Live data from Hacker News

Apple Sues HTC for Patent Infringement

prnewswire.com

151–156 of 156 posts

Re: Apple Sues HTC for Patent Infringement

#151
Why can't Apple continue to out-innovate Nexus One and Android instead of suing them?

Reading from the overall situation and his quote, Steve Jobs might feel that the current iPhone UI is 'perfect' as a whole. Apart from nitty-gritty details, he does not see a way to drastically improve it. (That's why he chose it for the iPad UI as well.) So he might figure that the only way to stop competitors from getting too close is to sue them.

Re: Apple Sues HTC for Patent Infringement

#152
post #114

Earlier quoted context omitted.

if must-have software starts showing up on Android, it would really help. You mean like Google Voice and Google Maps Navigation? Unfortunately that doesn't seem to have helped much.

"You mean like Google Voice and Google Maps Navigation? Unfortunately that doesn't seem to have helped much." Android is a few years behind IPhone but is gaining traction. I seriously do not feel like Android needs much help. All it needs is just time and have Apple continue to try to put tight controls on its ecosystem.

I wouldn't even say Android is that far behind. It's lacking polish, to be sure, but there isn't anything I cared to do on my iPod Touch that I can't do on my Nexus One. And the N1 offers me some things the iPod couldn't do, even ignoring the GPS, camera, and phone functions. I find the N1's interface to be a lot prettier, too (but I suppose that's a matter of personal taste).

Re: Apple Sues HTC for Patent Infringement

#153
post #31

If this had happened a day earlier I don't think I would have posted that RFS. Apple is inching ever closer to evil, and I worry that there's no one within the company who can stand up to Jobs and tell him so.

I've realized this for a while; ever since I looked at the terms of service for the iPhone SDK, which forbid pretty much any innovation on things like RFS #5 (you are not allowed to write compilers or interpreters which run on the iPhone, which pretty much precludes any development tools that aren't web apps).

I think it's about time for me to get an Android phone. The platform isn't as polished, but you can actually get root on your damn phone and some of it is free software (about like Mac OS X, actually; a free kernel, some libraries, and utilities, with some applications on top that are closed).

Re: Apple Sues HTC for Patent Infringement

#154
post #31

If this had happened a day earlier I don't think I would have posted that RFS. Apple is inching ever closer to evil, and I worry that there's no one within the company who can stand up to Jobs and tell him so.

Apple has been evil since the first ipod when you had to use itunes to load music. They have locked people in with no cheap way out. Pure evil IMO.

Sheesh, honestly this is far afield but why do people keep lumping not having a feature in with evil?

Aren't most of you people software developers? Do you sell software to people? Regular humans who can blow out your profit with a single helpline call?

Choosing to not support a scenario is about as far from evil as you could possibly get.

Do you seriously look at all of the things that itunes doesn't do, all of the things that it does poorly or all of its bugs and think "apple is evil"?

Isn't it clear that they, despite having some great talent, are resource-constrained like everyone else?

Have you ever used a bug database? Tracked a bug count? Tested? Shipped a product?

OK, I'm trying not to be insulting or personal here but let's be clear: not supporting file system access aka supporting only the sync model INDISPUITABLY saved engineering resources. That feature you want is not free. If you can't see that then we're done because the only response would be insulting.

Re: Apple Sues HTC for Patent Infringement

#155
post #111

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Netbooks suck to use, I know because I'm using one right now. Small, cramped, hot, ugly.

And you're thinking removing the keyboard will make it suck less?

Less heat, less space, less crap getting into the computer, less breakable things...

Yes, I fucking do think it'll suck less.

Re: Apple Sues HTC for Patent Infringement

#156

Earlier quoted context omitted.

No one is forcing you to be in the iTunes store and write iPhone apps. As for all personal PCs having only software approved by a central authority -- all electrical appliances are approved by UL. I don't see that as having resulted in much evil. To get to drive in the US, everyone is approved by their State. I don't see that as being very evil. The former is opt-in and arranged by insurance interests. The latter is…

That's like saying 10 years ago, no one is forcing you to use Windows. Right now there is no credible alternative to iPod/iPhone/iTunes. Guys like Google and Microsoft are trying to make a better product. If Apple continues to win by making the better product, that's good for consumers, that's how the free market is supposed to work. If Apple decides to focus their time instead on PREVENTING other people from making…

Seriously? No credible alternative? CDs are a credible alternative. Seriously. Not to mention any number of music managers, archos, sony, zune etc.

I mean, they might SUCK, but some people think cars that aren't beemers SUCK, it's hyperbole to say that sony isn't credible.

You can buy a sony product, download mp3s from amazon and listen to music.

What makes that not a credible alternative?

Post reply on HN