Live data from Hacker News

UK to permanently ban future generations from buying cigarettes

nypost.com

141–142 of 142 posts

Re: UK to permanently ban future generations from buying cigarettes

#141

Earlier quoted context omitted.

there is also a strong question as to whether smokers are actually a net cost to government or not. They draw decades less old age pension, have decades less medical visits, etc. I am extremely unconvinced that a large cancer related medical cost now has a higher net present value than a stream of government pension payouts, health costs, etc for decades ended with a large medical cost for some other reason. This is…

If your government requires its people to be dead, it is by nature a foul and evil thing.

thats one wrong way to interpret it, yes. The right way is a government choosing criteria to determine how much it should interfere in your personal choices and in that context net cost to the government is a reasonable metric to consider, although not the only metric

Re: UK to permanently ban future generations from buying cigarettes

#142
post #11

I cannot fathom the twists of logic necessary to justify such a specific and arbitrary prohibition

Smoking related illness costs the UK more in healthcare than the tax revenue it collects. No twist needed, it's really fucking logical.

It’s logical if you regard people as cattle
Post reply on HN