Live data from Hacker News

Shipping containers are falling overboard at a rapid rate

supplychainbrain.com

141–150 of 159 posts

Re: Shipping containers are falling overboard at a rapid rate

#141

Earlier quoted context omitted.

My grandfather used to go and salvage (loot?) smashed up ships on the Yorkshire coast after storms as a kid in the early 20th century. They had places they’d go after bad weather, knowing that’s where wrecks ended up.

Thats a very old tradition. Sometimes local traditon encuraged potential salvage, by setting up false lights. edit: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wrecking_(shipwreck) but wikipedia actually says, this might be a urban legend, as there is no clear evidence this ever happened

There's a Japanese novel on the topic, which has a great English translation: "Shipwrecks" by Akira Yoshimura.

https://www.japantimes.co.jp/culture/1999/06/08/books/the-da...

Re: Shipping containers are falling overboard at a rapid rate

#142

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The Box is way more fascinating than it has any right to be. It touches on basically every aspect of post-1950 world economy, history, urban planning, social changes, migration, etc.

On a related note, there is an episode of Connections that ties the width of the early railcar's wheelbase to pretty much all subsequent forms of transportation, ending with modern space exploration capability. Pretty awesome to observe the actual reach of decisions made long ago.

Wasn't it actually Roman carriage wheel spacing that determined rail gauges (and the rest)?

Re: Shipping containers are falling overboard at a rapid rate

#143

Earlier quoted context omitted.

One interesting take I’ve read on that quote is that you need to consider the source. If you’re a general for a country that routinely deploys troops to the other side of the world, in the service that specializes in landing those troops on a hostile beach with no friendly infrastructure, in a milieu when it is no longer considered acceptable to supply your troops by allowing them to pillage the countryside, you are…

It's not just remote deployments where it matters. There is no deployment scenario that is not heavily dependant on logistics. This is more true in protracted land deployments of troops across large distances, not less so. No matter the strategy, logistics must match it or success is significantly more difficult. Take Napoleon w/ Russia, where Napoleon's ambition out ran his logistics. His strategy and tactics had yi…

Sure, but there are circumstances where logistics become more and more challenging, and I’d say Napoleon’s invasion of Russia was another clear case of such a circumstance. The more challenging the logistics are, the more you have to worry about them. American Marines need to worry about logistics a lot, and Napoleon probably should have worried about logistics more than he did in 1812. But, to pick an example off the top of my head, I don’t think the Finns needed to worry about logistics quite as much in 1940; logistics were the least of their challenges.

Re: Shipping containers are falling overboard at a rapid rate

#144

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Selling on eBay is theft. The contents if those containers belongs to someone. You can possibly make a living recovering the container for the owner, but if you don't agree to a price beforehand the lawyers will make a killing in court deciding what you should get.

I would assume the legality depends on where the container fell.

North Korea and a few similar countries. Otherwise all countries recognised some form of law which is things lost at sea are still owned by the person/org that lost it.

Re: Shipping containers are falling overboard at a rapid rate

#145
post #116

Earlier quoted context omitted.

That kind of makes sense, though. The tail risk of something like AWS must to be significant in comparison, so a hefty margin to insure against that seems reasonable. Sale and distribution of things is probably much milder in its variations, and the expenses seem like they'd be more strongly correlated with revenue. (All of this is a speculative attempt at explaining the figures, not an authoritative source on strate…

Why would the tail risk of AWS be so high? Apart from the economic troubles of COVID which increased online buying, normal periodic economic downturn would be expected to hit all retail businesses fairly hard. Amazon's non retail unit AWS grew significantly throughout the 2008-2010 economic downturn.

I don't know. It feels like the demand from complex software systems would fluctuate more wildly than a relatively predictable human consumer base, but I could be way off the mark.

Re: Shipping containers are falling overboard at a rapid rate

#146

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I would assume the legality depends on where the container fell.

North Korea and a few similar countries. Otherwise all countries recognised some form of law which is things lost at sea are still owned by the person/org that lost it.

Oh, interesting, I didn't have a sense of how widespread that was.

I remember this 300-year-old Spanish shipwreck that was dredged up by a private company. The Spanish government then sued and won. They had to give back ~500k coins. https://www.bbc.com/news/world-44302476

I'm not sure how I feel about the outcome. In particular it seems odd that Spain could indefinitely claim ownership, even if they have no intention of recovering the wreck. That being said, I don't strictly believe "finders keepers" applies here either.

Re: Shipping containers are falling overboard at a rapid rate

#147

I see ships being overloaded a good problem to have. The more countries trade with eachother, the less reason they have to fight wars with eachother.

> The more countries trade with eachother, the less reason they have to fight wars with eachother. WW1 pretty much proved that wrong. Europe was trading a lot with each other. That didn't stop all the rivalries from starting up and causing the general "Great Game" feeling between powers. For now, it seems like DEMOCRACY is the best thing to prevent wars. Democracies don't like fighting against other democracies: it s…

The President of the United States, 2 days ago: "We’re in a competition with China and other countries to win the 21st Century."

The leading global purveyor of DEMOCRACY is deeply embedded in the dangerous game you describe

Re: Shipping containers are falling overboard at a rapid rate

#148

Earlier quoted context omitted.

> The more countries trade with eachother, the less reason they have to fight wars with eachother. WW1 pretty much proved that wrong. Europe was trading a lot with each other. That didn't stop all the rivalries from starting up and causing the general "Great Game" feeling between powers. For now, it seems like DEMOCRACY is the best thing to prevent wars. Democracies don't like fighting against other democracies: it s…

The President of the United States, 2 days ago: "We’re in a competition with China and other countries to win the 21st Century." The leading global purveyor of DEMOCRACY is deeply embedded in the dangerous game you describe

I'm not sure if you are aware of the term "Great Game". But it refers to a particular philosophy which has been dead since the early 1900s.

The "Great Game" was a huge reason why WW1 broke out. Back then, social Darwinism was considered a good thing. To win a war and prove that you're superior was honorable. Imperialism was reaching its highest points.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Great_Game

Under the "Great Game" mindset: war between powers was good. War encourages innovation. War encourages progress. Its why World War 1 happened: so many political powers believed that humanity would be advanced by fighting.

Also: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Social_Darwinism

Re: Shipping containers are falling overboard at a rapid rate

#149

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The President of the United States, 2 days ago: "We’re in a competition with China and other countries to win the 21st Century." The leading global purveyor of DEMOCRACY is deeply embedded in the dangerous game you describe

I'm not sure if you are aware of the term "Great Game". But it refers to a particular philosophy which has been dead since the early 1900s. The "Great Game" was a huge reason why WW1 broke out. Back then, social Darwinism was considered a good thing. To win a war and prove that you're superior was honorable. Imperialism was reaching its highest points. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Great_Game Under the "Great Gam…

If there is no longer any desire among the democracies of the world to war against rival nations, why have the leading democratic power and its allies been involved in constant covert and overt warfare for the better part of the last century?

Why are we talking about "winning" the next century if, as you allege, democracy has superseded geopolitical competition?

We may affect more opposition to war in the present day, and we may wage it more subtly, but by no means has it ceased

Re: Shipping containers are falling overboard at a rapid rate

#150

Is there a list of what exactly was lost? Does anyone actively seek out and salvage this sunken treasure? I hate to think of another Garfield Phone thing in the future with something more dangerous. https://time.com/5561165/garfield-phones-france/

Somewhere there is a container full of Amazon Basics Butt Plugs waiting to spill forth its rubbery contents upon unsuspecting American beaches.

Thankyou for the poetry!
Post reply on HN