Live data from Hacker News

Apple Intelligence for iPhone, iPad, and Mac

apple.com

141–150 of 1001 posts

Re: Apple Intelligence for iPhone, iPad, and Mac

#141
post #129

I remain skeptical until I see it in action. On the one hand, Apple has a good track record with privacy and keeping things on device. On the other, there was too much ambiguity around this announcement. What is the threshold for running something in the cloud? How is your personal model used across devices - does that mean it briefly moves to the cloud? How does its usage change across guest modes? Even the phrase "…

Same they say privacy so many times i got Facebook PTSD.

Re: Apple Intelligence for iPhone, iPad, and Mac

#143
So, if I've got this correct there's:

1. On-device AI

2. AI using Apple's servers

3. AI using ChatGPT/OpenAI's services (and others in the future)

Number 1 will pass to number 2 if it thinks it requires the extra processing power, but number 3 will only be invoked with explicit user permission.

[Edit: As pointed out below, other providers will be coming eventually.]

Re: Apple Intelligence for iPhone, iPad, and Mac

#145
post #111

Calling it Apple Intelligence seems a bit short sighted to me considering how quickly things are moving in this space. There's a danger that before long, the stuff Apple will take ages to implement into their devices will seem dated compared to the state of the art less encumbered players will be rolling out. I felt that a few times watching them demo image generation and contextual conversations.

For broadly similar reasons, I think it's a wise move to ensure Apple's AI services exist under a brand Apple entirely controls.

Re: Apple Intelligence for iPhone, iPad, and Mac

#146

It’s a little disappointing that even big companies like Apple jump on OpenAI instead of building their own thing. Diversity seems pretty important with AI.

They use OpenAI as an optional fallback model. Adding support for more models later. I’m positively surprised they’re not trying to solve everything with their own tech.

Re: Apple Intelligence for iPhone, iPad, and Mac

#147
post #129

I remain skeptical until I see it in action. On the one hand, Apple has a good track record with privacy and keeping things on device. On the other, there was too much ambiguity around this announcement. What is the threshold for running something in the cloud? How is your personal model used across devices - does that mean it briefly moves to the cloud? How does its usage change across guest modes? Even the phrase "…

They need to provide a mechanism to view the data being uploaded by you

Re: Apple Intelligence for iPhone, iPad, and Mac

#150

It’s a little disappointing that even big companies like Apple jump on OpenAI instead of building their own thing. Diversity seems pretty important with AI.

Unfortunately OpenAI has a pretty big "dollars and hours spent on GPUs" moat right now. I imagine Apple is already hard at work building their own models, but until then they will leverage 3rd parties
Post reply on HN