Live data from Hacker News

Cloudflare's new AI traffic options for customers

blog.cloudflare.com

141–150 of 169 posts

Re: Cloudflare's new AI traffic options for customers

#141
post #43

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Good. Google's approach here is manifestly predator, unfair, and IMO illegal. They deserve to be in court for this behaviour, and mandating owners give consent for AI training or drop out of Google; which is just a non-starter because they're a search monopoly. That's exactly what antitrust laws are supposed to do, and I hope at least EU regulators take action. Every single Googlebot crawl in your access logs is a tr…

The irony here is that the people blocking all other crawlers are the ones shoring up their monopoly. If you can't block Googlebot because you need the search traffic but you block everybody else so that nobody other than Google can index your site, how do you expect to ever get any search traffic that isn't from Google?

Search traffic is nose diving due to LLM use. The fundamental calculus with google is you install GA and it helps your SEO has changed and google is riding out what will eventually wither as people start to reevaluate the trade off.

Re: Cloudflare's new AI traffic options for customers

#142
post #43
post #4

The big news here is that Googlebot will be blocked from September 15th onwards by one the "block training" policies, because Google use the same crawler infrastructure for their search index AND for training Gemini: > Another change that will apply on September 15 is that multi-purpose crawlers (specifically those that combine Search with Training) will be allowed/blocked according to all of their behaviors, in line…

Good. Google's approach here is manifestly predator, unfair, and IMO illegal. They deserve to be in court for this behaviour, and mandating owners give consent for AI training or drop out of Google; which is just a non-starter because they're a search monopoly. That's exactly what antitrust laws are supposed to do, and I hope at least EU regulators take action. Every single Googlebot crawl in your access logs is a tr…

> mandating owners give consent for AI training or drop out of Google

Huh?

Search and AI are hand-in-hand.

They both rely on embeddings. (Unless you still do keyword-only search, but that's not as good.)

Re: Cloudflare's new AI traffic options for customers

#143
post #104
post #90

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Their scraping products are mostly about paying them money to not be blocked.

So Google has to pay Cloudflare 10B$ to get Googlebot moved to their default Allowlist otherwise Google would loose access to a significant portion of the internet? Genius move.

Wait until you find out what Google is paying Reddit…

Re: Cloudflare's new AI traffic options for customers

#145

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> Please consider installing one of the many PoW schemes such as anubis Why not go all the way and mine monero instead of just completely wasting the work?

because then someone will complain that you're stealing their CPU cycles or something, on the website they chose to visit and execute

"Stealing" CPU cycles is exactly what PoW bot protection is doing. The whole point is to add cost to the bots so they decide it's too expensive and give up.

The only difference is the cycles are getting converted into heat now. They could be getting converted into monero instead. It's still heat but at least creator got some money for it.

Re: Cloudflare's new AI traffic options for customers

#147

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Please don't use Anubis, it makes visiting websites very difficult (often multiple minutes wait times) on old hardware and low-end smartphones.

As things stand right now, the current web may not be possible to maintain for old and low-end phones given the costs imposed by AI training crawlers. Please propose an alternative to both Cloudflare and Anubis, that shields websites against inhuman traffic without frequent operator intervention (or otherwise negates the capacity costs they pay for AI crawling) and is compatible with low-end smartphones. Certainly, I…

Great you now made the internet unusable for half the planet.

Re: Cloudflare's new AI traffic options for customers

#149

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The irony here is that the people blocking all other crawlers are the ones shoring up their monopoly. If you can't block Googlebot because you need the search traffic but you block everybody else so that nobody other than Google can index your site, how do you expect to ever get any search traffic that isn't from Google?

Search traffic is nose diving due to LLM use. The fundamental calculus with google is you install GA and it helps your SEO has changed and google is riding out what will eventually wither as people start to reevaluate the trade off.

It's nose diving due to Google putting the LLM answer box at the top of the search results. But then isn't it even worse to be blocking every search engine crawler that isn't doing that?

Re: Cloudflare's new AI traffic options for customers

#150
post #18

This is fine so long as it’s easy for me to turn off. I just don’t want to accidentally lose all AI traffic one day.

Do you actually get any signifcant AI traffic today?

Yeah, maybe like 10:1 bot to human traffic. I'm just a rando blogger so I have principally machine readers - which is not a thing I mind. But I do use Cloudflare everywhere and I could just as well have PEBKACked a setting somewhere to block the traffic. Amusingly, I used to have like 100x the readers in the 2000s posting just as inane takes. I've been left behind by the refinement of the craft!
Post reply on HN