Live data from Hacker News

DJI FPV

dji.com

141–150 of 162 posts

Re: DJI FPV

#141
post #112

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Interesting that it is all sold out too...

DJI seem to have diverted their supply chain from hobbyist FPV to this new drone. Supply for all DJI FPV gear has been very limited ever since they filed the "V2" goggles (for the Drone) with the FCC. I'm hoping they keep their hobbyist/DIY FPV system going though, as it blows everything else out of the water. Analog video is well, bad, open source alternatives are either abandoned or mediocre, and the Divimath/Fat S…

I guess all the things you mention is why they continue to get my money. Bought the drone yesterday to compliment the Air2, which I absolutely love, and can't wait to try it out.

Re: DJI FPV

#143
post #112

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Interesting that it is all sold out too...

DJI seem to have diverted their supply chain from hobbyist FPV to this new drone. Supply for all DJI FPV gear has been very limited ever since they filed the "V2" goggles (for the Drone) with the FCC. I'm hoping they keep their hobbyist/DIY FPV system going though, as it blows everything else out of the water. Analog video is well, bad, open source alternatives are either abandoned or mediocre, and the Divimath/Fat S…

That makes sense though.. they're probably putting initial production of the V2 goggles into the FPV kits, and running out their supply of independent V1 Goggles.

My guess is at some point soon they'll be selling the V2 goggles on their own for the hobby use case.

Re: DJI FPV

#144

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Heh, true. Thanks.

No worries. If there's just one thing I want to get across though, it's that as drone operators, we are collectively responsible for how the broader community views us and drones. Random drones floating through neighborhoods is sketchy from a safety standpoint but also it tends to upset people, who often think that any drone they see is spying on them. Just a consideration. Personally I like to fly around abandoned b…

I'm super cautious like you but one thing about the Mini and Mini 2 is they don't attract much attention. They're really small and pretty darn quiet.

I've had my Mini about a year and have yet to have any interaction with strangers who see it flying.

Re: DJI FPV

#145

Earlier quoted context omitted.

>without investing the time/effort to learn about how to do it better with other setups I do not believe that this is a good thing at all.

Why is gatekeeping FPV drones so important to you? Opening it up to new potential users some of which will want to eventually invest in better setups seems very much like a good thing.

I don't consider it gatekeeping. I consider it responsibility. Low barrier to entry is not always such a good thing. The idiots that would not get into it because of some sort of required training but would get into it without hesitation without training are typically ones that cause the problems for everyone else. There are lots of things in life/society that requires some sort of responsibility. I feel that something you can fly in a manner that you can only see in one direction without fully knowing what else is around you is one of those things. Caveat being designated areas setup and maintained as a UAV operating area.

Re: DJI FPV

#146
post #107

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Recs for a cheap radio that is easy to connect to a pc? I also had the same result when trying to use a gamepad

I haven't personally used these radios but they seem to be highly recommended budget options from people in the know: - BetaFPV LiteRadio 2 - Jumper T-Lite In terms of a pc simulator I have used Velocidrone which everyone says has the most realistic physics but is not necessarily the prettiest. You might also find the following site useful as a shopping guide: - https://www.fpvknowitall.com/fpv-shopping-list-controll…

Thank you!!!

Re: DJI FPV

#147

Earlier quoted context omitted.

Recs for a cheap radio that is easy to connect to a pc? I also had the same result when trying to use a gamepad

After research I went with the Radiomaster TX16s. There are several specs and I went for the mid-range version that has Hall effect gimbals for the sticks. You can get more console controller style radios as well but I fancied the bigger screen and a bit more space.

Thanks!

Re: DJI FPV

#148
post #89

Earlier quoted context omitted.

DJI digital video has been out for quite awhile now for hobbyists to include in their custom builds. Transmission range is not a valid point because a clean analog video signal and Crossfire outpaces DJI enormously. The 20 min flight time is a lie, Joshua Bardwell measured 10 minutes hovering. That's extremely easy to surpass on typical light weight 5 inch freestyle drone with a 1300mah battery that cost a fifth of t…

I think the biggest thing is accessibility. DJI continues to break down the preexisting knowledge required to get into a space. For better or worse, because there's a lot of irresponsible drone flyers as a result too, but this product makes fpv flying much readily available for those who want to try it without investing the time/effort to learn about how to do it better with other setups

> For better or worse, because there's a lot of irresponsible drone flyers as a result too

The industry is doing a horrible job of educating people and, as a result, they are ruining it for everyone else. I have been flying all manner of radio control craft for over thirty years (planes, helicopters, drones and "things"). As a simple example, I would never --ever-- fly anything over people, homes, roads or high fire risk brush areas. I have crashed enough time to understand that that these things are toys that are not designed to the standards of real aircraft, often suffering from multiple single-point failure risks that could bring them down and either hurt someone or cause serious damage to property.

Our neighborhood FB group is, at times (usually around Xmas and people's birthdays) filled with videos from people flying their new drones over roads (as in, directly over cars), over homes, over bone-dry brush surrounding our neighborhoods, over people (crowds, kids, at parks, without anyone knowing), etc.

The other kind of post is "I flew my drone for the first time in front of my house and I lost it". Which, of course, makes me crying at multiple levels. The crash could easily cause a brush fire that could take out an entire neighborhood [0], and, of course, hurt or kill someone [1].

At first I tried to educate people as to the realities of these devices. I own RC helicopters that cost well in excess of $3,000 and I still consider them unsafe toys. Yet people get offended and verbally abusive when you explain that their $300 drone, despite the hype, is a toy that could fall out of the sky at any time and potentially cause great harm. I mean, I have worked on the design of space capsules that are docked at the International Space Station and people are arguing with me about their toys actually being "reliable". Jeez.

It's only a matter of time until a tragedy occurs. Thankfully the large fires caused by drone crashes have, so far, been limited to open areas. One day someone is going to crash a drone into the bushes in a neighborhood, the LiPo is going to rupture and half the neighborhood will burn down. Sadly people seem to value their fun far more than the safety of others.

[0] https://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2018/03/drone-crashes-in...

[1] https://www.theverge.com/2017/2/27/14755116/jail-sentence-dr...

Re: DJI FPV

#149
post #142

Doesn't it make you nauseous like VR?

No, it is no delay 120fps. The sickness induced from VR is primarily when the tracking is bad, then slow refresh rate of display, then screen door effect last. Something like this would make only screen door effect be the factor that makes one sick which is minimal for most.

Re: DJI FPV

#150
post #128

Earlier quoted context omitted.

The product is amazing, but I'm sad that the first amazing integrated fpv product out is coming from DJI. It makes perfect sense, but I hate giving them money as each DJI purchase is a positive reinforcement for their abhorrent approach to consumer privacy. I'll probably get one, but continue to complain loudly online that every DJI product, including the offline ones, requires an account and email address and regist…

Is there a drawback to lying on this registration? One-time email, fake PID, etc.? Assume one doesn't live in PRC...

An excuse to eventually brick your device.
Post reply on HN