Live data from Hacker News

Starlink Defies Order to Block X in Brazil

nytimes.com

141–150 of 207 posts

Re: Starlink Defies Order to Block X in Brazil

#141

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> Musk expect that a right wing government will align with him, and be in favor of blocking China and that would open the door for him to buy the mining companies instead.. Things in Brazil are not simple as that. Bolsonaro, the latest right wing president, did more business with china and russia than expected. He was one of the first chief of state to fly to Moscou when Russia invade Ukraine, to reinsure brazil woul…

He did more business then expected but he did not miss an opportunity to speak ill of china. There were even multiple letters from the Chinese embassy complaining about stuff he said.. China even blocked buying meat from Brazil for a while with the excuse of mad cow disease.. So regardless of how much business Bolsonaro did with China, he would be more inclined to help Elon in blocking China then the current left win…

nah, Bolsonaro criticizing China is the same as Lula criticizing the US: they are sending signals to their supporters.

Both know that Brazil is not in a position to refuse to do business with China and the US.

Re: Starlink Defies Order to Block X in Brazil

#142
post #135
post #75

Earlier quoted context omitted.

You will find Musk's pretend "free-speech absolutism" is highly selective, and only applies to far-right voices. He's repeatedly censored his critics and journalists on his platform.

Example?

https://theintercept.com/2022/11/29/elon-musk-twitter-andy-n...

Re: Starlink Defies Order to Block X in Brazil

#143

Earlier quoted context omitted.

He did more business then expected but he did not miss an opportunity to speak ill of china. There were even multiple letters from the Chinese embassy complaining about stuff he said.. China even blocked buying meat from Brazil for a while with the excuse of mad cow disease.. So regardless of how much business Bolsonaro did with China, he would be more inclined to help Elon in blocking China then the current left win…

nah, Bolsonaro criticizing China is the same as Lula criticizing the US: they are sending signals to their supporters. Both know that Brazil is not in a position to refuse to do business with China and the US.

Who said anything about stopping doing business with china??

What i said is that Elon expect that a right wing government would block, difficult or delay this single Chinese company from buying Sigma Lithium to help him to buy it instead..

Australia is doing the same think right now.. Australia is currently the largest exporter of Lithium in the world and Chinese companies tried to buy some mining companies there but the Australian government prohibited.. They said the Lithium mining is too important to the country and that they do not want China to control it..

There is some investigation going that China might have went ahead and acquired the mining companies in Australia indirectly via third-party companies and last i have seen Australia government had ordered those companies to sell their share or else they will seize then..

China is still one of the largest Australia trade partners, that did not stopped it from blocking the mining company acquisition..

Re: Starlink Defies Order to Block X in Brazil

#144

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> Musk expect that a right wing government will align with him, and be in favor of blocking China and that would open the door for him to buy the mining companies instead.. Things in Brazil are not simple as that. Bolsonaro, the latest right wing president, did more business with china and russia than expected. He was one of the first chief of state to fly to Moscou when Russia invade Ukraine, to reinsure brazil woul…

Unfortunately Lula isn't quite neutral as he likes to parrot Putin's propaganda narratives, particularly as to the root "cause" of the war: But it’s not just Putin who is guilty. The U.S. and the E.U. are also guilty. What was the reason for the Ukraine invasion? NATO? Then the U.S. and Europe should have said: “Ukraine won’t join NATO.” That would have solved the problem. https://time.com/6173232/lula-da-silva-trans…

Lula being aligned with Russia is not news..

But Lula will not move to prevent BYD from buying Sigma Lithium or to help Elon buy it instead.

While a right wing government is not guarantied they will help Elon there is a much higher chance of it..

Re: Starlink Defies Order to Block X in Brazil

#145

Earlier quoted context omitted.

You are free to express your opinions ("I don't like immigrants from Africa"), but you are not free to choose any manner of speech, as there's restrictions in certain areas, such as hate speech or inciting violence ("Kill the N-words!")

Isn't that full of loopholes though? It seems like that would allow someone in Germany to say "I think the Nazis were 100% right in what they did to the Jews", though my understanding is that would be very much illegal under German law. Similarly, would it be illegal to say "Kill the N-words!" but not "I think all the N-words should be killed!"? Obvious caveat - this is a highly contentious topic. Thank you for helpi…

Actually, that's why there's judge to interpret the Law

In Europe, in general (and that's something that look a bit strange to US it seem), we judge on THE SPIRIT of the Law more than on THE TEXT. So a European court would surely consider "hate speech" independantly of how it is phrased exactly

However "I think the Nazis were 100% right in what they did to the Jews" is IMHO NOT "hate speech" but an opinion. What would be "hate speech" would be more "We have to kill the XXXXXX" (insert any race, color, religion, sex....) or "All the XXX must die" (different phrasing, same idea).

"Hate speech" is, well, spreading hate against some people. The judge will decide case by case. Example: some humorist have some racists jokes but the context will make clear if it "hate speech" (1st degree) or "humor" (2nd degree)

Re: Starlink Defies Order to Block X in Brazil

#146

Earlier quoted context omitted.

nah, Bolsonaro criticizing China is the same as Lula criticizing the US: they are sending signals to their supporters. Both know that Brazil is not in a position to refuse to do business with China and the US.

Who said anything about stopping doing business with china?? What i said is that Elon expect that a right wing government would block, difficult or delay this single Chinese company from buying Sigma Lithium to help him to buy it instead.. Australia is doing the same think right now.. Australia is currently the largest exporter of Lithium in the world and Chinese companies tried to buy some mining companies there but…

> What i said is that Elon expect that a right wing government would block, difficult or delay this single Chinese company from buying Sigma Lithium to help him to buy it instead..

My point is about this: Musk's expectations will most likely not be met, even with a right wing president. Brazil and China are strong trading partners (and friends nowadays, with Brics became a reality).

Re: Starlink Defies Order to Block X in Brazil

#147
post #138

Earlier quoted context omitted.

People can do whatever they want. They just need to accept the consequences. I post my comments here knowing there's a risk this judge might learn of my existence and persecute me for them. I chose to accept that risk because I find this situation to appalling to keep quiet about it. This wasn't a choice I made lightly. My own parents who lived through last century's military dictatorship recognized the signs and ask…

> I post my comments here knowing there's a risk this judge might learn of my existence and persecute me for them My brother in Christ. There is ZERO chance of this to happen for this kind of comment and to me It only tells me you need to distance yourself a bit from this. Focus on something positive for a week. You're going down a path that is so far outside the realm of possibilities at this time that's worrisome.

I wouldn't say there's a zero chance. The judge has gone after YouTubers and journalists before. I know that at least some of them fled to the USA to escape his persecution. There's one journalist in particular that the judge hates so much he was mentioned in those WhatsApp message leaks. Judge and his people apparently think the USA is being "difficult" for not giving the guy up.

Re: Starlink Defies Order to Block X in Brazil

#148
post #135

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Example?

https://theintercept.com/2022/11/29/elon-musk-twitter-andy-n...

X and US law both have rules against incitement of imminent violence. It's one of the only exceptions to the First Amendment. X extends that to making violent threats in general. Those accounts were doing the latter and sometimes the former.

The @vps_reports account named in the first tweet in your story is a good example. The Intercept claims they were suspended for engaging in "journalism", "organizing" and "documenting extremism". X claims they were suspended for making violent threats.

If we follow links a bit further we see what sort of tweets @vps_reports was making:

https://twitter.com/stillgray/status/1596074770193604609/pho...

> "One last thing. ChayaRaichik10 should live in fear for the rest of her days. It's only fair. Put the PHOBIA in her transphobia."

(there are several more examples like that)

It's not surprising that such people would fall afoul of an anti-threat rule if enforced fairly. Pre-Musk, people like that could make violent threats on Twitter, or even coordinate mob violence there, as long as they were threatening right wing people. Musk fixed that. The Intercept is being dishonest.

Re: Starlink Defies Order to Block X in Brazil

#149

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Who said anything about stopping doing business with china?? What i said is that Elon expect that a right wing government would block, difficult or delay this single Chinese company from buying Sigma Lithium to help him to buy it instead.. Australia is doing the same think right now.. Australia is currently the largest exporter of Lithium in the world and Chinese companies tried to buy some mining companies there but…

> What i said is that Elon expect that a right wing government would block, difficult or delay this single Chinese company from buying Sigma Lithium to help him to buy it instead.. My point is about this: Musk's expectations will most likely not be met, even with a right wing president. Brazil and China are strong trading partners (and friends nowadays, with Brics became a reality).

And what i am saying is that i do not agree with that take..

While a right wing government is not guarantied that Elon will be able to buy Sigma Lithium, i am 100% sure that a right wing government will work to try block or at least delay as much as possible the acquisition by BYD..

Specially in the unlikely case that Trump win the US election, remembering that Elon is supporting him.. US will not only support blocking China from increasing their foothold in the region, they would likely pressure Brazil for it..

It might even happen with Kamala but to a smaller degree..

Re: Starlink Defies Order to Block X in Brazil

#150
post #67
post #41

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Do you have any examples where he blocks other people's speech?

How about this? https://newrepublic.com/post/177936/twitter-suspends-account... "This is at least the fifth time that X, under Musk, has purged accounts that are the slightest bit critical of him, his friends, or causes he supports"

That article says the suspensions lasted only a few hours. In no way were they "purged", and the first three named accounts all are highly active.

MintPress News journalist: https://twitter.com/alanrmacleod (active, posted in the last hour)

Intercept journalist: https://twitter.com/kenklippenstein (active, posted 46 minutes ago)

Texas Observer journalist: https://x.com/stevanzetti (active, posted 2 hours ago)

If these are the best examples of Musk engaging in censorship then he must be doing a very fair job indeed!

A more likely explanation is that the suspensions were related to anti-botting activity, as they came back from suspension with fewer followers than before. Journalists buying Twitter followers is not unheard of, unfortunately:

https://www.nbcnews.com/news/us-news/journalists-struggle-ex...

Post reply on HN