US wouldn't let me sell silver that is actually nickel either - it seems logical to insist that goods are labelled truthfully

Re: Spaniards face ham shortage as Chinese market gets taste for jamón ibérico

#153
post #63

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Note that you can buy any movies you want in ripped dvd form in the street, some restaurants or some shops anywhere in China. They even sold it on my campus uni. Its common practice to go there once a week to pick up a bunch of dvds

The DVD shops have been disappearing as more content is pirated online. Progress I guess.

Interesting, back then it was already really easy to use PPTV or other "apps" that would stream anything
Post reply on HN