Live data from Hacker News

Revolt: Open-Source Alternative to Discord

revolt.chat

141–150 of 562 posts

Re: Revolt: Open-Source Alternative to Discord

#141

Earlier quoted context omitted.

How to quickly lose a few potential users.

It seems strange that someone would be offended by the US variant being called "simplified" spelling — wasn't that the whole point?

Maybe they meant people who don't want to be considered traditional...

Re: Revolt: Open-Source Alternative to Discord

#142
post #25

Earlier quoted context omitted.

It’s really fucking boring how every platform that hosts speech tries to nudge you in their direction these days.

No platform can allow you to 100% say whatever you want, just how it has limit to what it can enforce. Every platforms has to balance this fact. It is impossible to enforce clear borders on this as well, as human interaction is endlessly complex.

They can allow you to 100% say whatever you want as long as the law allows them to host your speech. If they try to limit you beyond that, they are censoring you, which is what is occurring here.

Re: Revolt: Open-Source Alternative to Discord

#143

What do people find upsetting about Discord? It's free, there's no ads, it's reliable, it has many established communities, it's cross-platform and even works in the browser, supports voice chat and screen sharing. What more could you ask for? Or, are you asking for too much? What I mean is: What innovative functionality is missing to such a degree, that if it was introduces, would make people abandon Discord?

> there's no ads

This is a patently ignorant and ridiculous statement. They absolutely shove their own store garbage every release and upsell Nitro at every opportunity. Here's an article from last year about them explicitly introducing third party ads.

https://techbriefly.com/2024/04/01/discord-introduces-ads-to...

Re: Revolt: Open-Source Alternative to Discord

#144

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> it is where enthusiasm is met with "bad girls" energy. What does that mean?

Group mentality that picks and chooses who is "cool" and then bullies everyone else.

Sounds to me like you're hanging out with the wrong people.

Re: Revolt: Open-Source Alternative to Discord

#145

What do people find upsetting about Discord? It's free, there's no ads, it's reliable, it has many established communities, it's cross-platform and even works in the browser, supports voice chat and screen sharing. What more could you ask for? Or, are you asking for too much? What I mean is: What innovative functionality is missing to such a degree, that if it was introduces, would make people abandon Discord?

> What do people find upsetting about Discord?

These are the most common complaints I see from people

- They don't allow third party clients and some people have various complaints about theirs (e.g resource usage)

- Some people think discord is too popular, to the point some things that "don't belong there" have moved to discord. This is usually about being search indexable and requiring an account.

- Fear of monopolostic behaviour ( "enshittification" )

- Some people are mad that they killed public urls for files uploaded to discord. Mostly this is people running into links to images online and being unable to see them, usually not the uploaders

- Discord is centralized and you cannot host your own server

- The only client they allow you to use (See above) is propietary, and some people would rather run something open source

As for me personally, their search functionality drives me insane. I feel like the exact same query gets completely different results depending on the time of day and phase of the moon, making it super unreliable.

Re: Revolt: Open-Source Alternative to Discord

#146

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I hate discord, it is where enthusiasm is met with "bad girls" energy. Plus, it's an information black hole.

> it is where enthusiasm is met with "bad girls" energy. What does that mean?

I think they might've meant "mean girls" energy... :)

Re: Revolt: Open-Source Alternative to Discord

#147
post #132

What do people find upsetting about Discord? It's free, there's no ads, it's reliable, it has many established communities, it's cross-platform and even works in the browser, supports voice chat and screen sharing. What more could you ask for? Or, are you asking for too much? What I mean is: What innovative functionality is missing to such a degree, that if it was introduces, would make people abandon Discord?

It's very, very badly performing. And yet every time I want to start it, it requires another 15 updates.

I agree about the updates, but I'm in a shit ton of servers and performance is fine for me. Can you talk to the issues you've had a bit?

Re: Revolt: Open-Source Alternative to Discord

#148
post #40

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> How is open-source supposed to compete without access to Apple's certificates? Does the license of your application somehow prevent you from following whatever Apple wants to do regarding signing? I think there are plenty of apps/games out there built on FOSS technology yet they're still signed and run like anything else signed on macOS, but maybe I remember incorrectly?

It’s the 99 bucks argument every time…

The problem is that with exception of single person projects it's not as simple as paying 99$.

Using individual developer account means exposing private information of one of the developers (which not everyone wants) and is a major buss factor.

Doing it properly with organization account means nontrivial amount of paper work to establish either a commercial company or an officially registered non profit. There are very few open source projects big enough for this.

Re: Revolt: Open-Source Alternative to Discord

#149

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> it is where enthusiasm is met with "bad girls" energy. What does that mean?

Group mentality that picks and chooses who is "cool" and then bullies everyone else.

But I assume that is because of the people on that specific server, not because of the software? Or is there something about discord that enables it, that IRC etc. does not have?

I hang out with friends that predate discord, on discord and can't see it. Same with new servers.

Re: Revolt: Open-Source Alternative to Discord

#150

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I think the biggest selling point is clearly the community. Without the community revolt.chat is just another Mattermost or Matrix. Discord is popular for one reason and one reason only, all the young people are there. The secret is how did they get popular with young kids? Well they offered a free service obviously, just like Google, just like Facebook. I've been trying to explain this to a friend recently. You're o…

> The secret is how did they get popular with young kids? Well they offered a free service obviously, just like Google, just like Facebook. In 2015, when they first got started, they marketed towards gamers (i.e. boys and men in their teens and early 20's). Even though the company's tagline at the time was that it offered a better Skype, Discord was more inclined to be a better replacement for a moribund Xfire and an…

Curse was becoming more popular than TS at the time, but Discord offered a better quality of audio and stable connection. That's why my group of friends migrated to Discord around 2016.
Post reply on HN