Live data from Hacker News

Inside Putin's Circle

ft.com

141–150 of 239 posts

Re: Inside Putin's Circle

#141
post #100
post #87

Earlier quoted context omitted.

We will be much closer if Russia cannot win

Then stop helping Ukraine? But then don't be surprised when Putin invades Latvia and Estonia.

>don't be surprised when Putin invades Latvia and Estonia.

They are NATO countries, so no. People are acting all surprised by this Ukraine invasion but it's been an ongoing thing for many years. This didn't just happen. Even before the coup/revolution in 2014.

Re: Inside Putin's Circle

#142
post #131

Earlier quoted context omitted.

there's also long interviews from 2017~ on PBS Frontline IIRC, a series called "Putin files" Julia Ioffe, Masha Gessen It's partial but has a lot of detail On the other side there are the Russian friendly views such as Mearsheimer or even Stone. It's difficult to weigh what is true (even though I'm biased anti aggressor in this case)

>Russian friendly views such as Mearsheimer I don't know that I would refer to Professor Mearsheimer's view as pro-Russian, he has plenty of criticism of Putin and the Russian political system in general. But the fact that he has been railing on the likely consequences of our approach for dealing with the Russia/Ukraine situation for years, and been proved right, should make his writing and interviews required for an…

That's why I said russian friendly.. it's a subtle topic.

Re: Inside Putin's Circle

#143
post #104

Earlier quoted context omitted.

"The Chinese model" is fundamentally underwritten by exporting vast quantities of goods to the West which Putin just blew up any hope of doing.

Other than fossil fuels and vodka, what does Russia have to offer the world?

Suicidal novelists of course.

Re: Inside Putin's Circle

#144
post #42

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> FSB is an intelligence agency It is a security agency, a.k.a. the “secret police.” (It does, of course, spy on the populace.)

Basically the Stasi of Russia, no?

FSB is former KGB, so indeed it is Stasi, but KGB may be even more familiar name from those times.

Re: Inside Putin's Circle

#145
post #3

> These men are known in Russia as the “siloviki” — “men of force”, or perhaps even, in the Irish phrase, “hard men”. Just to clarify. The word "siloviki" made from "силовые структуры", which may be translated literally as "structures of force", or less literally but preserving some meaning "armed organizations" (maybe "armed forces", but I think that in English "armed forces" doesn't include the likes of police and…

"siloviki" is literally a "men of power" ("sila" in Russian is "power" in English) => these include the FSB (an FBI equivalent, or the ex-KGB in practice) and MVD (the police). That's it.

“sila” is strength, not power. Power is “vlast.”

Re: Inside Putin's Circle

#146
post #47

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Does a dollar a day sound more affordable? Just read the news over a cup of home-brewed coffee instead of getting a take-out, and you should easily break even. :)

If I'm going out to get my avocado toast anyway, it only makes sense to get the coffee with it since I'm right there. Maybe they should let me round up my change to get the day's FT news with my coffee at Starbucks instead.

Not an entirely bad idea.

Re: Inside Putin's Circle

#147
post #131

Earlier quoted context omitted.

>Russian friendly views such as Mearsheimer I don't know that I would refer to Professor Mearsheimer's view as pro-Russian, he has plenty of criticism of Putin and the Russian political system in general. But the fact that he has been railing on the likely consequences of our approach for dealing with the Russia/Ukraine situation for years, and been proved right, should make his writing and interviews required for an…

That's why I said russian friendly.. it's a subtle topic.

Mearsheimer has been trotted out by so many people that likely never heard of him three weeks ago that it's getting a bit tiring.

Re: Inside Putin's Circle

#148

Earlier quoted context omitted.

That's why I said russian friendly.. it's a subtle topic.

Mearsheimer has been trotted out by so many people that likely never heard of him three weeks ago that it's getting a bit tiring.

That tends to happen when someone turns out to have accurately predicted the future.

Re: Inside Putin's Circle

#149
post #119

Evaluation of Russia by Finnish Intelligence Colonel (subtitles) https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=kF9KretXqJw I think this is something you should watch if you are interested in how russia works. It's very straight talk and clarified russian mindset a lot for me at least.

Also a long and great Twitter thread: https://nitter.net/kamilkazani/status/1501360272442896388

He has a number of good threads.

Re: Inside Putin's Circle

#150

I’ve been a paid subscriber of FT for years. It’s horrifically expensive and worth every penny.

I was a subscriber for ten years, but gave up on them over mediocre coverage of important issues in the US and East Asia, about which I had some knowledge. Relying on their reporting risked costing me money in my investment decisions.

Do you have an opinion on Asia.Nikkei.com?
Post reply on HN