Live data from Hacker News

Does Company ‘X’ have an Azure Active Directory Tenant?

shawntabrizi.com

141–150 of 197 posts

Re: Does Company ‘X’ have an Azure Active Directory Tenant?

#141

What I can’t understand is why Azure AD doesn’t have a stronger position in the consumer space. Authentication via Google, Apple, and even still Facebook are nearly always supported on customer-facing logins. I rarely see an option for Microsoft. They have a commanding position in the enterprise. What’s keeping them from crossing those enterprise boundaries?

Isn't every github account also a microsoft account? There are plenty sites there integrating with github login.

Re: Does Company ‘X’ have an Azure Active Directory Tenant?

#143
post #21

Earlier quoted context omitted.

NetIQ eDirectory tends to be the other big one. Although I am seeing a rise in companies not having an SSO solution recently at all. In fact some of the SMEs I've seen recently are running most of their stuff entirely via basic Microsoft O365 accounts or iCloud.

A lot of startups or smaller companies I've worked with are entirely on the Google stack (gmail, google drive). I imagine there's a scale when that option breaks, but I think it'd be fine until 50-100 employees.

I've seen it working for schools with 5000+ account so it'll go well past 100 users. Not sure I'd want to depend on Google though.

Re: Does Company ‘X’ have an Azure Active Directory Tenant?

#145

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Really? So you really think companies shouldn’t be able to sell software that works together bundled together? Why stop there? Phones and computers shouldn’t be “bundled” with operating systems? Computers shouldn’t be “bundled” with sound hardware? Where does it stop?

Bundling is fine. Bundling by a company that is a monopoly in the space is (or rather, used to be) a violation of antitrust law. But see Amazon’s Antitrust Paradox, especially sections IIA and IIIB: https://www.yalelawjournal.org/note/amazons-antitrust-parado...

So in that case, every cable company is a local monopoly and shouldn’t be allowed to bundle channels. Doesn’t anyone see how silly this sounds in 2022?

Disney is by far the largest entertainment conglomerate. Should they not be allowed to bundle Hulu, Disney and ESPN?

Intel has over 80% of the PC market, how much hardware should they be able to bundle on their motherboard?

And HN has a habit of calling any big company a “monopoly”. Amazon only has 56% share of e-commerce and a tiny share of all commerce in the US

But getting back to MS Office, I have three “office suites” right now on my phone - all three made by companies worth 1 trillion dollars - Google, Microsoft, and Apple.

There is no “monopoly” in the IDP space.

Re: Does Company ‘X’ have an Azure Active Directory Tenant?

#146

This is assuming the domain has it, but it's even easier actually - you can just DIG DNS records and see if what they run as MX, cnames, etc, if there is teams DNS records and the MX record points to *.onmicrosoft.com or $tenantname.mail.protection.outlook.com there you go, even easier than "querying" google and seeing what's index. And much easier to script too. ;)

This shows you which domains uses Microsoft365 though not Azure AD

Re: Does Company ‘X’ have an Azure Active Directory Tenant?

#148

Microsoft is traditionally great at bundling their products. This is reminiscent of bundling Internet Explorer with Windows. Could an Okta have a claim against Microsoft similar to Netscape in the late 90's?

Signing up for Office 365 gets the company in AzureAD as it is used for logging into 365 on the back end. And all the user accounts etc. You can have another identity solution and also Azure AD. Its just why would you when everyone needs an email and they are already in AAD

Re: Does Company ‘X’ have an Azure Active Directory Tenant?

#149

I know next to nothing about AD, but my company appears to match against this merely because we have an Office 365 account (from which we do nothing except download Word and Excel every now and then) so it doesn't necessarily mean you're using whatever it is much.

You dont use it for email/exchange online?

All 365 accounts get created in AAD. And your user has access to the portal even. https://aad.portal.azure.com/

Re: Does Company ‘X’ have an Azure Active Directory Tenant?

#150
post #125

What I can’t understand is why Azure AD doesn’t have a stronger position in the consumer space. Authentication via Google, Apple, and even still Facebook are nearly always supported on customer-facing logins. I rarely see an option for Microsoft. They have a commanding position in the enterprise. What’s keeping them from crossing those enterprise boundaries?

Only very recently Windows started requiring a MS account. I'd guess most people who don't own a Xbox don't have a MS account.

Every hotmail and outlook email is an MS account...
Post reply on HN