Live data from Hacker News

The Real Book

99percentinvisible.org

141–143 of 143 posts

Re: The Real Book

#141
post #39
post #4

When I was learning to play the saxophone my instructor had an old copy of the Real Book. The transcriptions of songs by some of the jazz legends would blow my mind. I thought the people being able to transcribe those were geniuses (still do). They had no sophisticated software to help them. It was all done manually by listening to countless hours of recordings over and over again. All those chord changes, harmonies,…

I've spoken to a few professional arrangers, and I always ask "How many times did you have to listen to that to write it down?" "Just once." Genius indeed. Or 10,00 hours. Or both.

Mozart became famous at the age of 14 by transcribing Allegri's Miserere from memory after hearing it performed in the Sistine Chapel. It was a piece of music that had been composed about 150 years earlier, and which was not permitted to be written down or distributed, only to be performed once a year during Holy Week services in the Chapel.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Miserere_(Allegri)

Re: The Real Book

#142

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Jamming over a tune that you don't know is called "faking." That's a skill unto itself. ;-) But I think it's also a skill worth learning.

I've spent a lot of time playing bass on stage with band's I've never rehearsed. I heard a saying the other day you might like... bass players aren't paid to play quickly, they are paid to hear quickly.

Bass players are paid for the plays they note, not the notes they play.

Re: The Real Book

#143

Earlier quoted context omitted.

I just checked since I’ve never heard it played with that Bb7 in bar 4... I’ve got one of the old unlicensed editions and it has the “right” changes, Cm7 / Cm7 / Fm7 / Fm7. Some of the stuff in the legal versions is particularly wonky.

That's very interesting. I've only been playing piano for a few months and I was very surprised/distressed to notice this discrepancy.

There's tons of examples. Check Yardbird Suite by Charlie Parker in the RB, you'll also find a lot of mistakes :)
Post reply on HN