Live data from Hacker News

New Referendum Would Flip Brexit Result 10 Years On, Poll Finds

bloomberg.com

141–150 of 184 posts

Re: New Referendum Would Flip Brexit Result 10 Years On, Poll Finds

#141

Earlier quoted context omitted.

We can distill our disagreement into: "present perspective vs past perspective". Why do I think that the archaeologic/anthropologic perspective is a great point on this issue? It's because it's precisely one of the talking points of Japanese anti-immigration or xenophobic politicians or writers to emphasize those points. They always say that Japan is different in that of America or of European countries. However arch…

> gaijin which is widely regarded as a xenophobic slur. Its used commonly and not a slur.

You're right that it is used commonly, but we have the chance to be in a position to know better (thanks to our cross-cultural and larger perspective).

The right term is gaikokujin, but if we speak in English there is no reason to not just say "foreigner".

"gaijin" has the vibes of "outsider", and is never used in public speech other than by xenophobic speakers.

In private or familiar conversations it is commonly used, yes.

Re: New Referendum Would Flip Brexit Result 10 Years On, Poll Finds

#142

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> gaijin which is widely regarded as a xenophobic slur. Its used commonly and not a slur.

You're right that it is used commonly, but we have the chance to be in a position to know better (thanks to our cross-cultural and larger perspective). The right term is gaikokujin, but if we speak in English there is no reason to not just say "foreigner". "gaijin" has the vibes of "outsider", and is never used in public speech other than by xenophobic speakers. In private or familiar conversations it is commonly use…

[flagged]

Re: New Referendum Would Flip Brexit Result 10 Years On, Poll Finds

#143

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Japan is fairly homogenous with the obvious exception of the Ainu and certain castes. Much more so than Persia/Iran, Russia, Mexico or India. When Japan had a large empire, that was not so much the case, because they ruled over very different peoples.

That's not what most recent archaeological discoveries tell. Quite distinct groups of humans mixed in ancient Japan, as different and distant at that time as the groups that are mixed in modern times in Peru or India. Some groups were related to Autronesians, others to Yakuts, yet other groups to Hans, etc. If I remember correctly, at least three distinct groups are proven to have cohabited and arrived at different t…

and your point ?

Re: New Referendum Would Flip Brexit Result 10 Years On, Poll Finds

#144
post #91

Earlier quoted context omitted.

These questions aren't comparable. Japan had a crash modernization followed by a brief outburst of violent colonialism, which they thought was the style at the time but was actually in decline almost everywhere else. Britain had an empire that lasted hundreds of years, and whose greatest legacy is linguistic and temporal system dominance. Having spent centuries proclaiming itself to be the literal center of civilizat…

[flagged]

>"Mass immigration is your punishment for the British Empire" has a certain ideological appeal. But if you're a British person, you don't care about that. What matters is whether you'd rather live in London as it was in 2000 or London today. And I think the answer to that is obvious if your judgment isn't compromised. My parents went to visit London a year or two ago, and my mom was shocked by the decline in public order and standards, the ghettos, etc. This is a woman who lived in Bangladesh most of her life, and she came back telling me about the decline of London.

I walk around outside my home in the very heart of London: the street is full of Rolls Royces, pretty Russian and Ukrainian girls walk around carrying their Graff jewels and Kelly bags. Men still wear watches worth hundreds of thousands despite what the FT style section says.

What ghetto? Where is it? Everybody here is as rich as Croesus and very much a part of the same global jet set culture.

Re: New Referendum Would Flip Brexit Result 10 Years On, Poll Finds

#145

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Easy question with an easy answer that threatens a lot of bad people: immigrants are good.

Yes. Mixing of cultures always lead to adding up their different solutions to all kinds of problems, improving the fitness of the result among other groups of humans. It's gathering all the positive ideas or traditions of several groups, and the less useful or negative aspects tend to just fade naturally.

yeah that didnt workout in germany

Re: New Referendum Would Flip Brexit Result 10 Years On, Poll Finds

#146

None of this should be surprising unless you've been just gobbling up whatever you heard through mainstream media. Britain is at a breaking point. There are existential questions to be asked: Is Britain British without British Bourgeoisie that have lived there for thousands of years with new arrivals that have no commmon culture or connection to the land? Can Japan be called Japan without Japanese that have lived the…

> Why is it okay for one but not the other? Where does this double standard come from ?

Because in Japan AIUI they haven't been infiltrated by people pushing narratives that being eg White British is inherently racist, that to not open your borders to one and all is racism and xenophobia (you can see lots of examples of such people in the post about the Swiss referendum on the 10M population limit), which they do in order to gain for them and their communities.

The existing minority populations know they can abuse our good nature, our placidity, our leftist politicians, and even the English language in order to gain, and to position themselves as continuous victims. Some feminists do the same. The idea that the whole of the UK is full of angry white supremacist racists is the kind of propaganda I allude to (it's funny how many US folk here fall for it).

(I am British, lived here all my life, live in a county with many areas of significant minority populations, and just old enough to have observed plenty of change in England)

Re: New Referendum Would Flip Brexit Result 10 Years On, Poll Finds

#147
post #8

Earlier quoted context omitted.

[flagged]

As someone who is white british -- this isn't happening. Please stop regurgitating right wing US talk show talking points. It's boring.

London, white British %, census data

2001: 59%

2011: 44%

2021: 36%

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Demographics_of_London

Re: New Referendum Would Flip Brexit Result 10 Years On, Poll Finds

#148
post #147

Earlier quoted context omitted.

As someone who is white british -- this isn't happening. Please stop regurgitating right wing US talk show talking points. It's boring.

London, white British %, census data 2001: 59% 2011: 44% 2021: 36% https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Demographics_of_London

london is one place in the whole of the uk. might be the big stonking capital city, but it is definitely not representative of the whole of the UK.

late edit copypasta stat from sibling reply with actual national census data instead of cherry picking from the obvious culturally diverse capital city

> "White" remained the largest high-level ethnic group in England and Wales; 81.7% (48.7 million) of usual residents identified this way in 2021, a decrease from 86.0% (48.2 million) in 2011.

https://www.ons.gov.uk/peoplepopulationandcommunity/cultural...

80% is a long way off from 50%. and it took 10 years to drop by 5ish percent. in something like 50-60 years us white british people can start moaning about becoming a minority (assuming certain things on average stay the same, or average out over the 50-60 years).

Re: New Referendum Would Flip Brexit Result 10 Years On, Poll Finds

#149
post #91

Earlier quoted context omitted.

These questions aren't comparable. Japan had a crash modernization followed by a brief outburst of violent colonialism, which they thought was the style at the time but was actually in decline almost everywhere else. Britain had an empire that lasted hundreds of years, and whose greatest legacy is linguistic and temporal system dominance. Having spent centuries proclaiming itself to be the literal center of civilizat…

[flagged]

This comment is nonsense, and it is the usual propaganda based on an ideological bent. I'm sorry but I think you and your family have retained the class/caste based system of you original homeland and it is just manifesting in a weird way.

I am willing to bet your mother never encountered anything of the sort. Most of the old very rough areas in London are now gentrified (people complain about it). You can pretty much walk around anywhere in London, at night, without any issues. Phone snatching is the major problem, but general crime, violent crime, ghettoism, etc are all down since 2000.

I know this, because I am an immigrant from a 3rd world country, have lived in London for 25+ years. And the stats show it too.

Your post really makes me angry.

Re: New Referendum Would Flip Brexit Result 10 Years On, Poll Finds

#150
post #127

Earlier quoted context omitted.

As someone who is white british -- this isn't happening. Please stop regurgitating right wing US talk show talking points. It's boring.

Just look at the data, you say "it isn't happening" but it's easy to prove. University of Manchester: https://hummedia.manchester.ac.uk/institutes/code/briefings/... 1990: White British 95% 2025: White British 77% 2050 (projected): White British 57% Many parts of London the percentage in schools is already below 20%. Here are projections for the near future: https://www.theflyingfrisby.com/p/what-the-uk-population-wi…

as per sibling comment, your headline stats are cherry picking two things that are not representative of the whole of the uk.

university of manchester is a university, and since the cameron/clegg tuition fee change it was more profitable to attract international students. that’s not representative of the wider population, data is skewed. so you’re cherry picking some stats that are not representative there.

london, well it’s lahndahn. it’s in no way representative of the rest of the uk. remember how people complain about london centric decisions made that have no relation to where they live? because lahndahn is not representative of the rest of the country. when i go home to oxfordshire i don’t get confused with where i am because oxfordshire is obviously not the same place as lahdahn.

the projections are just projections and judging from the domain name aren’t from anywhere official. so i’ll gloss over them as i cba.

the one national statistic you’ve found - the a 4% share change from 69% ish to 64% over five years for school pupils, this is not white british people becoming a minority. it is a very long way to go until we’re under 50% in that one statistic.

here a better statistic from the 2021 census, actually tracking national level ethnicity

> “White" remained the largest high-level ethnic group in England and Wales; 81.7% (48.7 million) of usual residents identified this way in 2021, a decrease from 86.0% (48.2 million) in 2011.

https://www.ons.gov.uk/peoplepopulationandcommunity/cultural...

80% is a long way off from 50%.

i know it makes you all scared and insecure inside. but don’t forgot, these other people are just that. other people. the only scary thing about them is whatever is running through your own mind, or whatever bs people are spouting on social media. in reality, they’re not that scary actually. usually they’re really lovely humans. try speaking to some of them some time.

Post reply on HN