Live data from Hacker News

Crypto Winter, or Crypto Ice Age?

technollama.co.uk

141–150 of 167 posts

Re: Crypto Winter, or Crypto Ice Age?

#141
post #22

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Wire transfers in North America are literally 40 years behind the evolution of bank transfers in EU and UK. Sending money in Europe is free and increasingly often instantaneous 24/7. It will be very difficult for crypto to reach the level of convenience available on unified infrastructure created through sensible regulation. Lacking that, maybe Americans will have to keep settling for all these clunky, incompatible i…

We must have different definitions of Europe because I live in Romania (which has been a member of the European Union since 2007) and yet even national transfers are not instantaneous if you're doing them in the evening, not to mention the weekend. And don't get me started with transfers to other European countries. I also think you meant cheap, not free. By the way I find it funny that some banks tax the receiver, s…

In the UK they're still usually instantenous in the evening, and also completely free.

Re: Crypto Winter, or Crypto Ice Age?

#142
post #13

I live in Canada and recently invested a small amount in a startup via AngelList RUV. There were two funding options: (1) wire transfer, (2) transfer USDC via Ethereum network. One of these options is cheaper, faster, and more flexible than the other. Crypto has long been criticized for being gambling and lacking utility. I think utility is finally trickling in, although currently in limited settings. If you look at…

It's not kicking in. The utility was always there and very few people/institutions have any interest in using it. Whatever fee/time costs are inherent in the current system are obviously worth whatever security and regulatory oversight they offer. Enough stable coins have collapsed to remove whatever credibility the entire idea of a stable coin may have.

You're going to be the edge case for a long time.

Re: Crypto Winter, or Crypto Ice Age?

#143

Earlier quoted context omitted.

We must have different definitions of Europe because I live in Romania (which has been a member of the European Union since 2007) and yet even national transfers are not instantaneous if you're doing them in the evening, not to mention the weekend. And don't get me started with transfers to other European countries. I also think you meant cheap, not free. By the way I find it funny that some banks tax the receiver, s…

In the UK they're still usually instantenous in the evening, and also completely free.

Including for companies?

Re: Crypto Winter, or Crypto Ice Age?

#144

Earlier quoted context omitted.

But that's the point he made. It's not Blockchain it's Blockchain + escrow. Escrow needs a third party. It destroys all your Blockchain advantage.

Escrow is handled on the blockchain with a smart contract. There are no trusted third parties. https://academy.particl.io/en/latest/in-depth/indepth_escrow...

Aren't the authors of the smart contact a third party? Unless they're so simple a layperson can inspect, read, and understand them.

Re: Crypto Winter, or Crypto Ice Age?

#145

Earlier quoted context omitted.

But that's the point, crypto is a coordination mechanism that in most cases serves as an alternative when you don't have effective and trustworthy centralized institutions. It's pretty clear that (in this case) European financial regulators did a good job coordinating an effective and efficient electronic money transmission system. But the whole world is not Sweden. Even in America, which is relatively first world wi…

I’m currently in Turkey. I can transfer funds from any bank account to another in about 1 sec., for a very low or no fee, 7/24. I can even withdraw money from an ATM w/o a card just by scanning a QR code from banks app. All merchants have adapted contactless visa etc.. payments. I honestly don’t see how crypto has a sliver of chance as payment alternative.

Turkey? Good luck with the Lira.

Re: Crypto Winter, or Crypto Ice Age?

#146

Earlier quoted context omitted.

In the UK they're still usually instantenous in the evening, and also completely free.

Including for companies?

Can't speak for the UK, but at least in Austria a company bank account is no different from a personal bank account, at least as far as technology is concerned.

That said, I know at least a couple of (admittedly rather large/corporate) companies that explicitly opted out of instant transfers for some reason.

Re: Crypto Winter, or Crypto Ice Age?

#147
post #39
post #22

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Wire transfers in North America are literally 40 years behind the evolution of bank transfers in EU and UK. Sending money in Europe is free and increasingly often instantaneous 24/7. It will be very difficult for crypto to reach the level of convenience available on unified infrastructure created through sensible regulation. Lacking that, maybe Americans will have to keep settling for all these clunky, incompatible i…

That's the point! Locally, there are great options almost everywhere. In Canada, I can e-transfer (Interac) anyone and the transfer is ~instant. Across borders the solutions are much worse. Crypto is the only payment rail that can realistically reach _everywhere_.

And how often is that needed? And how often does it not also involve other issues, such as violating money laundering rules or tariffs?

Crypto is the only payment rail that is practically accepted nowhere (I cannot use it to pay 99,99% of the places I do business with).

Re: Crypto Winter, or Crypto Ice Age?

#148

If the author didn't bother to mention central banks, monetary policy or currency debasement in the article, I don't think he quite gets the real value of Bitcoin.

So there was never a way to invest money before? Such as buying gold, stock, bonds, real estate or natural resources such as oil?

Re: Crypto Winter, or Crypto Ice Age?

#149
post #5

Bitcoin is absolute garbage and in theory any critique is good, but it bothers me that half of the points in this article aren't even internally logically consistent: > “Blockchain is just like the early internet”. No, it isn’t. Satoshi Nakamoto’s paper was published in October 2008 ... . Nothing about the original statement is predicated on the age of the tech. Even if it did, I don't see what modern tech corps have…

Gold is worse than Bitcoin in every way.

1. Its harder to store gold

2. Its harder to verify the integrity of gold

3. Its harder to transfer gold

Re: Crypto Winter, or Crypto Ice Age?

#150

Earlier quoted context omitted.

But that's the point he made. It's not Blockchain it's Blockchain + escrow. Escrow needs a third party. It destroys all your Blockchain advantage.

Escrow is handled on the blockchain with a smart contract. There are no trusted third parties. https://academy.particl.io/en/latest/in-depth/indepth_escrow...

Sooo I write a smart contract and say you pay 10€ when you buy ice cream?

Who proofs that the smart contract is fulfilled?

Or let's asked different: how does a smart contract solves the trust issue from items not on the Blockchain?

Post reply on HN