Live data from Hacker News

Asteroid Mining Venture Backed by Google Execs, James Cameron Unveiled

space.com

141–150 of 221 posts

Re: Asteroid Mining Venture Backed by Google Execs, James Cameron Unveiled

#141
post #45

I wouldn't drink water from a heavy-metal rich asteroid.

Right now, here on Earth, heavy metals are being extracted from water to make it drinkable. If you've ever drank water that wasn't straight from a well, you've had water that has had heavy metals filtered from it.

Re: Asteroid Mining Venture Backed by Google Execs, James Cameron Unveiled

#142
Reading through this thread makes me realize there is no shortage of people who want to contribute either financially or through engineering talents.

Prior to now, I didn't even realize it was conceivably feasible to do asteroid mining... but if it is, why doesn't someone start a massive open source track? A classic space race, though it would between a private company, and a non government public effort. I'll contribute money and time :D

Re: Asteroid Mining Venture Backed by Google Execs, James Cameron Unveiled

#143

Earlier quoted context omitted.

This leads to scary thoughts on using this for military purposes

If you're going to bombard something for military purposes, the most effective technique involves using a very large number of nuclear weapons, which is well within the capabilities of anyone who would try to bombard the earth from space. Back during the Space Race, the idea that the Russians could put something into orbit wasn't just a wound to the national pride, it was a technical demonstration of the fact that th…

[deleted]

Re: Asteroid Mining Venture Backed by Google Execs, James Cameron Unveiled

#144

Wow. Second the comments about feeling about ten years old again. I hope beyond all hope that this is actually happening in my lifetime. Questions for those in the know: 1. Is there any legal precedent on whether or not they're even allowed to mine the asteroids? From what I understand the Moon can't be exploited by any one country or corporation. Does any similar law apply to asteroids? 2. How are they going to get…

1. Law seems to be undecided. http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/47151745/ns/technology_and_scien.... Presumably once someone starts to do some actual mining there will be some pressure to move on this.

2. Drop it in small bundles (a few tons?) over the ocean with a flotation device and a large reusable parachute. Preferable avoiding areas with significant pirate populations.

Re: Asteroid Mining Venture Backed by Google Execs, James Cameron Unveiled

#145
post #142

Reading through this thread makes me realize there is no shortage of people who want to contribute either financially or through engineering talents. Prior to now, I didn't even realize it was conceivably feasible to do asteroid mining... but if it is, why doesn't someone start a massive open source track? A classic space race, though it would between a private company, and a non government public effort. I'll contri…

I wouldn't normally post song lyrics to HN, but this just seemed too appropriate:

  *And I want it so much.
  Close my eyes, I can taste the Mars dust in the air.
  In the darkness the space stations shimmer in orbits that I will not share.

  But I'll teach the student
  Who'll manage the fact'ry
  That tempers the steel that makes colonies strong.
  And I'll write the program that runs the computer
  That charts out the stars where our rockets belong.
  It will never get easy to wake from my dream
  When the future I dream of is so far away.
  But I am willing to sacrifice
  something I don't have For something I won't have
  but somebody will someday.*

Re: Asteroid Mining Venture Backed by Google Execs, James Cameron Unveiled

#147
I am tremendously excited to hear about this project; it's exactly what I want(ed) to do, these billionaires have just gotten the jump on me by a few (dozen) zeroes of net worth.

If any of them are reading, or anyone here knows them, I would do anything to get involved in this effort; the development and exploration of space is the most important mission in human history, and I'd love to put to work my business expertise, youthful energy, and eagerness to contribute... I'm well credentialed but more importantly extremely passionate!

Re: Asteroid Mining Venture Backed by Google Execs, James Cameron Unveiled

#148
post #88

Earlier quoted context omitted.

All it would take to get governments back into the game is some private firm proving the value of resources that can be mined there. If governments get a clue of how valuable space real estate, energy and resources can be. Expect a space race, like weapons race. In fact you can expect wars on the basis of who controls which asteroids and who gets to stay where on mars.

I can see perhaps the Chinese and maybe the Russians looking to own asteroids, but that would require they pull out of several international treaties (not that big of a deal). For the West, their model has always been government-backed private monopolies (Hudson's Bay Company, East India Company, United Fruit, modern oil companies, etc). The American government would be more than happy to let Planetary resources do t…

Two words : United Nations.

Given the ever growing need for money I can bet a tax would be put in place to where it might not even be profitable after all the regulation and such got put into position.

Think about it. They can lay levies for everything from managing the movement of objects in space to the environmental damage and insurance against such for returning materials gained in space. Then comes the whole "it belongs to all and none" type spiel that will surely follow.

Post reply on HN