Live data from Hacker News

How I Got a Digital Nomad Visa for Japan

tokyodev.com

141–150 of 196 posts

Re: How I Got a Digital Nomad Visa for Japan

#141
post #138

Can someone please explain to me why it is called “Visa” in some languages and “Visum” in others? My understanding is that “visum” means “that which has been seen” in Latin. What does “visa” mean then?

They're both forms (perfect passive particle in particular) of the latin verb "video". So they both mean "having been seen". The difference is in gender. visa = feminine; visum = neuter; visus = masculine.

Re: How I Got a Digital Nomad Visa for Japan

#142

Earlier quoted context omitted.

And a world of difference in stability and perception. If you have $35k+ to dedicate to this (and note that it does not cost $35k, these are more like initial capital requirements), you should 100% go the investor route. People underweight how amazing it is to be able to pay less than $50k for the equivalent of a golden visa to a top 5 GDP nation that is well regarded, safe, has some opportunity and is generally easy…

> People underweight how amazing it is to be able to pay less than $50k for the equivalent of a golden visa to a top 5 GDP nation that is well regarded, safe, has some opportunity and is generally easy to live in. The Japanese are incredibly racist and xenophobic. Numerous businesses outright place signs barring foreigners (particularly russians, chinese, etc) Japanese citizens are almost always completely trusted by…

This is heavily tilted.

The Japanese conviction rate is high, but this is largely in part because the authorities are extremely reluctant to try cases unless they have a slam-dunk case. See https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Criminal_justice_system_of_Jap...

  Scholars say the biggest reason for Japan's very high conviction rate is the 
  country's low prosecution rate and the way Japan calculates its conviction rate 
  is different from other countries. According to them, Japanese 
  prosecutors only pursue cases that are likely to result in convictions, and not 
  many others. According to Professor Ryo Ogiso of Chuo University, 
  prosecutors defer prosecution in 60% of the cases they receive, and conclude the 
  remaining 30% or so of cases in summary trials. This summary trial is a trial 
  procedure in which cases involving a fine of 1,000,000 yen or less are examined 
  on the basis of documents submitted by the public prosecutor without a formal 
  trial if there is no objection from the suspect. Only about 8% of cases are 
  actually prosecuted, and this low prosecution rate is the reason for Japan's 
  high conviction rate.
Also worth noting that, when evaluated equally, the US justice system has a similarly high rate:

  According to Bruce Aronson of New York University School of Law, Japan's conviction rate is
  misleading because it is the rate at which defendants admit guilt in the cases they are
  charged with. According to him, if the method of calculating the conviction rate in Japan is
  applied to the United States, the conviction rate of federal defendants in the United States
  in 2018 was also over 99%. According to him, when there is a discussion about Japan, it
  is easy to misunderstand because people quickly rely on broad cultural generalizations and
  stereotypes.
None of which is to say that there aren't serious problems with the Japanese justice system (or the US one, for that matter).

Re: How I Got a Digital Nomad Visa for Japan

#143
post #138

Can someone please explain to me why it is called “Visa” in some languages and “Visum” in others? My understanding is that “visum” means “that which has been seen” in Latin. What does “visa” mean then?

> My understanding is that “visum” means “that which has been seen” in Latin. What does “visa” mean then?

Basically the same thing, from the same root verb “vidēre”; vīsum is “that which has been seen” (noun), vīsa is “which has been seen” (adjective), from which English and some other languages have derived a noun “visa” as a shortening of the modern Latin “charta vīsa” (“paper/document which has been seen”) possibly through a french intermediary before English (different sources I’ve seen disagree on this.)

Re: How I Got a Digital Nomad Visa for Japan

#144

Earlier quoted context omitted.

If you read the article the author does quote the US embassy in Japan strictly advising against this and that you risk arrest and deportation, that immigration officials do crack down on digital nomads, especially re-entering Japan to renew 90 day tourist visas to work. A lot of countries have laws against working remotely without a visa, although apart from the US few actively enforce them.

Seems like the restriction would only make sense in the context of working for a Japanese company. Similar to US visas for visitors where the traveler cannot visit the US for work purposes with a US-based employer. Otherwise, opening a work laptop and answering some work emails for your foreign employer would be risky.

Precisely this - countries protecting their job markets against foreigners working illegally (not paying taxes, undercutting wages, etc).

This has nothing to do with you working for your own foreign employer while on vacation.

Re: How I Got a Digital Nomad Visa for Japan

#145
post #42

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Eh, I ran a business in Japan and have had that visa. I still tell most people who just want to dip their feet in that the digital nomad visa is totally fine and a good way to go. That stability and perception only matters if you _truly_ want to live here, and quite a number of people spend ~3 months here [1] and realize that it's got issues past the honeymoon period (like anywhere else). There's also no reason you c…

While this is purely anecdotal, the friends I have that ended up bailing earlier than planned got really annoyed by nonsensical things like ATMs having operating hours and having to use a fax machine to do something. They probably weren't the main problem but more straw that broke the camel's back.

The ATM working hours can be annoying but honestly I understand the reasoning, it's to prevent drunk guys from being taken advantage of or threatened into making withdraws.

Other than those who have built up Japan as a magical place in their head and are inevitably disappointed that it fails to match, I think that the reason that people end up bailing out of any country is one where they are unable to adapt to a culture and it's nuances.

Most people would get annoyed when you have to take a document to city hall, get it stamped at one desk thane take it 5 desks over for the stamp there as well. Or you can try and understand why their workflow may be this way. Or just not care.

If you are the kind of person who gets annoyed, then you will end up leaving.

Re: How I Got a Digital Nomad Visa for Japan

#146
post #88

with US passport I can stay in Japan for 90 days without a visa, if I want to work occasionally remotely for jobs at US part time, do I still need go through all the paperwork to get a Nomad visa? what's the purpose of Nomad visa when everyone has a laptop and can work remotely if they want to?

The article addresses this. > My first thought was to work remotely and use the 90 days permitted by the tourist visa. Yet working in Japan on this visa is a gray zone at best and a practice I would stay away from. In fact, the US Embassy in Japan strictly advises against this: > Persons found working illegally are subject to arrest and deportation. > Persons believed to be entering Japan without a working visa but w…

[deleted]

Re: How I Got a Digital Nomad Visa for Japan

#147
post #45

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I visited Tokyo from London recently and found it to be much cheaper. A decent meal is half, or less than half of what you would pay here, not to mention healthier. Another comment mentioned taxis are expensive, but I found the opposite, my journey was cheaper than it would have been in London, and the drivers are much more professional. As for apartments, you can live much cheaper and more centrally (~£1500 is the m…

Serious question, and not being flippant: crine in .jp vs .uk? Noticeable?

I had never felt so safe while I was there. I knew I didn't have to check over my shoulder, or walk down a side road if I wanted to use my phone so as to avoid having it grabbed from my hands. When I rented a bike, I could simply park it up without a lock, and knew I would come back to see it exactly where I left it. I forgot my bag in a taxi and got it back the next morning by going to the taxi office. I left my umbrella on a chair and came back to see it exactly where I left it.

It's how living in a civilised, first world country should be.

Re: How I Got a Digital Nomad Visa for Japan

#148
post #88

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The article addresses this. > My first thought was to work remotely and use the 90 days permitted by the tourist visa. Yet working in Japan on this visa is a gray zone at best and a practice I would stay away from. In fact, the US Embassy in Japan strictly advises against this: > Persons found working illegally are subject to arrest and deportation. > Persons believed to be entering Japan without a working visa but w…

Did more quick reading, Nomad visa gives you 6 month(tourist is 90 days), as long as you don't take local jobs you're fine, and there is no need to pay tax to Japan as well. now it seems just like a visa double the duration of tourist visa to me.

Right, “working illegally” here means taking local jobs, not working for your own employer located in a foreign country.

Re: How I Got a Digital Nomad Visa for Japan

#149
post #125

Earlier quoted context omitted.

This makes no sense... consider these scenarios: A) You work for a US company, earn money from the US company, pay income taxes in the US, live and spend money (and thus sales taxes) in the US B) You work for a US company, earn money from the US company, pay income taxes in the US, but live and spend money (and thus sales taxes) in Japan Clearly (B) is better for Japan economically? I think these laws are mostly enfo…

> Clearly (B) is better for Japan economically? Scenario B is amazing for the US. I don't see how it's clearly better for Japan. I don't know about you but I pay far more in income tax than sales tax. You spend money but you also consume government services and infrastructure while paying less in tax to Japan than a resident employed in Japan would.

But in scenario (B) you're spending money in Japan, basically you're directly injecting US money (your US salary) into the Japanese economy. Don't see why it's "amazing" for the US and not for Japan.

Re: How I Got a Digital Nomad Visa for Japan

#150

When the girlfriend was living in Japan I stayed for 89 days and then went to Taiwan (amazing country, highly recommended) and came back for another 87 days and nobody cared. I guess if you did this a lot it would be an issue but you’re reasonably fine to do it once I think. I was not working but I did have “free” accommodation in the smallest apartment I’ve ever been in so I’d be more concerned about this if I was a…

As the sibling comment noted, you were within the legal prescribed boundaries. The flag is automatic if something is off. No person (I think/in general/most countries) sits and counts days. The computer does.

In fact if they note they can not track exactly how many days you were in and out of the country that is a separate flag, that would likely in most jurisdiction lead to questioning.

(Source: friend had to pull his tickets and explain his travel path, when following unusual route via Schengen in between his entry/exit.)

Post reply on HN