Live data from Hacker News

They see your photos

theyseeyourphotos.com

141–150 of 240 posts

Re: They see your photos

#141

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Apple Photos in iCloud can also be E2E encrypted (though not by default: you have to explicitly enable that), are indexed locally, and Apple's pricing for storage is about half of this service.

That assumes you only use apple devices for everything.

No, it also offers web access

Re: They see your photos

#142
post #85

Earlier quoted context omitted.

That phrasing raises my weasel-word hackles… first of all, it’s unclear what it would mean to “use your photos and videos for advertising.” That sounds to me like reprinting your photos to advertise something—which nobody accused them of doing. Perhaps more importantly, it only mentions the photos and videos themselves in relation to the advertising. Analyzing the photos (as per the demo in TFA) isn’t “advertising,”…

Cleverly lawyered weasel words are usually complex, highly specific and don't cover all possible uses. This statement is so simple and so general that it covers everything.

It’s as weaselly as the wording where they say things like “we use your data to improve our services, eg. personalised advertising. To opt out of personalised advertising […]”

Nowhere does it say they stop using your data.

Re: They see your photos

#143
post #138

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Embeddings (and other derived metadata) will sync across all your devices e2ee. So you could use our desktop app[1] to import and index your existing library. Newer photos will get indexed during upload on respective clients. Search is yet to be implemented on web and indexing is turned off by default on devices with General > Advanced > Machine learning. [1]: https://ente.io/download/desktop

Why should people not turn to https://permanent.org , a 501(c)(3) nonprofit that that claims to care about your photos even after you die?

I can’t see any evidence of encryption on their front page. I can see evidence of storing your data in multiple third party clouds (this is advertised as a feature, data redundancy).

Re: They see your photos

#144
post #140
post #128

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Exifpurge.com. A portable Windows app to remove all exif data from multiple photos.

Cool. Can anyone recommend a linux tool for removing exif data from images and metadata from pdfs?

For jpg: jhead -purejpg, exiftool looks like it only has "remove this specific kind" (like -gps:all= .)

(The more boring use case for this: putting images up on a web page - if you use jhead -autorot to correct the orientation, then the browser sees the metadata and rotates it again...)

Re: They see your photos

#145

Earlier quoted context omitted.

No it isn't. A democracy only works with informed voters. The amount of lies and obfuscation spewed by Trump's campaign is a successful attempt to deliberately break democracy. They don't have a mandate to do much besides mass deportation because they didn't talk about firing the entire federal workforce during the campaign. Project 2025 does talk about that but Trump lied during the campaign and said he disavowed it…

> No it isn't. A democracy only works with informed voters. By that logic we can never have a working democracy because collectively voters will always be ignorant and misinformed to some extent. We can't force voters to educate themselves on the issues and can't stop them from lying to themselves or to each other. We can do things to improve the situation, just as there has been a sustained and coordinated effort to…

My real problem is with the claim that they have a mandate to tear the government apart. That's not what they told voters during the election. They don't have a mandate for that.

Re: They see your photos

#146
post #140
post #128

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Exifpurge.com. A portable Windows app to remove all exif data from multiple photos.

Cool. Can anyone recommend a linux tool for removing exif data from images and metadata from pdfs?

exiftool is the standard. Should be in your distros repo...

https://exiftool.org/

Re: They see your photos

#147
post #62

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Terrible search without AI is a bit of a stretch. Also Google does not have a monopoly on object/face recognition in photos. There are self-hosted solutions that readily provide you with that without feeding a faceless AI with your photos while boiling the ocean.

Could you please tell some? I am about to switch to a self-hosted solution.

Immich is really good. They have AI semantic search, face grouping, etc. Really similar to Google Photos. Only the mobile app is still not that good.

https://immich.app/

Re: They see your photos

#148

  magick convert IMG_1111.HEIC -strip -quality 87 -shave 10x10 -resize 91% -attenuate 1.1 +noise Uniform out.jpg
This will strip ALL exif metadata, change the quality, shave 10 pixels off each edge just because, resize to xx%, attenuate, and adds noise of type "Uniform".

Some additional notes:

- attenuate needs to come before the +noise switch in the command line

- the worse the jpeg quality figure, the harder it is to detect image modifications[1]

- resize percentage can be a real number - so 91.5% or 92.1% ...

So, AI image detection notwithstanding, you can not only remove metadata but also make each image you publish different from one another - and certainly very different than the original picture you took.

[1] https://fotoforensics.com/tutorial.php?tt=estq

Re: They see your photos

#149

It'd be more terrifying if it didn't hallucinate earrings on somebody whose ears are out of frame , make comments about the left shoe of a barefoot child being out of focus, and so forth...

I had it trying to guess the economic status of a snow leopard.

> The image centers on a single snow leopard; there are no humans present. The leopard's expression is alert and slightly wary but not aggressive. It's difficult to definitively determine the leopard's age or exact health from the image, but it appears to be an adult in relatively good physical condition. There are no clear indications of its economic status or lifestyle

Re: They see your photos

#150

This is just an ad for their photo service. Which presumably has terrible search features, if it doesn't use AI to analyse them. That's one of the best features in Google Photos!

Terrible search without AI is a bit of a stretch. Also Google does not have a monopoly on object/face recognition in photos. There are self-hosted solutions that readily provide you with that without feeding a faceless AI with your photos while boiling the ocean.

> Terrible search without AI is a bit of a stretch.

How so? I was looking for a photo of a grave I took some years ago. In Google photos I just searched for "grave" and if found 2 photos, including the one I wanted.

Without AI I would have to search all my photos. Maybe I could narrow it down by date and location but it would take a lot longer.

Post reply on HN