Live data from Hacker News

Productivity porn

calebschoepp.com

141–150 of 430 posts

Re: Productivity porn

#141
I think for content like this there's a scale between mostly "feel good" fluff (i.e. Gary V stuff, imo) to mostly "useful" stuff (i.e. Atomic Habits, imo). But everything has a mixture of actionability and story-based fluff thrown in there entertainment/inspirational value.

In my opinion, the fluff gets you through the drier parts of the reads. But what you decide to actually take out of the book and action on - that's up to you.

You turned it into mere entertainment when you read but didn't take action, for example, clean up your desk to enable your habits to begin, as clearly described in the Atomic Habits book.

The good reads you'll probably need to note down and return to a few times to extract all the useful, concrete advice.

Re: Productivity porn

#142

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I get that this is satire but could you expand on why people who want to be healthy + productive "have it wrong" (which I feel your satirical comment alludes to?) You're "taking the piss" at people who value working hard/long hours, reading, trying to be successful financially, taking care of their health/fitness, cutting ties with loser friends (drug addicts? bums?)

I’m not qualified to comment on the health factor. In general striving to be healthy is good, no contest there. But regarding working those long and hard hours (which then cannot be spent on other things) maybe we should heed the advice of the dying: https://www.theguardian.com/lifeandstyle/2012/feb/01/top-fiv... > 2. I wish I hadn't worked so hard. > > "This came from every male patient that I nursed. They missed th…

For anybody who is just scrolling by and not clicking any links:

Top five regrets of the dying

1. I wish I'd had the courage to live a life true to myself, not the life others expected of me.

2. I wish I hadn't worked so hard.

3. I wish I'd had the courage to express my feelings.

4. I wish I had stayed in touch with my friends.

5. I wish that I had let myself be happier.

Re: Productivity porn

#144

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I get that this is satire but could you expand on why people who want to be healthy + productive "have it wrong" (which I feel your satirical comment alludes to?) You're "taking the piss" at people who value working hard/long hours, reading, trying to be successful financially, taking care of their health/fitness, cutting ties with loser friends (drug addicts? bums?)

Valuing hard work, reading and trying to be financially successful is something completely unrelated to trying to do 18 hour work days, skimming several books a day, and running the hamster wheel off the peg and into the frying pan. Hard work is often what is required to be successful, but just mindlessly toiling away is not the key ingredient to success. Also, what good is a friend who wouldn't come to your aid in t…

> Valuing hard work, reading and trying to be financially successful is something completely unrelated to trying to do 18 hour work days

Are you trying to say "it's easy to be financially successful by working 8 hours a day instead of 18 hours"?

like... it's "overstated" that people think they need to "work more/work harder" to become successful?

Re: Productivity porn

#145
post #35

I can't find an online article where Merlin Mann discusses this but I remember very vividly him talking about why he stopped posting on 43Folders.com a decade ago. 43Folders was a GTD productivity porn site and after while Merlin decided that he didn't want to be "giving drugs to addicts" and stopped posting little "5 ways to write a better task title" articles for all the same reasons OP is writing about here.

Here ya go, one of my all time favorites of his: https://www.43folders.com/2011/04/22/cranking

A beautiful piece, thank you. But this is more about him prioritizing family over his book. It must have been on a podcast I remember him talking about how he kind of had a crisis of faith over running 43folders and stopped doing little "life hack" posts.

Re: Productivity porn

#146

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Parent poster is referring to the people that take "healthy and productive", condense it, distill it, then shoot it into their veins. At some threshold it becomes an obsession, which is not great.

why would anybody want to be unhealthy and unproductive? what is to be gained from those two characteristics?

Fun. The answer is fun.

But obviously, it's not that you have fun eating because you're unhealthy, it's that you're unhealthy because you eat stuff for enjoyment.

Similarly, being unproductive isn't fun in itself, but having fun means almost by definition not being productive. If a hobby is productive, it's not really a hobby.

Re: Productivity porn

#147

I recently read The Focal Point and The One Thing. While these are tangentially related to productivity porn, they finally allowed me to let go of optimizing my work methods and focus on the one or two important things every day/week/month/year/lifetime. Stress levels: plummeting. Output (& happiness) much, much higher, far more than 10x before Optimized work methods: I now print out a very short to-do list for each…

Have these books on my list. I feel you would recommend them?

10/10, yes.

Re: Productivity porn

#148

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Parent poster is referring to the people that take "healthy and productive", condense it, distill it, then shoot it into their veins. At some threshold it becomes an obsession, which is not great.

why would anybody want to be unhealthy and unproductive? what is to be gained from those two characteristics?

No post body was provided.

Re: Productivity porn

#150

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Parent poster is referring to the people that take "healthy and productive", condense it, distill it, then shoot it into their veins. At some threshold it becomes an obsession, which is not great.

why would anybody want to be unhealthy and unproductive? what is to be gained from those two characteristics?

The opposite of these people is not necessarily "unhealthy and unproductive".
Post reply on HN