Live data from Hacker News

China’s AI Awakening

technologyreview.com

151–160 of 181 posts

Re: China’s AI Awakening

#151

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Recent emeeging internet markets in china’s backyard like Myanmar and Cambodia are even more dominated by western internet companies. To the average Cambodian, internet means YouTube and Facebook. Chinese companies are completely MIA.

Interesting, care to share the source? I was under the impression that Cambodians are mostly using devices from Chinese brands and hence exposed to pre-installed Chinese software (at least to a small extent). For example, Xiaomi phones come without google play stores but Chinese app stores.

There was a big article about their success in SE Asia (including Cambodia and Myanmar) a few years ago, but I can’t find it ATM. Anyways, this page helps:

http://geeksincambodia.com/cambodias-2017-social-media-digit...

Chinese phones outside of china are generally sold with a straight google app stack. None of those Chinese services are localized in kmher!

Re: China’s AI Awakening

#152

Extremely relevant quote from the talented Mr Ng: > “When the Chinese government announces a plan like this, it has significant implications for the country and the economy,” says Andrew Ng, a prominent AI expert who previously oversaw AI technology and strategy at China’s biggest online search company, Baidu. “It’s a very strong signal to everyone that things will happen.” ie. There is going to be a tonne of money p…

> ...but anyone sitting here scoffing that China can’t make itself a world leader in a field by simply pouring money and support onto the problem needs a serious history lesson. They have before, and there is every indiction they will again, here with this. What are they currently leading?

Pollution.

Re: China’s AI Awakening

#153
post #138
post #132

Earlier quoted context omitted.

pardon my ignorance, but what is the specific correlation of math skills to dominance in AI ? yes, AI/ML/dnn uses substantial amounts of linear algebra, much the way accountancy uses large amounts of arithmetic. but we don’t see mathematicians racing to be accountants. i have specifically written to several math departments in the US asking if they do any sort of AI/ML related graduate research. Even schools that off…

The PISA test (at least when I took it) measures math skills in calculation, i.e. the kind of applied mathematics that academic departments write off as too trivial. Nonetheless, those are the skills that are required for Deep Learning as well as accountancy. You could make an argument that high performers on the PISA test would find AI and accountancy too boring and would go into pure mathematics instead; but I don'…

> those are the skills that are required for Deep Learning

Why do you believe that?

Re: China’s AI Awakening

#154
post #70
post #56

Earlier quoted context omitted.

One example where they poured money and got ahead is the rail system and the high speed rail system.

Their maglev train was built by Siemens and ThyssenKrupp in Germany, the _real_ leader in high speed rail transportation.

It doesn't work like that. If you sell significant goods in China, you have to manufacture there and your methods will be copied. China is moving towards economic autarchy very quickly.

Re: China’s AI Awakening

#155

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Interesting, care to share the source? I was under the impression that Cambodians are mostly using devices from Chinese brands and hence exposed to pre-installed Chinese software (at least to a small extent). For example, Xiaomi phones come without google play stores but Chinese app stores.

There was a big article about their success in SE Asia (including Cambodia and Myanmar) a few years ago, but I can’t find it ATM. Anyways, this page helps: http://geeksincambodia.com/cambodias-2017-social-media-digit... Chinese phones outside of china are generally sold with a straight google app stack. None of those Chinese services are localized in kmher!

https://www.similarweb.com/apps/top/google/store-rank/kh/all...

According to this page,number 8,9,10 ranked Android apps (from play store) are app offered by Chinese companies.

Also, there are cheap Android phones directly brought over from China which are installed with Chinese app stores (I know that's the case for Myanmar, not sure about Cambodia), they wound be missing from this chart.

So I wouldn't say it's entirely MIA.

Re: China’s AI Awakening

#156

Has China produced a single major AI breakthrough with all these cited papers? Just because they have a lot of papers written doesn't mean anything. Quality vs Quantity. You can take technology developed by others and copy it all you want, and assign all your grad students to write something publishable about it, but unless you innovate in it, I wouldn't say you are a world leader. At best you may see novel applicati…

Yes, lots. StackGAN comes to mind.

Re: China’s AI Awakening

#157
post #48

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Due to the language barrier, there is a lot of interesting work that we will never "see". For example I was randomly looking through text recognition competition results and found out Tencent has an AI lab that took first place: http://rrc.cvc.uab.es/?ch=1&com=evaluation&task=4 . But I was unable to find any information about them. They have github repos with thousands of stars but the community is entirely in chines…

I believe TenCent AI Lab is based in Silicon Valley.

According to its recruit page (http://ai.tencent.com/ailab/recruit.html), they have researchers in US and Shenzhen, China.

Re: China’s AI Awakening

#158
post #32

I was reading the USNews CS ranking yesterday, got really surprised that apparently some Chinese universities are now considered as the best in CS. top 20 list: https://www.usnews.com/education/best-global-universities/se... https://www.usnews.com/education/best-global-universities/co...

Well, it's interesting to see that the USNews ranks Harvard ahead of UCBerkeley. Back when I used to work at a quant shop in NYC, Harvard wasn't even considered for hiring -- they only recruited from MIT, CMU, UIUC, Berkeley, Stanford and UToronto. Also, not surprisingly, most quants were Chinese.

Trust your own expertise. I can’t find the paper where I got this from but if you rank CS departments by where professors got their doctorates and where they end up teaching the basically equal top four were Carnegie Mellon, MIT, Berkeley and Stanford. Which four would round out the world Top 10? Georgia Tech?

Aren’t a ton of quants French as well?

Re: China’s AI Awakening

#159

Key competitive advantages of China are their strength in quantitative skills, a huge population, and the hard working and competitive culture of the populace. An objective measure is PISA results [1]. When comparing with even the best performing US state, Massachusetts, China has many more top performers in Math, as a proportion of population [2]. (In 2015 only four provinces of China participated, but their combine…

Even with the hostile environment in the US, I suspect China is far more hostile . I don't see China retaining top talent--these individuals might simply go to Europe, Canada, Japan or elsewhere.

I've been living here for 5y and I work in a research lab. A lot of talent is deciding to stay here or come back (Chinese that went to study/work abroad). Attracting foreign talent is a little different, but so far the government is not really worried about that.

I can only see the trend speeding up. Especially as/if the environment (air quality, etc.) improves. This now, in my personal view, seems to be the main factor for many people to decide to come or not.

Re: China’s AI Awakening

#160

Earlier quoted context omitted.

There was a big article about their success in SE Asia (including Cambodia and Myanmar) a few years ago, but I can’t find it ATM. Anyways, this page helps: http://geeksincambodia.com/cambodias-2017-social-media-digit... Chinese phones outside of china are generally sold with a straight google app stack. None of those Chinese services are localized in kmher!

https://www.similarweb.com/apps/top/google/store-rank/kh/all... According to this page,number 8,9,10 ranked Android apps (from play store) are app offered by Chinese companies. Also, there are cheap Android phones directly brought over from China which are installed with Chinese app stores (I know that's the case for Myanmar, not sure about Cambodia), they wound be missing from this chart. So I wouldn't say it's enti…

Sure...I mean, yes, they have a couple of Chinese apps that are used (for pirating movies and TV shows?), if that's what you mean. But no WeChat, Baidu, or the major ones.
Post reply on HN