Live data from Hacker News

Code together in real time with Teletype for Atom

blog.atom.io

151–160 of 230 posts

Re: Code together in real time with Teletype for Atom

#151

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Yeah, appears to be dumb luck. You don't put together branding and a demo of real-time collaborative editing in a day.

My hack-a-thon team did it in 48 hours this weekend, lol. https://www.nodeknockout.com/entries/35-nodeist-colony

You put developed "the world's most advanced code collaboration experience" as advertised by the website in 48 hours ? Can I hire you somewhere ?

Re: Code together in real time with Teletype for Atom

#153
post #5

Lovely seeing Nathan and co ship this. Interestingly enough, this feature is the primary reason behind Atom itself existing. We saw the first internal demo of "Atom" (I believe it was "Thunderhorse" at the time) 6-7 years ago, and the main idea was real-time collaboration on code. That sorta took a backseat for awhile as GitHub started to recognize that a collaborative editor was pretty swell in its own right, but gl…

This one single feature could potentially have the largest impact on my workflow in 2018. As much as I love async task management. Real-time collaboration with remote team members should be fascinating ;)

Re: Code together in real time with Teletype for Atom

#154
post #39

Is it only a coincidence that real-time collaboration is being announced both for Atom and VS Code ( https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15704376 ) at the same time?

Why is there breakneck competition here to offer the best free code editor?

What I'm interested in is whether Live Code Share is a free service.... feels like it might be a paid service. Or limited free then pay? Not sure. It's also for visual studio.

Also be interesting if someone makes a teletype plugin for VSCode :)

Re: Code together in real time with Teletype for Atom

#155
post #80

Earlier quoted context omitted.

What's wrong with Typescript? Also, why does it matter to you? Genuinely curious.

Curious, Why does it matter to you? On the Atom.io website https://atom.io/ it reads "A hackable text editor for the 21st Century". Well I can code in JavaScript 5 and 6. I love love it when a project sticks to web standard, and not have to worry about slangs I don't care about. > Typescript is great at catching bugs The same with JavaScript. Google Closure compiler and anyway most IDEs "understand" JavaScript too an…

I was surprised to see someone who cared what style of javascript a program is written in, especially if they aren't an active contributor. Maybe you are?

Re: Code together in real time with Teletype for Atom

#156
post #128

Earlier quoted context omitted.

What's wrong with Typescript? Also, why does it matter to you? Genuinely curious.

It's like having Leonard Cohen transpiled to Justin Bieber. Now look at it from the Justin Bieber fans point of view, why would they listen to Leonard Cohen in order to hear Justin Bieber ? Even though research says Leonard Cohen makes better music! From Leonard Cohen fan's point of view it doesn't matter as they only hear Leonard Cohen, not Justin.

I'm having a really hard time making sense of that analogy...

Re: Code together in real time with Teletype for Atom

#157

Is it only a coincidence that real-time collaboration is being announced both for Atom and VS Code ( https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15704376 ) at the same time?

Wouldn't it be nice for VS Live Share and Teletype to be compatible on protocol-level?

(Several years of realtime editing experience reporting in)

Plain text CRDT and OT systems are often mutually adaptable. Even if they aren't directly compatible, with a bit of work it'll probably be possible to adapt from one realtime editing protocol to the other.

Of course, in the medium to long term having a standard for OT/CRDT operations that works in a lot of source code editors would be fantastic.

Re: Code together in real time with Teletype for Atom

#158

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I just stopped sharing the document. I was just running it over crappy cafe wife for 2.5 hours, max ~20 people, always 5 to 10... performance seemed fantastic - didn't tax my lappy at all. Very impressed! [Re-shared it at 28e6c3b4-754c-44ef-9406-869604db9db5 - it would be good if you could keep a UUID somehow, but I guess that's unfeasible]

Someone please build a game around this premise. 15+ people having fun in a shared simulation is prime territory for game ideas.

Which premise? Isn't that just re-inventing multiplayer gaming?

Or do you mean targeting web games, much like was discussed in this HN post: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13264952

Re: Code together in real time with Teletype for Atom

#160
post #5

Lovely seeing Nathan and co ship this. Interestingly enough, this feature is the primary reason behind Atom itself existing. We saw the first internal demo of "Atom" (I believe it was "Thunderhorse" at the time) 6-7 years ago, and the main idea was real-time collaboration on code. That sorta took a backseat for awhile as GitHub started to recognize that a collaborative editor was pretty swell in its own right, but gl…

This one single feature could potentially have the largest impact on my workflow in 2018. As much as I love async task management. Real-time collaboration with remote team members should be fascinating ;)

I guess the next step would be something along the lines of Google Wave where you could playback the "conversations" and see the learning process develop.
Post reply on HN